
To abstain or to consume? The hermetic perspective on plant based vs animal consumption.
So as of late, this is actually been a dilemma for me because in early March I made a transition to vegetarianism, largely motivated by fitness goals, but the secondary and most strongest support actually came from reading On Abstinence by Porphyry, who’s primary argument as to why animal consumption is unlawful was that animals contain logos, and to eat a creature that contains logos is to violate divine order.
Now, I wasn’t set in stone about his interpretation, but it resonated enough with me to at least draw the conclusion that when it comes to appetite and our human need to fuel our bodies with sustenance, animal consumption ranks as the lowest level of virtue, because the consumption of dead flesh, souped up with spices and herbs signify submission to the fullest satisfaction of our desires, particularly the tormentor of lust.
But then, I was rereading the Stobaean Hermetica, in book 4, which states that non-human animals do not truly contain logos, and that which is mistaken for it is in actuality, instinct, and memory, which are natural animal impulses.
Since processing that, it’s put me in this place where I’m like, well, I can eat meat if I want to, and I really don’t like that place because I’ve been eating really clean, feeling light and strong without animal consumption, and the previous module I was operating under provided a more ontologically rooted restriction that compelled discipline for me that the are awareness of non-human animals not containing logos does not. Full transparency, I wrote this after I was contemplating ordering five guys for the first time in four months 😳for now I’m going to continue exercising continence!
So basically, what I gather is that, eating animals is not an inherently irreverent or disruptive to divine order, but, because of the intensity of desire it signifies, it does represent momentary submission to the tormentor of lust, which it would seem that in pursuit of the highest virtue within us, we should thrive to spiritually grow out of.
What do you all think?