the scholars is overhated
I feel as though The Scholars was VERY criticized upon release especially given the 5 year anticipation of a new album. I do give credit to the critics saying the albums narrative is hard to follow and vocally the album lacks the passion and emotion in comparison to previous projects. and to preface, NO! i am not one of those people who are like “why won’t he just remake another twin fantasy type of album even though he isn’t 19 anymore and is 33 years old BLAH BLAH BLAH.” I will agree very much so that the deep raw emotion depicted in twin fantasy 2018 and all work leading up to it has kind of ran flat in my SUBJECTIVE opinion. that’s really the only thing that struck me as disappointing but considering everything that’s occurred with will since their last album release, can’t really blame him if his whole entire heart and soul wasn’t thrown into this record .
However i think Will’s vocal and production progression over the years has reached its ultimate peak on The Scholars. His vocals throughout the entire album are absolutely BREATHTAKING. I think the track lengths are perfect for what they are. if we’re nitpicking, then the three 10 minute+ track run, back to back to back may make the album feel like it’s dragging on a bit but doesn’t take away from each individual songs performance rating. The in-depth lyrics, chilling guitar riffs, gorgeous and atmospheric vocals/production, beautifully executed pivot to a rock opera genre, all contribute to overcompensating for what lacks on this record whilst pushing this up to a 9/10 album for me.
I originally rated this album between a 9 and a 10 but was open to the idea of that being recency bias. it’s been a bit over a year now since the albums release and i have yet to stop having this album on repeat CONSTANTLY. it has fantastic replay-ability value and my rating has not changed whatsoever. i find more to admire that i hadn’t previously noticed with every listen.
shoutout car seat headrest 🙏