I Built You a Tower feels like a proper Death Cab record for the first time since the Walla era
Okay so sort of clickbaity title but I do need to specify up front: I liked TYFT and Asphalt Meadows; there was just something about them that didn’t quite feel like the Death Cab I knew (because it wasn’t). This is expected and understandable when you make such a drastic change to a band lineup.
Ben’s lyrics have stayed consistently great, and the songwriting never faltered, but the instrumentation and mixing fell a bit flat for me at times on the last few records. I’ve seen them live on every tour since Chris left, and they have never failed to put on an incredible show - but the studio albums never made it into my heavy rotation the way that Walla’s did.
That being said, I Built You a Tower is scratching that “old Death Cab” itch for me, while still feeling really fresh. It feels like they finally took the training wheels off of Dave + Zach and let them properly cook. Jason and Nick are absolutely on fire on this record as well, and everything feels to truly click behind Ben for the first time.
Punching the Flowers hits on a Photo Album vibe with the punchy and aggressive drum part and busy tapping on the guitars. Pep Talk would feel right at home on Plans or Codes. Envy the Birds moving time signatures and dissonant chord progressions feel like Narrow Stairs.
I could almost feel where each song pulled its inspiration from, but none of them felt like rehashes of old songs.
The true peak of the album for me though, is How Heavenly a State. This song fucks. This is where I feel like everything comes together and every single member of the band comes together to say “this is us now. Get on board or get out of the way.”
I’m on board.
This is my favorite Death Cab record since Kintsugi, and I genuinely think it’s going to keep working its way up my rankings even higher - which I never thought I’d say as a Walla fanboy.
Anyway, I just wanted to ramble about how much I am enjoying this record. Let me know how you all are feeling!