r/AgathaAllAlong

I finally watched and I have to say I enjoyed it very much, I liked the witches and their journey until the ending. just threw it all away, with “it was Agatha and Billy all along”. It makes sense given wandavision I suppose, but the more I think about it, the less sense it makes and more plot holes I poke in it. Especially Agatha’s motivations and her backstory. It raised way more questions than it answered, and I doubt we’ll get them all answered in vision quest, as the focus will be on vision,ultron, and Tommy.

How did Agatha get the darkhold? did she steal her covens powers before or after she had the baby? Couldn’t she have just offered herself to rio instead of Nicholas like she did with Billy?

It’s implied she steals witches powers to feed Nicholas and keep him alive, so why does she continue after he’s gone? corrupted by the darkhold? Only we don’t know the timeline of when she actually got it.

The witches road has been a long con by Agatha for hundreds of years and no other witches have ever caught on. They just know nobody has “survived” but Agatha. She gathers up her coven again this time in hope of stealing their powers (it is revealed at the end) but they’re all powerless…? What was she planning on steal there exactly? Maybe Billy’s powers, because if anything, he gave the witches back their powers on “the road”.

How did the Salem 7 get into the world Billy created?

If Agatha’s plan was to steal Billy’s powers all along and suspected they were in something he conjured up, why was she so worried about him? She suspected his identity from the beginning. Why was Billy so loyal to her?? This kid knew he was actually Billy maximoff, and ran straight to the woman his mom imprisoned? Billy needs something from her, “the witches road” but he trusts her implicitly despite her reputation. Agatha is soft on Billy because he reminds her of Nicholas. Yet when she dies, instead of being with him in the afterlife, she comes back as a ghost to follow Billy around?

Should’ve just ended at Billy realized he’d made up the road cause phew that ending was messy. Please don’t downvote me to hell, I genuinely enjoyed the show but hated all the plot holes and ending.

Hii Everyone!!!

In honor of VisionQuest coming out, I want to know people’s theories on whether or not you think Agatha, Wanda, or Rio will deadass show up in Vision Quest!!

I’m unsure how Marvel is going right now, I recently watched Spider-man and I know they’re introducing the young avengers!!! I’m a firm believer that Agatha will try to get her body back, but I want to hear real Marvel fans opinions!!!! (I’m a Marvel fan, but only in Wanda/Agatha terms😭😭😭)

I'm rewatching the show in preparation for Vision Quest, and it made me think.

When it comes to the Witches' Road>!scam,!<Agatha was only shown killing witches that attacked her first. This is the same with her original coven as well (mind you her crimes were literally just learning magic "above her station" and practicing dark magic like... she wasn't even a serial killer atp it can't have been that serious).

A belief that stemmed from her trauma was reinforced for her whole life. So it's no surprise that Agatha continued killing witches for so long and didn't bother being part of a coven. In every instance they try to KILL her just because she ragebaited them over the road not opening.

This is why despite her being a villain I don't count those deaths "against" her because wtf was their problem??

Do you guys have new thoughts on the show? Am I stupid?

Sorry if this has been asked before but I’m doing a rewatch. Was Rio really there in there in the first episode or was it Agatha’s imagination?

If she was truly present was she seeing Agatha’s perspective from the spell she was trapped in it was Rio seeing reality like Billy was?

I love the Back Home Ballers song from SNL so much. I was listening to that song again and I love that Sasheer is part of it. I discovered her through Agatha All Along and it's been really fun watching her SNL sketches.

Before Lilia dies she tells Agatha something along the line of 'hit the ground when rio says coward'… but that scene happened after Lilia‘s death aka she would not have experienced it as part of her out of order lifespan. So how did she know to tell Agatha what to do?

Why was Jen purported to be 'the way forward' and made to seem like she’d play a huge part in something and then not even really appear in the finale. I felt like I missed something.

How did they know Agatha was the witch who bound Jen in Boston? just because she was somewhere in the vicinity of Boston at the time? Surely there’s many other witches living in that area especially considering near westview there were 3 alone.

Hey everyone! I've got an interesting theory with VisionQuest coming out - and I've been doing a bit of a deep dive cos I'm a bit of a nerd, and I think i've got near enough proof positive that Kathryn Hahn and Joe Locke filmed for VisionQuest, and the timeline itself is near enough proof of that.

So - let's get into it!

Vision Quest / Joe Locke / Kathryn Hahn timeline:

March 2025 — VisionQuest begins filming in London

• VisionQuest began principal photography at Pinewood Studios in London in March 2025.
• Location filming also took place around London.
• Production ultimately wrapped in late July 2025, with some completion work continuing into August.

Spring–Summer 2025 — Joe Locke is in London

• Joe Locke was in London for his West End commitments surrounding Clarkston. The production was at the Trafalgar Theatre, with Ruaridh Mollica in the cast as well.
• This is particularly interesting because Mollica was simultaneously involved with VisionQuest as Tommy.

July 15, 2025 — Kathryn Hahn is publicly confirmed to be in Dublin

• Following the Emmy nominations, Hahn said she was “currently in Dublin”, celebrating the nomination with a pint.
• This establishes that she was physically in Ireland on July 15 — but doesn't establish that she remained there for the rest of July.

Late July 2025 — VisionQuest wraps

• Production reportedly wrapped toward the end of July, making this an especially interesting window if additional scenes involving returning MCU characters were being filmed

So - you might be asking - what does all of this potentially prove?

Not that Kathryn Hahn definitely filmed VisionQuest — we don't have that confirmation yet.

What it DOES show is that the timeline for an Agatha / Billy cameo, or even substantial scene filming works.

Kathryn was in Dublin on July 15. VisionQuest was still filming in the UK toward the end of July. Joe Locke was already in London, and reports point to Billy and Tommy material being filmed. There is nothing publicly known that prevents Kathryn from having travelled from Dublin to London and filmed during that window.

And if the finale contains a significant Agatha appearance, rather than a brief cameo, the fact that Kathryn was already in the UK/Ireland region during the final stretch of production becomes particularly interesting.

None of these clues is definitive on its own.

But together, they create a timeline in which Kathryn Hahn appearing in VisionQuest is not only possible — it is completely compatible with what we know about the production.

Am I doing too much analysis here? Or do you think they'll be back too? Let me know!

Its October, i wanna dress witchy and fun. Do yall have any day to day/not fully cosplay outfits based on agatha and Rio? Share inspooooo!!! Love you all and thank you in advance 🖤💜💚