
Bring back the SATs
I'm returning to college after a few years and I have a less than perfect academic history, but I think I could do well on the SATs because I did at the past. Recently I spoke to someone at a selective school and asked about the SATs. They told me the only thing the SATs would prove is that I survived a patriarchal capitalist society, and they do not even consider the SATs at all for conventional college age students.
I have ADHD and I have never done well on consistent everyday work like homework. Especially in high school where homework is often pointless and you don't have a lot of freedom, I perform better in classes I choose myself. However even if I don't do all the homework I can learn and do well on tests so I feel like tests are the easiest and most efficient way to prove I am intelligent. Especially in the current era with rampant cheating, socially normalized scam artistry, AI use, grade inflation and ever-increasing illiteracy, I would think testing would be extra useful in a time like this, yet it has less institutional support than ever.
They defend these decisions by pointing to economic and racial disparity in test scores, but no school in the past admitted students entirely based on test scores and nothing else. They would look at your cultural context and say "this student didn't get a great SAT score, but they got one of the top scores in their high school so we will admit them." Studies show SATs pretty reliably predict future performance, see this NYT article.
"Holistic admissions" apparently means you're supposed to do a bunch of extracurriculars which the average public school kid has limited access to, so it's not at all more equitable than the SATs are.
I'm gonna put on my conspiracy theory hat and wonder if this is intentional. Did they get rid of the SATs because they are actually trying to exclude students who aren't already elite, under the guise of progressivism? It's easier for them to admit students who appear visibly different by having a different skin color but still have an upper middle class or higher upbringing. It would be more work for a school to integrate students who are intelligent but from genuinely underprivileged backgrounds, not to mention supporting those students financially in an age of budget cuts.
Edit: Since it keeps coming up, I'm not opposed to test-optional schools. I'm opposed to schools that refuse to consider the SATs at all even slightly because we apparently need to dismantle capitalism before anything means anything.