r/CommanderMTG

Ive made a red thorin, the mountain king deck as red and white, is that allowed? Am a little confused, hes mono red so would that mean i cant play white cards?

Hi I'm new-ish to magic and commander. I've played a handful of games and generally understand how to play. I really want to make a viable rat deck. One of the commanders is [Karumonix, The Rat King], which adds toxic 1 to all rats.

Will I be beaten up if I did that? We generally try not to make decks that make the game unfun (like a deck that just counters every spell you cast so you're just not playing). How is your experience going against poison? Do you hate it? Or is it only as annoying as any other normal deck?

If it is too unfun, what rat commander would you recommend? We like to stay in (what I understand as) bracket 2 and 3

Hello everybody,

I'm thinking about making new commander deck in esper colors that is based on enchantments.
My picks so far:
[[aminatou, veil piercer]]
[[The Master of Keys]]
[[Alela, Artful Provacateur]]

My main goal is to make it as fun as possible and 2-3 bracket kind of deck.

Would be great to hear your experiance with those commanders. Maybe you have better idea regarding commander that is also esper enchantment based - I would also like to hear those as well.

Commander: Tasha, The Witch Queen

14x swamps

9x Islands

Hidden Cataract

Soured Swamp

Captivating Cave

Sinister Hideout

Dismal Backwater

Jidoor, Aristocratic Capital

Adventurer's Inn

Thriving Isle

Theorix Annex

Lotus Ring

Quick Draw Katana

Lazarus, Familiar Stranger

Sephiroth's Intervention

Morbius the Living Vampire

Untamed Hunger

Mortus Strider

Consuming Aberration

Emet-Selch, Unsundered

Skullcap snail

Death baron

Qutrub Forayer

Oathsworn Knight

Zulu Ashur, Rich Lord

Phylactery Lich

Abysmal Harvester

Boneyard Desecrator

Overzealous Muscle

Soul-Shackled Zombie

Mabel, Bitter Recluse

Danish, Spear of Agony

Corrupted Conviction

Get out

Aggressive Negotiations

Brineborn Cutthroat

Aetherize

Stab Wound

Chandra, Chill of Compliance

Fake Your Own Death

Enter the Enigma

Spectral Sailor

Unlikely Aid

Negate

Offer Immortality

Loan Shark

Pitiless Carnage

Spider-Man No More

OverKill

Siren of the Fanged Coast

Common Courtesy

Tithing Blade

Clinquant Skymage

Sadistic Glee

Amazing Acrobatics

Combat Tutorial

Gruesome Menagerie

Expedition Lookout

Swallowed by the Leviathan

Wake the Dead

Veteran ice climber

Essence Capture

Break Under Pressure

Naga Fleshcrafter

Rite of Replication

Silence the Echo

Fog bank

Rise from the Tides

Damnable Pact

Mocking Sprite

Mind Funeral

Rise of the Dark Realms

Louisoix's Sacrifice

Helmet of the Ghastlord

Army of the Damned

Icy Reception

Foggy Swamp Spirit Keeper

Damnation

There are so many brands, but I want to know which ones are the best for durability and shuffle feel. I'm stuck between Ultra Pro, Dragon Shield, Gamegenics, and Ultimate Guard.

Help!! T_T

I’m trying to build a toolbox/stax/combo deck and I’ve heard that combo takes away from the toolbox element of a deck but I’m pretty determined to make it work. How do I make these two strategies work together in a fun way?(fun for me not my opponents because this is a stax deck we’re talkin about here)

So I just recently got The Ur-Sphinx from a friend and want to build a commander deck around it that’s primarily kindred and focuses on scry/surveil, and making opponents mill. I currently have a WIP deck list that has around 150 cards and that I need to cut down. But while I figure that out, I wanted to ask the community for advice on good cards with those effects to put in the deck.

PSA: this is going to be my ONLY Esper deck and my ONLY eminence deck (never got Ur-Dragon or Edgar Markov).