r/CommanderMTG

I'm building a treasure and piracy deck

I'm building a treasure and piracy deck

Are there any effective and/or lesser known cards I should look for that would be on theme with theft and treasures for Locke?

u/LoneFajita47 — 11 hours ago
▲ 2 r/CommanderMTG+1 crossposts

Ozai, the phoenix king.

Wanting to build a commander deck using Ozai, below is the list I have so far. What other cards would you add?

Aggravated Assault
Ashling, Flame Dancer
Avatar Roku, Firebender
Deflecting Swat
Diabolic Intent
Dolmen Gate
Doubling Cube
Dualcaster Mage
Electro, Assaulting Battery
Embercleave
Fiery Emancipation
Gratuitous Violence
Insatiable Avarice
Jeska’s Will
Koh, the Face Stealer
Mana Geyser
Moraug, Fury of Akoum
Neheb, Dreadhorde Champion
Rogue’s Passage
Savage Beating
Secret Tunnel
Seething Song
Twinflame Tyrant
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
Valakut, the Molten Pinnacle
Vampiric Tutor

u/ParsnipNo4531 — 12 hours ago
▲ 19 r/CommanderMTG+1 crossposts

Help with deck

I want to make a unique loot deck that doesn’t fully rely on EDHrec. Also trying not to drop like $500 on a deck but would consider it. I understand how the game works just not the greatest at building decks. Any suggestions for cards or strategies would be greatly appreciated.

▲ 4 r/CommanderMTG+1 crossposts

Birthing/Death (redeathing ? reanimating ?) Pod in Sultai

I'm trying to build this creature focused tool box-y kind of list in sultai colors that centers around ultimately trying to get either [[Colossal Grave-Reaver]] or [[Summon: Bahamut]] on the board, or just filling the grave and then going for a [[Living Death]] for the win. I like the idea of having the grave be a second hand while also having cards like [[Birthing Pod]], [[Sidisi, Regent of the Mire]], or even [[Cauldron of Essence]] act as sort of the hidden commander(s) that are enabling the deck. I'm not necessarily trying to win with a combo, more so just overwhelming the board state or having Bahamut survive long enough for his thermonuclear blast to laser beam the other players. That being said, I want this deck to be able to survive in a strong bracket 3 pod.

There have been a couple of problems I'm running into though. Firstly, I think birthing pod might be a little redundant. Or rather, it is sort of rendered useless if I start milling like crazy. Though there are some times where I don't get many cards that mill in the early game which is where birthing pod sort of comes in clutch. I like that both Sidisi and birthing pod are asking you to build the same in terms of curving out on creatures, but I wonder if its better to go for more cards like Sidisi, the cauldron, and [[Hell's Caretaker]] and forget the pod all together.

Another issue I have is finding early game plays. A lot of the times, my opening hands are less than ideal for turns 1-3. This is in part due to the fact that I don't have very many one drop creatures, but I just couldn't find many that were super worth it. [[Stitcher's Supplier]] and [[Hedron Crab]] were obvious choices, but it kind of falls of from there. That also leans into another problem, where I have so few blue pips and blue lands in my deck because of how golgari based it is, but at the same time early game cards like the crab, [[Gran-Gran]], [[Careful Study]], and others are blue spells.

Finally, I'm also looking for feedback on the commander and color identity as a whole. I like the idea of sultai because it gives me that boggy, marshy, creature from the black lagoon kind of vibe, but I also feel like I'm just looking for justifications to splash blue. I'm not super comitted to [[The Master, Transcendent]] either, he just seemed like the best fit for the 99 since he is repeatable recursion as long as I'm milling

Overall, I think the deck needs smoothing out in terms of getting it online faster and the mana base. I play with my friends mostly over spell table, so out of budget cards are an option to consider ! Budget friendly options are great too, especially for the mana base if I wanted wanted to try and make this in paper.

Thanks in advance for the feedback !

https://archidekt.com/decks/22722117/swamp_bitch_v2

u/Apt213_ — 1 day ago

Advices needed on a bracket 2 Yuriko deck

https://preview.redd.it/1baw3g43m92h1.png?width=1200&format=png&auto=webp&s=707918777f7acd2a8d1ce64064db1b3376354479

[EDIT] : From the feedback I've got so far, this is going to stay in reserve and is getting marked as a high B3/B4 deck. I've got a lot to learn about powerlevels, thanks to the people who helped !

Hello all. First post and an account created specifically for my first paper commander deck.

First of all, yes, I know, the best advice would be "Don't play Yuriko in bracket 2". But I really want to try to make it work and - hopefully - make a deck that is not a complete nightmare to play against at a somewhat reasonnable price (<200€)

My idea is the following : what if I made a Yuriko deck but without any topdeck manipulation ? It would still be an aggressive and dangerous pile but hopefully it would feel less frustrating ?

Anyway, the full decklist is in the link below, any advice and constructive critisism is more than welcome 😄

The link : https://archidekt.com/decks/22698685/yuffie_commander_project

reddit.com
u/Desk-Napper — 1 day ago

What bracket is my deck?

I'm pretty sure my deck is bracket 3 AT MOST I could see it being is bracket 4 but I feel like that's only if I get super lucky. I was hoping to get more opinions from people who will have more experience than me https://moxfield.com/decks/9y9U5Oa80UejpGa20agn9A (If this isn't allowed in the subreddit I'm sorry)

u/OddBird4731 — 2 days ago
▲ 5 r/CommanderMTG+2 crossposts

B3 Bello that can handle a bit low B4

Hello,

I'm thinking about adding some cards to my bello decklist, using the tags on moxfield you can see which cards i'm hesitant to add.

I want to know which would be good to add and which would be good to cut.

I'm on a low budget so i'm not going to spend more that 5 to 8€ on a card.

here's the decklist : https://moxfield.com/decks/lKLXgVzQYEOdGYh1pRyofQ

I would also be very curious about which bracket you think the deck already is !

PS : english is not my language so excuse me for any typos

u/ZarteK974 — 3 days ago
▲ 29 r/CommanderMTG+1 crossposts

i built a zacama deck that uses airbending to generate insane value

hey everyone!

Have you ever made the mistake of playing an incredibly powerful card with an amazing ETB, flickering it to get some bonus value and then realising that it requires you to cast the card to get the effect. Whomp-whomp.

Well, thanks to the Avatar set, we can fix that issue! And today I've got a deck that lets us play weather-wizard with a three-headed dinosaur for incredible value.

Decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/WBW8LCEwp0KtT9uyzmWhwg

Deck showcase video: https://youtu.be/pRVrFXAqlx0

[[Zacama, Primal Calamity]]] is a classic Naya commander and is already known for the [[Temur Sabertooth]] combo; letting you untap your lands on cast, then return it to your hand with the Sabertooth and then cast it again netting you infinite mana.

And while that's fiiiiine, did you know you can also do it with airbending? The rules for airbending read that you exile a card, and then it's owner can cast it from exile for {2}. This means we can get our cast triggers all over again without needing to pay the nine (or more!) mana for Zacama.

There are plenty of airbending options to choose from. [[Airbender's Ascension]], [[Appa, Steadfast Guardian]] and [[Aang, Airbending Master]] to name a few. These'll also all give you bonuses too when you cast stuff from exile such as a 1/1 army or a bunch of experience counters!

The best airbending card though? [[Monk Gyatso]]. I think we all already knew this. He's basically mono-white Nadu, but if you cast Zacama, untap your lands, and then target Zacama with it's own ability to deal 3 damage while Gyatso is on the board, he'll get airbended and you can cast him again to do the loop all over again. Once you've done this enough times, you'll have infinite mana to pour into his other abilities to wipe the board of creatures, enchantments and artifacts and gain unlimited life!

But Zacama isn't the only card with a cool cast trigger. [[Kozilek, Butcher of Truth]] gets your four cards, [[Vibrance]] bolts anything, [[Herigast, Erupting Nullkite]] let's you churn through your library and [[The One Ring]] gives you protection from everything!

Once you've got the engine running, airbending means you can basically cheat your way through the game at your opponent's expense and it's a fun twist on a well-known combo.

Let me know your thoughts! Would love to know what you have to say, and if you'd like, feel free to check out the decklist and showcase video.

Check out the decklist: https://moxfield.com/decks/WBW8LCEwp0KtT9uyzmWhwg

And the showcase video: https://youtu.be/pRVrFXAqlx0

u/Thalizar — 3 days ago
▲ 0 r/CommanderMTG+1 crossposts

Looking for a fun deck to loose with

Hello,

I play Magic since 2014, standard at the beginning, then took a break and came back 5 years ago to play mainly commander and a bit of limited.

Long story short, I play with 4 of my best friends for the last 2 years and two of them play ... Sub optimaly to say the least. I spent a lot of time advising them on deckbuilding, on threath assessing, even on "read the card until the end please" but I still win "too much" and I understand it's frustrating, especially for one of them, so I'm looking for solutions.

Swapping decks is not a real solution because everybody wants to play their deck. I verified with my two other pods if I tend to underestimate my decks, it seems that I don't. Sometimes I play upgraded precon vs stronger decks, but in these cases it isn't fun for me.

So I had an idea, why not build a deck to loose with fun ? Sort of a group hug deck, which is not really my kind of archetype, so I came here to get some ideas !

And if some of you :

-had to deal with a player frustrated because they don't win

-have been in my position

-have some feedback that could help me

your experience is welcome too 😊

reddit.com
u/GoldoLeDoux — 3 days ago
▲ 6 r/CommanderMTG+2 crossposts

I’m starting to make Commander proxy decks — looking for theme inspiration!

I’m starting to create Commander proxy decks and I’m looking for inspiration for themes, not card requests.

I’d love to hear what kind of styles, series, movies, aesthetics, or concepts you enjoy the most.

If you want to share ideas, feel free to tell me:

  • A theme (series, movie, character, style, etc.)
  • A commander that fits the vibe

I’m not requesting specific cards — just looking for creative inspiration. Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Past-Might-5932 — 3 days ago

I need help building a deck of Adrix and Nev, Twincasters

Hi!
I want to build a Commander deck with Adrix and Nev, the Twin Conjurers, but it always seems a bit clunky .

If you've already built a deck with this commander, I'd love to see your list and some recommendations.

My decklist (with some extra cards because I'm still building it): https://moxfield.com/decks/oRULxOX8qkieVrrC9M8xcQ

u/FilipePato — 4 days ago

Witherbloom pestilence precon upgrades

Hey I just got myself a witherbloom deck with my commander being Dina what cards should I remove from the precon already and what should I replace them with I feel like Jo one really has a clear answer lol I need some help. Also I got like every golgari staple from strixhaven that I added already to the deck which ones are the best ones to use ? What pest creators can I add and how can I make even more ?

reddit.com
u/Massive_Instance_554 — 3 days ago

Which deck would you put “The One Ring In”

Commanders are;

  1. Atraxa (Proliferate)
  2. Urza, Chief Artificer (Artifact Swarm)
  3. Zhulodok (Cascade)
  4. Valgavoth, Harrower of Souls (Wheel/Chaos)
  5. Zimone (Landfall)
  6. Bello (Artifact and enchantment)
  7. Elivere (Voltron aura)
u/Over_Leave — 5 days ago