410 replies from contacting people who comment/like my competitors posts
Hey guys, we just wrapped one of our best performing outreach campaigns. 410 replies, 300+ positive, over around 30 days.
The reason I can share the full breakdown is that we ended the campaign. We changed our offer, so the sequence is dead and there's nothing to protect. Everything below is exactly how we ran it.
Results
- 4,860 leads scraped from post likers on competitor content about LinkedIn outreach
- 2,484 of them matched our ICP
- 2,058 connection requests sent
- 1,259 accepted (61% acceptance rate)
- 410 total replies, 300+ positive
Sequence overview
The sequence had four steps.
- If Connected (condition)
- ICP Scoring/lead qualification (condition)
- Send connection request (action)
- Send message (action)
Here's how each one worked.
Step 1: Filter out existing connections + ICP scoring
The first node checked whether the sender was already connected with the lead.
- If connected: stop the sequence (117 leads removed)
- If not connected: continue (4,723 leads remaining)
After that, every remaining lead went through an ICP scoring step before we sent a single connection request.
Our ICP is broad so we just used "Founder, owner, CEO, SDR, GTM expert, or Executive". Anyone that didn't matched that were removed from the workflow. We used a built in AI feature for this.
Out of 4,723 leads, 2,484 leads matched our ICP. That's the pool we actually contacted.
Step 2: The connection request (blank)
We sent every connection request with no note. I don't believe in connection notes. It mostly comes down to number of mutual connections, your profile picture, and your headline. Sometimes the location matters as well (mainly when targeting the US market).
Our acceptance rate was 61%, meaning 1,259 accepted out of 2,058.
The acceptance rate was consistent across all LinkedIn senders, regardless of follower count and gender.
Step 3: The message
After someone accepted, we waited 15 minutes and sent this:
>
What made it work was the anchor. Instantly and Smartlead are tools people in this space already know. Saying "like that, but for LinkedIn" gives them an instant frame of reference without needing a long explanation.
When leads responded positively, we just sent them a link to our AppSumo page. I don't have the exact conversion metrics for this, but our AppSumo campaign generated over $500K in gross sales and I have confirmed that $25K came from this campaign, but it is likely a lot more than that.
The setup
- We used 7 LinkedIn accounts, all human verified.
- 4 accounts had under 200 connections when we launched the campaign.
- 80 connection requests per day in total across all accounts, Monday to Friday
- Around 12 connection requests per account per day
- The same accounts were running other campaigns at the same time, this was not a dedicated setup
- No formal warm-up period before the campaign started
Account safety
We got zero restrictions on the campaign accounts across 45 days.
The accounts belonged to my girlfriend, friends, and team members. Most of them started from zero connections around 6 months ago and were built up organically before we used them for outreach.
One thing worth being transparent about: my personal account and our two founder accounts did get banned. That had nothing to do with the campaign or the tool we used. Our company breaks LinkedIn's terms of service at the platform level, the same reason Heyreach got banned earlier this year. Every other account we used is still active.
If you're running outreach through your own account or a client's account without that kind of platform-level exposure, the risk profile looks very different.
Happy to answer questions on any part of this. Drop them below.