r/PrintedCircuitBoard

Image 1 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 2 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 3 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 4 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 5 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 6 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board
Image 7 — Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board

Review Request - Car Power Antenna Driver Board

I'm needing to replace the burnt driver board of my vintage car's auto extending antenna. The antenna is triggered to extend whenever the car radio turns on, and retract whenever it turns off. This is via a 12V signal out of the back of the radio.

Rather than using a microcontroller solution, I thought I'd take some inspiration from the original driver board and build it using mostly discrete components. See the last photo for the schematic of the original circuit.

The original board used a timer to turn on the extension motor for a duration of ~12s (roughly the time it takes for the antenna to fully extend or retract), and also a PTC thermistor to detect overheating and shut off the motor.

I kept the timer idea in my circuit as a backup, but replaced the PTC thermistor with a stall current detector that shuts the motor off right when the antenna reaches an endpoint. An additional timer is used to prevent the stall detector from triggering for the duration of motor inrush current.

For simplicity and efficiency improvements, the original bjt h-bridge is replaced with a discrete mosfet h-bridge.

I know a circuit like this could be much easier implemented with a microcontroller and a modern integrated h-bridge IC, but I wanted the challenge of a discrete analog/digital design.

Please provide any suggestions to improve the simplicity of the circuit or to the pcb layout!

u/jighris — 5 days ago

[Review Request] MSPM0L1304SDG20 - based minimalist development board Schematic & 2-layer PCB Design

Uploading images of both layers of PCB design along with board schematics. Please point out mistake which may interfere with basic board functionality. Planning to submit this design to a PCB manufacturing house in a week.
Please let me know if I should upload any more details which might ease the review process and might help improve my design. Thank you.

u/alphabern_05 — 6 days ago

Review request - ESP32-C3 battery powered air sensor + oled screen

Hi, I'm a trying to build small projects to train myself in electronics and would appreciate if someone could give me advice on my work.

The board would be powered with a 800mah Lipo battery when not plugged in to an usb-c charger. I added a physical switch to select what mode of power I want to use on the board. The oled screen is a classic 096 led screen that can be added on top of the board.
The board is 45*45mm.

Any critique is welcome thanks in advance!

u/Darmonior — 6 days ago

[LAYOUT REQUEST] 4x USB-C Designs with Production ready protections: Which one would you keep?

From left to right: A, B, C, D.

Hello everyone! It's me again with another weird request.

My first PCB design is progressing well, I'm super proud of myself.

Yes, I design my pcb just like my schematic Hahahah, but dw: I'll stitch them up on the final pass and reoptimized the layouts.

However I went back to the USB-C block and still can't decide on the "best" version of this block.

Please read this:

  • My Requirements are : 5-15v, up to 3A. POWER ONLY
  • It's a 6 pin USB C with CC1/CC2 for negotiating PD with a TPS25730D
  • Fuse is included along TVS 2200 underneat, Caps and ESD762.
  • The ultimate goal is to reuse that block accross many simple projects.

The only difference between these designs is the layout placement.

My question is simple: What is the best one?

I'd personnally go for C/D (mirrors) then A then B.

Thank you <3

u/THE_HEXAGONE — 14 days ago