Open relationship: strong romantic bond, but sex is blocked between us while he wants to explore sexually elsewhere
I’m 25F and my partner is 39M. We met on FetLife last September. We both had recently come out of relationships and things moved very quickly. I was actually the one who wanted openness/non-monogamy at the beginning, because I had just left a relationship where I felt restricted.
Over time, the connection became much more serious and emotional. We spend a lot of time together, cuddle, play games, go dancing, share daily life and I do believe we love each other. When things are good, I feel very loved and cherished.
But we also have a difficult emotional dynamic. I have anxious attachment tendencies and get triggered by uncertainty, other women, inconsistent reassurance and feeling like I’m not special. He is very freedom-oriented and does not like feeling restricted. I need more emotional reassurance and consistency than he naturally gives, while he needs spontaneity and autonomy.
We are both on FetLife/Joyclub and the relationship is open. I have also met other people, including sexual/kinky dates, so I’m not against openness in general.
One issue is his ex. They broke up shortly before we got together and in the beginning he was not fully honest with her about me existing. She only found out about me later. Recently she stayed over at his place while I was there. I was polite and even made food for her, but the situation felt weird and afterwards she said things about me that were not true. He defended me, which I appreciate, but they still text every day and talk on the phone a lot. I’m not necessarily afraid he’ll go back to her, but it feels emotionally messy.
The biggest issue is sex.
In the beginning our sexual/kinky connection was amazing. That was honestly a big reason I started seeing him. We had chemistry, intensity, kink, desire and fun.
Now we haven’t had proper sex in about two months. He says he is not aroused because of stress and pressure in the relationship. He still likes being with me romantically: cuddling, spending time, sharing life but sexually he feels blocked with me.
At the same time, he hopes that swinger parties, couples or other women might help him get aroused again because of novelty and the unknown. He says at home with me, the situation does not awaken arousal and doing sexual things without arousal feels weird to him.
This is where I struggle. From my perspective, it feels painful that our sexual connection is blocked but outside sexual experiences are still treated as possible or exciting. I don’t want to be the romantic/home base while sexual energy is searched for elsewhere. I feel like openness feels safer when the base between the couple is stable including sexually.
Recently he did try some sexual things with me again, like spanking and fingering and it felt good. But he wasn’t really aroused and I feel like he is doing it for me rather than because he is genuinely into it. That makes me sad because I miss the sexual connection we had in the beginning.
I also know I can spiral by asking too many details about other women, texts, or parties. One question leads to another and then I get emotionally overwhelmed. So part of me thinks I should stop asking for details. But another part worries that I’m just avoiding reality.
My questions are: • Is it reasonable to want our own sexual connection to feel more stable before outside sexual exploration becomes a bigger focus? • Can an open relationship work if the romantic bond is strong but sex between the couple is currently blocked? • How do you handle it when one partner’s arousal seems tied to novelty/outside situations, while the other partner wants sexual connection inside the relationship too? • Is this something that can improve with less pressure and better boundaries, or does it sound like a fundamental mismatch?
I don’t want to force him into sex. I don’t want duty-sex. But I also don’t want to feel sexually left out of my own relationship.