r/TheHalloweenMovies

It dawned on me how influenced Rob Zombie’s Halloween movies are by Halloween II and how he established the sibling thing in his first movie at the very beginning. It just speaks to how heavily embedded the whole “Michael and Laurie are siblings” thing had been within the cultural zeitgeist for so long that I think many people assume it was something they established within the first movie and not the sequel. Also the hospital dream sequence from his Halloween II could be seen as a reference/homage to Halloween II (1981) but i’m not sure if that was confirmed

Halloween (1978) is untouchable but Halloween II has been a hugely influential film within the franchise (for better or for worse.) 4,5,6, H20, Resurrection, RZH and RZH2 all build off of it and Halloween (2018) retcons it but there are still many references to it in that movie and especially Halloween Kills

View Poll

View Poll

View Poll

I've always thought one of the biggest strengths of the Halloween franchise is also one of its biggest weaknesses. There are so many different timelines, versions of Michael Myers, and conflicting continuities.

Instead of trying to pick one timeline as the "correct" one, what if a movie embraced all of them as urban legends?

The setup would be simple: On Mischief Night, a group of teenagers break into the abandoned Myers house. While hanging out inside, they begin telling stories about Michael Myers. Each kid has their own version of the legend, and each story is presented as a segment of the film.

The twist is that the real Michael Myers is secretly in the house with them, listening as they retell his history...

Story #1: "I Saw the Boogeyman"

A side story set during the events of the original 1978 film.

An elderly Haddonfield resident claims they saw Michael multiple times on the night he stalked Laurie Strode. Not as the main victim, but as an eyewitness who kept noticing him lurking throughout town.

Michael is seen, standing beneath streetlights.

Watching from behind hedges. Appearing in backyards. Walking unnoticed through neighborhoods.

The story reinforces the idea that Michael wasn't just hunting Laurie that night. He was everywhere.

This would be pure 1978 Carpenter era Myers.

Story #2: "Bloodlines"

A story inspired by the Jamie Lloyd / Halloween 4-6 timeline.

In this version, Jamie survived and eventually grew up, but instead of having biological children, she adopted kids. Years later, Michael returns. The question is now, If Michael is driven by bloodline and family, would adopted children matter to him? Would he still feel compelled to kill? Or was the entire bloodline theory misunderstood from the start?

The story would lean heavily into the mystery surrounding Michael's motivations.

At the end of the story, the other kids immediately call BS because the storyteller somehow knows way too many personal details that nobody should realistically know.

Story #3: "The White Shape"

A completely original Michael Myers story.

A massive October blizzard hits Haddonfield.

Roads are impassable. Power is failing.

Residents are trapped inside their homes.

Somewhere in the storm, Michael Myers is moving through the snow.

The visual possibilities alone would be incredible. Michael emerging through whiteout conditions. Footprints appearing outside frozen windows. His silhouette standing motionless during a snowfall. Blood staining fresh snow.

Victims isolated because nobody can reach them.

We've seen Michael on Halloween night countless times. We've never really seen him in a setting like this.

The contrast between the darkness of The Shape and the bright, frozen landscape could create some of the most striking imagery in the franchise.

The Final Act:

For the last 20 minutes or so, the anthology structure completely disappears. The stories are over. The legends are over. Now it's just Michael Myers. The version of Michael we've been seeing in shadows throughout the film finally steps into the light.

Not the Michael from any previous movie. Not the Michael from any specific timeline. The real Michael.

The final act becomes Michael systematically hunting everyone trapped inside his childhood home.

No mythology.

Just pure Halloween.

I'd even lean toward having almost no survivors, if any at all. The entire movie builds Michael into a myth through the stories, only for the ending to remind everyone that the reality is much worse than the legend.

The kids spend the entire night arguing over who understands Michael Myers. Then Michael gets the last word...And he never says a thing...

So that's just an idea I've had for some time now. The segments obviously can change. Let me know what you think!