r/TradingView

▲ 1 r/TradingView+1 crossposts

Cloned a signal, only one fires what gives?

For me, Tradingview has been very buggy and laggy
I have an alert set to fire on an indicator, I created a "clone" - I literally clicked "Clone" and just changed the title of it, both are exactly identical....only one fired....

https://preview.redd.it/soid332mfp2h1.png?width=312&format=png&auto=webp&s=e0f7efaf5ac5158fc957f00e71dd97752b1b2634

https://preview.redd.it/z0n60r4nfp2h1.png?width=287&format=png&auto=webp&s=e759132b11beaa0bebdd8a5d0a1da6fd3d28ffcb

What gives??

reddit.com
u/egypsy31 — 9 hours ago

Indicator

I’ve posted here before, but I’d like to bring up the topic once again. I have the code for a custom indicator, but I need someone to review it and modify its visual appearance on the chart. I have screenshots of the visualization. The indicator itself is functional, but I need to fine-tune it.

reddit.com
u/Klutzy-Struggle-9816 — 9 hours ago

Bug: Same symbol, same settings, different "Last day %" on two tabs — anyone else experiencing this on futures?

I've been dealing with an annoying data inconsistency on TradingView with CME futures and wanted to see if anyone else has run into this.

**The problem:**

When I open NQ1! (or even the specific contract NQM2026) on two separate chart tabs with completely identical settings, the "Last day" percentage change shown in the Data Window is different between the tabs. This means TradingView is using a different Previous Daily Close on each tab.

**What I've verified:**

- Both tabs use the exact same settings: 15min timeframe, Electronic Trading Hours (ETH), Back-Adjusted (B-ADJ), UTC-4 New York timezone

- The current candle's OHLCV data is identical on both tabs

- Only the "Last day" value differs

- I've tried refreshing both tabs, closing and reopening, removing all indicators — the issue persists

- Switching from NQ1! to the specific contract month NQM2026 does NOT fix it

- This does NOT happen on CFD instruments, only futures

**Why this matters:**

Any indicator that depends on the previous day's close will calculate completely different levels on each tab. I was getting inconsistent data and thought it was my indicator — turns out it's the underlying data itself.

In my case the implied previous daily close differed by about 133 points between tabs — that's a significant discrepancy.

Has anyone else noticed this? Is there a known fix or workaround beyond using multi-chart layouts within a single tab?

https://preview.redd.it/qc9y37r4go2h1.png?width=308&format=png&auto=webp&s=fed570c760b6e6744698e22628391a845eed95ab

https://preview.redd.it/bxyuofl3go2h1.png?width=294&format=png&auto=webp&s=7b22efe1030ed4963724edb33766df497494ac28

reddit.com
u/moadmr2 — 12 hours ago

Still Possible to Accidentally Delete Indicators - YEARS ASKING FOR FIX

I've been asking for YEARS for this simple fix - still not done. Crypto exchanges in the Zambia, yes you did that, but not this.

It is SO easy to accidentally delete an indicator by accident when clicking on chart deleting old lines etc. and not to notice until it is way too late to undo dozens of steps.

Just add a confirm button if deleteing indicators from the chart or LOCK THEM from deletion by default and only allow going into the Object Tree to delete indicators (also, STILL there is no separate section with the Object Tree for indicators? Madness.)

These LITTLE changes have MASSIVE impact.

No way gives a shit about a new crypto exchange in some far-flung corner of the world - just make the basic product perfect first.

reddit.com
u/Vendetta1010101 — 18 hours ago

stop using webhooks for live execution if you care about your money

Using webhooks for pine script alerts is slowly draining your account. webhooks increases latency by hundreds of milliseconds. by the time your server receives the http alert and sends it to the broker, the market makers have already changed the price. webhooks are designed for notification of disagreements, not for real time trading. stop wondering why real time slippage cancels the pnl test results. This is the network topology, not your indicator

reddit.com
u/Henry_old — 21 hours ago

Trading View - BRING BACK TICKETS

Having to deal with the countless m0r0ns on this forum is soooo painful.

Please just bring back tickets, I literally HATE Reddit so much!

Reddit / Discord - filled with Millennial scum!

reddit.com
u/Vendetta1010101 — 18 hours ago

Metatrade vs Trading view

Why execution on Metatrade feel smoother than tradingview, I feel my entry move faster than the candle in trading view, it not gonna happen in met a trade. Someone know it?

reddit.com
u/NoGuest1986 — 1 day ago

The scrolling bar thickness

Hi . Just wanted to give a suggestion to make the scroll bar on the right a bit bigger or thicker . i believe many traders are in the same boat as me in the sense its very difficult to scroll up and down with the vertical scroll bar. We are literally walking a very fine in literal sense. most of the time we deviate left or right a bit and it messes up in the sense either the window closes or some other feature is getting clicked. Same case in Object tree when we are trying to scroll up and down on various indicators we have favorited. This is not a big ask but it will go a long way in creating more satisfied customer. its specially infuriating scrolling that very angel hair thin scrolling bar. Please deploy this feature at the earliest by just increasing the thickness of the scroll bar

Another Annoying Aspect of Trading on TV

The "confirm" button after moving stop or TP level.

It's OK to have a confirm but please keep it close to the new level the stop or TP has been moved to - zoomed out on a 15 or 30 min + chart it's easy to see. But if I am zoomed in tightly on the 1 min or even 5 min chart, and I'm raising stop agressively chaisng price. (i) having to confirm every time is super annoying and clumsy (ii) it's all the way down there or up there!

So I raise stop, then have to scroll scroll scrool down the chart to find the damn confirm button, then do it all over again if price continues to change.

This is not good at all.

reddit.com
u/Vendetta1010101 — 18 hours ago

Locking the Watchlist ?

At least 5 times in the past 2 years I logged in only to find my Watchlist with 170 tickers scrambled from the order that I had everything in. Very Frustrating as it takes me around 3.5 hours to set them up again in the order that I like. Is it possible for TV to add a lock to the watchlist? Then if I want to make changes or add or delete a ticker I can then unlock the watchlist, make the changes I want and lock it back up... ? This of course would also need to be applied to the TV App.

reddit.com
u/plutacrat — 1 day ago

TradingView Desktop update: customizable New Tab + improved tab sync

Hey everyone, quick TradingView Desktop update from us.

We’ve recently shipped a couple of changes aimed at making Desktop easier to set up and smoother for multi-tab workflows.

First, the New Tab is now customizable. You can choose which TradingView tools appear when you open a fresh tab, including Screeners, Heatmaps, Calendars, News Flow, Portfolios, Yield Curves, Options, Fundamental Graphs, Markets, and Community tools.

https://reddit.com/link/1tj7g17/video/c09mr25tle2h1/player

Second, Tab Linking now syncs more than just symbols and intervals. Linked chart tabs can now stay aligned by:

  • Symbol
  • Interval
  • Time
  • Date range

You can use these sync options together or separately, depending on your setup. This should be especially useful if you work with multiple monitors, compare markets across timeframes, review historical price action, or backtest across several charts.

https://reddit.com/link/1tj7g17/video/zcp70xbwle2h1/player

If you’re not using TradingView Desktop yet, you’ll want to get it here: https://www.tradingview.com/desktop/

As always, we’d love to hear your feedback. What’s working well in Desktop, and what still gets in the way of your workflow?

Team TradingView

reddit.com
u/tradingview — 2 days ago

trading view price alerts

with trading view when you put on a price alert . You dont need to be logged in to get an alert . If i am away from computer and computer is off i will still get text alert when price is hit . Ninja trader using thinking of converting to trading view

reddit.com
u/hoppy999 — 1 day ago

I turned $10K into $2 million in just 2 years through trading, AMA

A few years ago, I started trading with a relatively small amount of money. I didn’t come from a finance background, and I made a lot of mistakes early on.

Over time, I got curious and decided to check the Dark Web to see if there was anything related to trading. There was. It was an ins. trading website, literally. There were people there who sold their information.

At first, I thought it was a scam. But I decided to give it a shot anyway. It seemed too good to be true. I paid $6,000 for the first piece of information, and it worked. I was shocked. 5x profit.

The rest is obvious. And NO, I won’t sell information.

I’m here to answer your questions.

Ask me anything.

reddit.com
u/Tough-Try8620 — 3 days ago

TradingView showing broken candlesticks (tiny fragments instead of candles) – anyone seen this?

I’ve been running into a weird issue on TradingView where candlesticks are not rendering properly — instead of full candles, I’m seeing tiny scattered fragments/dots all over the chart.

Details:

  • Happens on SOLUSDC (Bitstamp)
  • Tried reset scale, zoom, switching candles → no fix
  • Happens on Chrome, Safari, and even mobile
  • Works fine on BINANCE:SOLUSDT

At first I thought it was:

  • zoom issue
  • GPU/rendering bug
  • something wrong on my setup

But now it looks like the chart is just not forming proper candles on that pair.

My friend uses Bitstamp too and doesn’t see this, so I’m confused.

Is this a low-liquidity / bad data feed issue on Bitstamp?
Or is there some setting I’m missing?

Would appreciate if anyone else using SOL on Bitstamp can confirm.

​
SOLVED BY u/Rodnee999

reddit.com
u/putainsamere — 2 days ago

Did TV Premarket Screener somehow NOT catch that SNOW had a massive move before open?

u/tecz0r — 3 days ago

Is Pine screener development ongoing?

I’ve been exploring the pine screener but I’m a bit confused. On the web app it says it’s in beta but the desktop app doesn’t seem to have it available. Is this being phased out?

reddit.com
u/Imaginary-Walrus7093 — 2 days ago

Is there any way or trick to get technical alerts for free?

For instance, I need mobile alerts when the 9 EMA crosses the 21 EMA on the 30-minute timeframe for 5 symbols.

reddit.com
u/william_buttler — 3 days ago