r/WorkBoots

Image 1 — Do steel toes wear faster than soft?
Image 2 — Do steel toes wear faster than soft?
Image 3 — Do steel toes wear faster than soft?
Image 4 — Do steel toes wear faster than soft?

Do steel toes wear faster than soft?

Bought this pair of Redwing supersole 2.0s about 6 years ago. the leather on the steel toes wore through within the first year, which disppointed me. Before this pair, I’d worn out (cobbler said they could no longer resole) 2 pairs of Thorogood soft toes and I never had that much wear there. In addition to the place where they wore through, they also just look more chewed up than the soft toe Thorogoods.

My question is whether the added structure/rigidity of the steel toes makes the leather that covers it wear faster than if it was unsupported?

In my trade, I work on doors, and often hold them open with my right foot. The bottoms of commercial glass-aluminum storefront doors are often sharp, and I suspect that’s what caused the cuts on my redwings. Why didn’t they also cut up the thorogoods? Is it because of the lower height of the soft toe?

u/Baseballbattheyears — 5 hours ago

Buying new boots I narrowed it down to two choices.

I ended up deciding on the Danner Vicious over the timberland pros. Both are extremely comfy to wear but the timberland insoles are slightly better. The timberlands are a little taller than the danners which i didnt like because i prefer shorter boots I feel like I can move around better. The ultimate deciding factor as stupid as this sounds was when I went to crouch and let my front part of the shoe flex as I bent down the timberlands composite part dug into the top of my foot and it was really uncomfortable. The danners flexed easily with no rubbing any where. The danners I spent $220 and the timberland pros were $175. My only concern is the outside toe area for the danners not having reinforcement which I can always add if I want.

u/Electrical-Juice-915 — 7 hours ago

Boots for 225

Hello! I work in telecommunications so I climb poles, go up hills and work in dirt and mud. My job gives us 225 to use towards our boots and I was wondering what the best pair of boots would be for that price. I've worn timberland pro this year and felt they got wore out pretty fast.

Thanks for the recommendations!

reddit.com
u/Grizzly9160 — 11 hours ago

Need some recommendations please

So I work for my city in the street department, we fix streets, fix alleys, pick up junk in alleys, run equipment such as loader, skid steer, and the occasional maintainer, thought I was cool buying square toes like my current phantom riders and were comfortable for a little bit but damn they’re uncomfortable now. Usually buy yearly as hot mix tears our boots up in the summer. Looking for some slip ons, water resistant, comp toe, around 250ish$ saw some keens? I think but just not sure. I’ve tried Ariats, Justins, red wing, and maybe some other name brand boots and just didn’t like I am semi flat footed.

reddit.com
u/JarJarBl1nks — 15 hours ago

New Boot Goofin!

Redwing Traction Tred Lites 2476, had to get them online. 8.5D but might trade them in for a wide size, I’ll give them a few shifts though to make sure.

u/Vex_Lsg5k — 21 hours ago

Just bought these three weeks ago

So I bought these three weeks ago and the left sole is doing this, is it a defect or something else?

u/irosk — 1 day ago

Extremely painful feet

Hi, Im posting this for my dad as he is not very tech savvy. but he is looking for new work boots that won't kill his feet. he works 12 hour shifts and is on his feet most of the time. any recommendation would be nice and if possible some recommendations for the more budgeted mind.

reddit.com
u/GH0ST124_ — 1 day ago

USA made traction tred comp toe alternative?

Wondering if what I want doesn‘t exist outside of a pricey custom order. Work requirements are EH rated and safety toe. Will be in a factory so indoor on concrete floors all day, no fluids or dirt to worry about. But there’s no HVAC to speak of and it can get either very hot or very cold, so I’d prefer comp toe over steel.

Got a pair of traction treds in 10EE and they fit well, but the price seems steep for boots made overseas and I worry the waterproofing I don’t need will make them hotter and less breathable. I wanted to like thorogood, but they‘re just too narrow. In EE I have to size up to the point that they’re too long. Tried both the Chelsea’s and moc toe. Cant find EEE available anywhere.

reddit.com
u/CommanderFlapjacks — 24 hours ago

Buying first pair of boots

I’ve done a lot of DIY and miscellaneous work but never decided to buy boots and instead just absolutely beat the snot of out some old sneakers. Unfortunately for me, my new job requires it, and now, I’m stuck wishing I already had a pair.

I’ll be on my feet for around 10 hours a day on a production floor and machine shop. I have plantar fasciitis so a pair of boots that would mould to my feet overtime and maintain support is essential. Composite/steel toe is mandatory. I’ll be working in all different weather conditions so I would at least like water resistance. I have a budget of $250 but I can be flexible with that.

That’s all I can think of off the top of my head, what’re some of your recommendations?

reddit.com
u/_Agent_Toast_ — 1 day ago

$130 Thorogood Moc-toes, all different sizes, all brand new. Are these counterfeit? Scam sellers?

Title basically says it all. There are hundreds of these boots for sale, steel toes are a bit more, almost half of retail. There appear to be multiple sellers all with good reviews.

u/Sparkykc124 — 1 day ago

Which ones?

In the uk workboot options are bad, the attitude is towards replacing them every six months and I’d rather have some that last. I had a pair of these Ariats for the past year and I loved them, mainly for their comfort and their waterproofing. However I noticed the sole was pulling away from the boot and it turns out the stitching is fake and you can’t just re sole them, I did get reimbursed through their year warranty. However I’ve just had these Tims catch my eye and was wondering if anyone had experience with both shoes. Mainly bothered about comfort and waterproofing

u/Venom252 — 1 day ago

What makes buying work boots at a western store different in Canada?

I’m curious about Canadians who prefer buying their work boots from a western wear or ranch store instead of a general shoe store, workwear chain, or online retailer.

What makes the experience different or better?

Is it the staff’s knowledge, the selection of brands and widths, getting a proper fit, the ability to try boots on, or the sense that these stores understand the kind of work you do? Are there particular stores that you trust?

I’d especially like to hear what keeps you going back, even if another retailer has lower prices or more convenience. And if you’ve had a bad experience buying work boots elsewhere, what did the western store get right?

reddit.com
u/thepalmerstongroup — 1 day ago

Comfortable Waterproof Work boots

Need recommendations for comfortable waterproof boots less than $200 for work with inspecting well and septic.

reddit.com
u/Confident_Ad437 — 1 day ago

Irish Setter Wingshooter 8”

Anybody have this pair and enjoy them ? Don’t see too many reviews on these they felt super comfortable in store just waiting on the heat to subside and in my thorogoods at the moment

u/TiggerNitties13 — 2 days ago

2nd pair of boots help

So after realizing working on concrete is bad for my body the hard way 😅 I invested in thorogoods heritage 6" as my first pair about 8 months ago. It's reduced a lot of fatigue on my body but I still feel like my body is taking a lot of impact for being on concrete for 10+ hours a day. My feet and ankles are still fatigued pretty bad. I know the next recommendation would be insoles.. I have custom orthotics, powerstep and sole/fulton cork insoles I have tried them all in my boots. (Darn tough wool socks too).

I was wondering if anyone else who stands on concrete for a long time had a similar experience. I know thorogoods are known for being pretty comfy out of the box and they do help but I just don't think they are right for my feet. I typically respond to firm support. I was leaning towards red wings traction tred lite. Did anyone else struggle with thorogoods (width wasn't an issue) and find another brand that helped them a lot?

reddit.com
u/Tweakn3ss — 2 days ago

Considering buying these anyone have positive or negative reviews?

I’m a sprinkler fitter apprentice which means lots of walking and waterproof isn’t an option for me. I’ve found vibram soles tend to hold a little better for me and the wear I do on a boot. Does anyone have positive or negative comments on these boots at this price point?

u/zam1696 — 3 days ago

6 month Review ( Sketchers )

Hello everyone. I do construction, on my feet all-day in the humid heat. I average alot of steps and needed something comfortable, been through alot of boots thru the years, some good some awful. Decided to but these Moc toe Sketchers for about 125 US dollars and so far I'm impressed. They holding up after 6 month's. Only negative is soles wear little fast but thats the soles being so soft and comfortable. Redwing I had one time with these soles did same thing but where also good boots. I would definitely buy them again and believe I get over a year out of them as it goes now. Thanks for reading.

u/Doctor-Death- — 3 days ago

Very new to this. Bear with me 😁

So, I just got a pair of Keen liberty carbon safety toe boots, my second ever real daily drivers. But the backside leather on the back of my ankles digs in if I have them tight. But if loose then they move around and I'm fearful of hotspots. I work in a warehouse 12 hour shifts and they had good reviews and stuff but I'm unimpressed so far. I cannot return them. Will they get better after being "broken in" or is there something someone would suggest? Thanks in advance. :)

reddit.com
u/PanicMental5211 — 2 days ago