r/barenakedladies

Old fan coming back round for a loop

Was quite a fan back in the day, and owned all of their albums on CD from Gordon through All in Good Time.

When Steven left, I briefly blamed him, and continued trying to follow BNL without him. In the end, I haven't found myself able to really enjoy the band's music post-Steven, minus a couple songs, so I often forget about them.

It's been a few years since I last listened to them, but today I saw an Eminem interview from 2010 where he talked about rhyming "orange" and mentioned "4-inch" and "door hinge" and I was like, holy shit, either Em influenced BNL or BNL influenced Em, and either way that's hilarious and awesome :D Anyway, it reminded me of BNL and so...

...today I'm listening through as much of their discography as I'll manage - I'm currently starting up Stunt, and I've got a few thoughts collecting:

  1. These guys were always so very, very talented. Tyler's drumming always managed to perfectly fit any vibe, Jim is a very creative bassist who really plays with the music, and Ed and Steven complemented each other so very much vocally - that said, Jim wasn't the best singer, and Ed may be more blessed with creativity than with actual musical talent, but that's totally ok ;)

  2. I hated Jim's songs when I was a teen, I guess because I hated his voice, but I'm finding myself really liking them today. He had a very, very interesting writing style, and while I would skip these tracks back then, now I wish we had more! I guess they stopped having him write songs because they wanted commercial success and Jim's songs were never going to achieve that, but it's honestly kind of a pity imo!

  3. Almost all of my favourite songs are turning out to be Steven songs...? I think - maybe I'm wrong. But it's Wrap Your Arms Around Me, What a Good Boy, Box Set, and The Flag from Gordon; You Will be Waiting, Am I the Only One? (I think this is the only Ed one?), and The Wrong Man was Convicted from Drive; This is Where it Ends, When I Fall (oh, another Ed one!), I Live With it Every Day, and Break Your Heart from Pirate Ship...

  4. I am going to try to listen through all their albums, but in the past I've never been able to listen all the way through anything after All in Good Time... and I'm wondering if this is connected to point 3... but I really wonder, because I like almost all of their songs on all the albums they were all together with Steven - no real skips I think!

  5. I cannot wait for Maroon, my favourite BNL album <3 <3 <3

reddit.com
u/Repulsive_Chard_3652 — 11 days ago

Official... where?

A post was made some time ago about the 1991 official release (per BNLArchive) of the band playing live, but I haven't been able to track down what release this show came from (as pictured, not crossed out) despite bearing a similar label. You'd think it would be another Ladies Room exclusive CD but the 1991 issue was the most the fan club issued in that style, to my knowledge. What has been uploaded sounds excellent, and I would love to have a copy of this in my collection, if only I knew where to find a copy of it...

https://preview.redd.it/arwhba9d4hth1.png?width=1092&format=png&auto=webp&s=e39d699d41ae3c3648f823ffa109d0cd531add2b

reddit.com
u/developer_9998 — 11 days ago

Newcomer to BNL listening to their discography for the first time in chronological order. Here's my thorough in-depth track-by-track review of "Barenaked Ladies Are Me" (2006)

Adrift - it's great

Bank Job - it's amazing

Sound of Your Voice - it's great

Easy - it's good

Home - it's great

Bull in a China Shop - it's great

Everything Had Changed - it's good

Peterborough and the Kawarthas - it's great

Maybe You're Right - it's amazing

Take It Back - it's fine

Vanishing - it's fine

Rule the World with Love - it's great

Wind It Up - it's good

u/WatercressNext3578 — 13 days ago

Pinch Me live version lyrics

This is probably a frequently asked question but… Why does Ed change the lyrics from “run through with my gym shorts on …. Change into some drier clothes” to “run through with no clothing on … change into my sister’s clothes?” I assume he thinks it’s funny, but for me it undermines the melancholy vibe that makes the studio version so effective.

reddit.com
u/Mickey_James — 11 days ago

"I have a history of losing my shirt" I finally read the lyrics and have no idea how I've gotten thise lyrics wrong my entire life.

I had no idea why my brain totally blocked out " I have a history of taking off my shirt" this entire time. Like taking off my sounds nothing like losing lol. I feel like im crazy for not ever noticing it wasn't losing my shirt... like ever. 😂

reddit.com
u/clockworknait — 13 days ago

Hello City origin

Pardon me if this story has already been shared on this sub, but here is the backstory for the iconic Hello City song on the Gordon album:

According to Steve in Public Stunts, Private Stories:

>*"...*we played at this bar called The Lower Deck, where they had mostly Celtic music, being as there are mostly sailors in there, drinking. [...] We stayed at this place called The Carlton Hotel, on Barrington Street, which was upstairs from this metal bar called Rosa's. It's no longer there, but it was a total flophouse. [...] The room that Ed and I shared had four beds. One of them was up against the wall and another had a mattress falling through its frame. There was a bathtub with no shower. It was just gross. [...] Halifax on a weekend, you can't go anywhere without seeing somebody bleeding, somewhere. To get to the street from our terrible room, you had to walk down three or four flights of stairs and then step over some bleeding body. We were young, none of us were real drinkers, Ed didn't drink at all, and the whole drink culture of Halifax was just shocking to us. [...] So we were playing at The Lower Deck, this sailor's watering hole, and no one would pay attention. I remember taking a picture from the stage and when I got the pictures back, there was nobody looking at the camera. [...] I remember thinking I hate this place, I hate this place. [...] We've actually had great times there since, but that's because we learned the "when in Rome" axiom. You know the expression, 'do at the Romans do?' So 'when in Halifax,' we learned to 'do as the Haligonians do,' which in this case means drinking and bleeding." ^([1])

u/HotelJournalist — 14 days ago