
r/ershow

Dr. Hicks: Complicated
She's easy to admire because apparently she's rigidly honorable and dedicated to professionalism and thoughtful decisions rather than emotional ones. But she twice encourages Benton to stifle criticism of the morally questionable Vucelich, and her concern is not for medical research integrity but for personal and institutional reputation and grant money. She lies to Benton about Carter switching teams. She recruited Carter in S3/E13: "If Peter can't use your talents, my team can." Carter had made no mention of leaving for another team. And then she tells Benton in S3/E17, "Dr. Carter asked to be transferred to my team. You don't think I'd poach him, do you?" She absolutely poached him.
It's difficult to regard her in the same light after that.
Just finished S12Ep01…
And I’m done trying to like Sam. Like, I get it. She was groomed as a teenager and wound up saddled with a kid she didn’t want, but holy shit is she infuriating.
She lets Steve lie to her son about where he is, which prompts him to go to Colorado, and then she spends the whole episode proving Kerry right that she has no impulse control. She disregards every piece of advice gets, wrecks her car and nearly kills her and Luka, and gets unbelievably lucky that the cops find Alex because she had ZERO idea what she was going to do when she got to Colorado anyway. Then, for all that, she throws it in Luka’s face that he wants to be a good partner and a father figure for Alex.
Deep down, Sam is still a rebellious teenager. She loves Steve, she loves the the chaos, loves the thrill, loves the attention, and doesn’t really care all that much that it’s ripping Alex apart. Fuuuuuuuuuuck Sam.
watching er as a young person in 2026
i’m 22 years old and watched all 15 seasons of ER a few months ago after finishing The Pitt, and it literally changed my life forever. that being said, it’s sometimes tough having a conversation about it online when a majority of the fans reminisce and share their experiences watching it live back in the day.
any other younger people here with me obsessed with a show old enough to be called a “classic”?😭😭
Raul
I really liked Raul and Shep together and was sad to see the actor go.
Any ideas as to why they just left his character to die?
Was it the actor’s choice? The writers?
I would’ve liked to see more Shep and Raul than Shep wouldn’t have turned into a depressive angry person.
Anyone? Bueller?
Best Carter & Benton episodes post-S3?
Hey there, new to this subreddit but I am currently doing an incomplete ER rewatch. I was really loving all the Carter & Benton scenes in the first three seasons but now I'm just finishing S4, and they sadly don't have half as much screentime together. As I'm not planning to rewatch every single episode could I please get some recommendations on which episodes have Carter & Benton scenes / storylines in them from S5 onwards?
Love's Labor Lost still wrecks me 30 years later
Cat knocked my coffee into my lap right as Mark Greene broke down in the OR in Love's Labor Lost. I didn't even feel the heat. I was 14 again, watching my mom cry on the couch, not fully understanding why. Jodi O'Brien walked into the ER pregnant and a little swollen. Walked out on a gurney with a body bag. 20-something years later and I still can't hear "she's crashing" without flinching. I have a degree and a functioning life and I'm still not okay. What's the one episode from any show you will simply never rewatch because it hurts too much?
Romano and Gallant
Watching season 9 episode 18. The shot that Gallant threw Romanos way when Romano was commenting on his stitches was amazing.
Just got to THAT letter episode in S8 and I'm literally sobbing. Mark Greene was everything.
The way he walked through the ER for the last time? The way he said goodbye to everyone? I'm not okay. And honestly I don't think I'll ever be okay about this episode. it still destroys me. Anyone else rewatching and going through this emotional wreckage?
Best Romano one liners
The guys a prick but he probably gives me the most LOLs of the show
“How much of your brain did they actually cut out?”
“Guess I’ll give myself CPR”
“You know I can’t bring my pager into the dojo!!!!”
S10 E11 – I love all those moments that could possibly make Luka change his mind to go back to Africa again... and I love the chat at the end with Kerry.
It's a common story plot in a tv show - a character is about to leave, put in positive or productive moments to make the character reconsider and in the end the character decides to stay. It works, in my opinion.
Ross vs Kovac
Who would you choose?
I would choose Luka. I find his storyline is much more interesting that I want to keep watching to see what happens. I also think he's more likable person.
He along with Abby are the bridge from the OG cast to the Next gen cast. I think with that he sometimes gets overlooked by Mark, Carter, Ross etc.
His introduction is very memorable. Walking into the ER with the young girl in his arms as an oxygen tank rockets through the ER almost hitting him.
I’ve always loved when he first meets Abby. Their formal introduction "Abby Lockhart-Luka Kovac" and then the handshake. Very sweet.
What's the general consensus on Morris?
I hated him when he first showed up but now with him for 2 seasons I kinda really like him.
Do you have an episode or a moment that shocked you? That you didn’t expect?
Mine was when that helicopter fell and crushed Romano. It took me a good 20 mins of a pause to continue watching it. It literally made me jump it scared the shit out of me I can’t lie
Kerry is such a snake
Watching 'The Advocate' s9 ep17 this whole alderman storyline is pmo.
I've been annoyed with Kerry since that Chen/Malucci pager incident when she threw them under the bus to save her own ass.
It's really hypocritical of her. To think of all the times she called people out, threatened to suspend them only for her to do worse.. At least they all did it for the sake of the patient. She does it cus it's for her own benefit.
The scene where she's telling Ted Mosby to basically keep his mouth shut & take the blame so she's not exposed for malpractice in the name of protecting Alderman - she's really getting on my nerves.
Has Doug Ross contact to his 1. son?
He made a journey from a playboy to a responsbile boyfriend, but whats with his 1. child? did we learn if he ever tried to take responsiblity for that child?
Or will he leave his 2. child as well following a pattern?
What's the one ER moment that still wrecks you no matter how many times you watch it
Just heard that ER opening theme—the one with the frantic beeping and the swoosh—and my entire nervous system reset to 1998. My cat launched off the couch like she heard a code blue.
That theme didn't ask if you were ready. It grabbed you by the collar and sprinted. Fifteen seasons, County General, and the opening credits alone raised my blood pressure more than my morning coffee ever could. Remember the chaos of the pilot?
Just finished watching ER for my first time.
I had shoulder surgery in early June and am on summer break, so I’ve spent the last 5 sedentary weeks binge watching ER, which I had never seen and knew nothing about. While watching The Pitt a few months ago, I learned that Noah had played Carter on ER, so I decided to check it out.
I loved it SO MUCH. I cried all the damn time, fell in love with so many characters, learned a ton, and decided to investigate a career in medicine. I’m considering med school after I graduate in two years, but I’m also considering becoming a perfusionist or a dosimetrist.
I know a lot of people who watch The Office as a background-playing comfort show. I think that is going to be ER for me. I am so sad it’s over but I’m so grateful I can watch it as much as I want!
Glad to be a part of the club! 😍
First watch
I’m on season one of my first watch of er and wow I can’t stop drooling over the Chamber stove in Benton’s mom’s kitchen. What I wouldn’t do for that stove.