r/filmscoring

[Crosspost] Hi reddit! I'm Jay McCarrol - composer of TONY (out in theaters nationwide this weekend from A24), BLACKBERRY, and HELL OF A SUMMER. I also co-created and co-starred in NIRVANNA THE BAND THE SHOW THE MOVIE alongside Matt Johnson. AMA!
▲ 633 r/filmscoring+16 crossposts

[Crosspost] Hi reddit! I'm Jay McCarrol - composer of TONY (out in theaters nationwide this weekend from A24), BLACKBERRY, and HELL OF A SUMMER. I also co-created and co-starred in NIRVANNA THE BAND THE SHOW THE MOVIE alongside Matt Johnson. AMA!

I organized an AMA/Q&A with actor/comedian/composer/screenwriter Jay McCarol. He has composed the scores for films such as BlackBerry, Tony, Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie, Hell of a Summer, The Kid Detective, The Dirties, and Operation Avalanche. He is also the co-creator (with Matt Johnson) of Nirvana the Band the Show and its TV show and film.

It's live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:

https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1vskgy8/hi_reddit_im_jay_mccarrol_composer_of_tony_out_in/

He will be back at 3 PM ET today to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!

His newest film, Tony, is out in theaters via A24 this weekend. It stars Dominic Sessa as Anthony Bourdain and co-stars Antonio Banderas, Stavros Halkias, Emilia Jones, and Leo Woodall. It premiered to critical and audience acclaim a few weeks ago.

Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k1MVnzd2aVc

Synopsis: Nineteen-year-old Anthony Bourdain stumbles into the chaotic world of a restaurant kitchen, setting off a summer that shapes the course of his life.

Thank you :)

u/BunyipPouch — 1 day ago
▲ 9 r/filmscoring+1 crossposts

My Appreciation for Thomas Newman

This is going to sound funny but I first fell in love with scoring as a kid, when I first watched Finding Nemo. At that time, I used to wonder why I felt so emotional when watching the movie (other than the plot). But while growing up, I began realizing that the purpose of these scores is to use motifs and intense orchestration to make the viewer feel something almost tangible.

I started hyper-fixating on scores while watching movies and even now, I still feel maybe even more intensely for Finding Nemo (which might sound silly, I know).

I fell in love with more composers, like John Williams, Hans Zimmer (I got to see this dude perform live, it was crazy), Howard Shore, James Newton Howard, etc. But it wasn’t until I watched American Beauty that I decided Thomas Newman was my favorite composer ever. Obviously, I know a lot of people would disagree with me, saying he’s never even won an Oscar or that composers like Williams and Zimmer are far better. But, subjectively, with Newman, I feel such intense frisson with every movie, so much so that I began noticing his style of music without looking at the credit details.

What bothers me about Newman is how many people don’t know him or forget about him (which is crazy considering his family’s prominence in film scoring).

But all the movies he composed for, Meet Joe Black, Shawshank Redemption, The Green Mile, Road to Perdition, Scent of a Woman, etc, have made me feel almost insane while watching them. It’s like my soul reverberates against my body, causing shivers to shoot up and down my spine (I tend to get poetic when speaking about Newman). I literally start tearing up from the score, even if there isn’t anything sad happening, I’ll cry and uncontrollably smile.

Anyway, I just really needed to rant about my love for Thomas Newman. My passion for film scores has insufferably become my entire personality and, funny enough, nobody in my life understands and it drives me NUTS.

reddit.com
u/DeadlyPanda20 — 1 day ago
▲ 22 r/filmscoring+5 crossposts

Made a site for rating and reviewing scores. Looking for people to break it.

soundtrackscores.com

I'm Robert, one of the co-founders of Soundtrack Scores YouTube channel and podcast.

My friends and I have had a longtime soundtrack newsletter/channel (reactions, reviews, discussions), but the goal all along has been to create an app that lets us capture our ratings and reviews, and build a community of soundtrack lovers like us.

The webapp is here. It's early days but already well on its way. Completely free as it stands, and we'd love all of you to test it out, send feedback, and help us build out the database with more reviews and tags.

Once you've explored drop your feedback here.
One of our outstanding questions that we'd love your take on: should the reviews also indicate whether the reviewer has seen/played the subject vs listened out of context? If so, how do we best indicate that?

u/Aragornslegacy — 1 day ago
▲ 28 r/filmscoring+1 crossposts

Every Movie (Soundtrack) Ever Made

A while ago, a student in my class asked, “I want to make music for movies. How do I do that?” I said, “Hold my Starbucks Grande oat latte.” And this was the result after 45 minutes of work - as a joke, of course, for the amusement of the students. Plus, the second phrase is even more epic than the first, and all utter nonsense 😂

Bad news: the oat latte got very cold.

u/pap272 — 1 day ago

some VST suggestions for scoring

I'm scoring a film. I need some freshness to my library.

What would anyone suggest for woodwinds, strings for scoring... I got some strings , textures VST already, I need definitely some woodwinds.. I can also share what i have.

Im thinking of some of these: from Orchestral Tools: Igudesman Solo Violin, Whisper Gentle wind instruments, Berlin Woodwinds... but I need some advices for the fellow users.

Im also open for spitfire and other brands

reddit.com
u/Consistent-Silver-6 — 2 days ago
▲ 6 r/filmscoring+2 crossposts

Second time scoring to picture, what do you think?

This took SO LONG, but i'm sooo proud of how it turned out! Also i didn't listen to the original score until i had uploaded the video to my youtube, i didn't want to get influenced in any way.

Any feedback is appreciated!!

youtube.com
u/LegendaryLandsTTRPG — 2 days ago

Tips for scoring scene with dialogue

A friend of mine is working on a short film and has asked me to score a scene in which the characters are peacefully lying about in a field. I had thought there would be minimal dialogue in the scene, but there’s quite a bit of talking in the actual footage. The scene is about a minute and a half long, and there are only a couple five second streaks of silence.

I have a strong understanding of theory and have written a few original compositions, but this is my first attempt at scoring film footage, so I’m having a bit of trouble finding a way to work around the dialogue. If you have any tips for me, please leave them below! I am also open to answering any questions.

reddit.com
u/Agile_Blueberry2291 — 4 days ago
▲ 4 r/filmscoring+2 crossposts

Introducing Myself — UCLA Jazz Guitarist & Composer Focused on Narrative Storytelling in Film

Hi everyone! I'm Niko, a UCLA Global Jazz Studies student, jazz guitarist, pianist, and aspiring composer for film, animation, and games.

I'm interested in using music not simply to accompany what's happening on screen, but to explore character psychology, relationships, and how characters perceive the world around them.

I'd like to introduce myself by sharing a rescore I'm particularly proud of. The scene depicts two characters clashing with one another, and I approached the score as a musical confrontation between two different worlds. I used jazz fusion as the primary musical language, allowing the harmonic, rhythmic, and textural elements to collide and evolve alongside the characters' conflict.

This piece was also awarded the Grand Prize in an International Youth Music Competition, which made it particularly meaningful to me.

I'd love to hear what other composers think, particularly about how effectively the music communicates the characters' conflict and whether the musical ideas feel narratively connected to what's happening on screen.

Alastor vs. Vox Rescore:
Link: https://youtu.be/qL5ICz1TTeQ

This is one of my favorite projects where I show how the two overlords of Hell in the Hazbin Hotel show where they engage in an ultimate duel that inspired me to re-score this scene. I decided to replace the original soundtrack with a Jazz Fusion composition heavily inspired by Snarky Puppy, because jazz functions as a universal musical language. It allows the two characters to literally share their 'voices' during the fight through the mechanics of instrumental improvisation and taking turns trading solos.

Two completely different demonic eras clash here: Alastor, hailing from the Great Stock Market crash of the swinging 1920s, and Vox, emerging from the modern, contemporary digital aftermarket. Their main instruments take turns in an aggressive dialogue, as if one is desperately trying to 'outplay' or 'outperform' the other. For Vox, I utilized multiple synthesizers executing complex melodies at odd rhythms to emphasize his tech-savvy atmosphere, simulating his internal circuits and systems becoming physically overheated as the fight intensifies. For Alastor, I used a piercing trumpet and some rhythmic stride piano to emphasize his decaying, organic analog frequency, capturing both his theatrical showmanship and the sinister, vintage radio-filter chaos that anchors his power.

Driven by a blistering 160BPM tempo that gradually ascends slowly as the fight progresses, metric modulation, and unstable polyrhythmic displacements, the score shifts from mere accompaniment into a simulation of hardware failure, where the two god-like entities attempting to violently overwrite each other on the exact same bandwidth.

NOTE: I do not own anything related to Hazbin Hotel. All rights are reserved to Vivziepop and Spindlehorse.

© 2026 Niko Macario

Thanks for listening! I'm looking forward to learning from and connecting with everyone here.

u/Super_Friendship_313 — 3 days ago
▲ 17 r/filmscoring+2 crossposts

Scoring Homer’s Odyssey — New, Updated Full Orchestral Concert Suite

As a performing musician, I’ve been getting back into composing again. I posted an earlier version here a couple of months ago, which was essentially the Logic Pro project itself. And thank you for all of the supportive comments and the previous discussions! Since then, I’ve made quite a lot of progress on the larger work for symphony orchestra. Plus, I'm almost finished with a behind-the-scenes video looking at the compositional approach in more detail, as well as showing how I’ve used the orchestral libraries in Logic to try to make the orchestral mock-up sound as realistic as possible.

As background, my passion for the Homeric epics was re-ignited by the trailers for the Odyssey film. But my project is inspired by Homer’s original Odyssey, and not a rescore of the current movie or previous motion pictures. I’ve been working through the epic poem, and one of the most interesting challenges has been deciding what not to score, and also where the same thematic material can represent different moments in the story. The Peril theme, for example, can apply to several very different episodes without needing a completely new musical idea every time. For many reasons, Odysseus does seem to end up in some ridiculously dramatic and dangerous situations a lot!

The suite here showcases four main themes from the larger work tied together in various ways by the same basic tonic–dominant interval: 1) the Wanderer (Odysseus trying to get home), 2) Ithaka, 3) Longing/Family, and 4) Peril.
The majority of the orchestral patches are EastWest Hollywood Orchestra Opus Edition; the solo violin is me. A full list of instrument plug-ins is at the end of the video. A friend also created some images that I’ve used as backdrops during the Ithaka and Peril themes, and you can see me playing the violin during the Longing Theme.

Anyway, this is where the project has got to since I last shared it here: interested to hear your comments and what you folks think for discussion!

u/pap272 — 4 days ago

Jingles!

Hello!! Does anyone compose music for commercials? jingles? I want to start my film scoring career, and I've heard writing for commercials is great practice, but I have little idea how to break into that industry. Does anyone have any experience scoring for commercials? Or know anyone? Thank you in advance!!

reddit.com
u/No_Teach_9365 — 4 days ago
▲ 2 r/filmscoring+2 crossposts

I built a platform so you can find movies to score

I built Motif, a platform so that directors and composers can find collaborators directly without Facebook groups, cold DMs, LinkedIn, hoping the right person sees your post. You can put your genre style, links to socials, and links to your songs directly on your profile. Try out the beta version here: https://motif.bolt.host/

(Mobile version placement is a bit odd-- recommend you use desktop orientation)

u/Spiritual_Tank_7652 — 4 days ago
▲ 29 r/filmscoring+1 crossposts

The Electro Suite - My Orchestral Arrangement

Hey everyone, I’m White_Winter.

I recently finished an arrangement of The Electro Suite (Electro’s Theme) from The Amazing Spider-Man 2, originally composed by Hans Zimmer, The Magnificent Six and others.

I arranged it for:

• Clarinet in Bb
• 1st & 2nd Electric Guitars
• Electric Bass
• SATB Choir
• 1st & 2nd Violins
• Violas
• Cellos
• Double Basses
• Percussion

The full score is available on MuseScore here:
The Electro Suite (Electro’s Theme) - The Amazing Spider-Man 2

I'd love to hear what other composers/arrangers think, especially regarding the orchestration, balance between the different sections, and the way the choir and strings interact with the electric instruments.

Any feedback is very welcome!

u/Kira__Mitzune — 5 days ago

Crow Hill - Arcane Strings?

Just caught a youtube on a new release from The Crow Hill Company -- Arcane Strings. Introductory price of $150 normally $200. Yet another library that wants me to part with my cash, this fricken addiction to composing, what's a person to do? Anyhow, curious what anybody thinks of the library, and very importantly do I already have a library that comes close to Arcane Strings so I can keep my money and use it for pizza and beer lol. I have tons of libs for Kontakt, tons from Spitfire and Heavyocity, so how unique really is Arcane Strings and could something comparable be had cheaper? I have the "evolutions" libs from Spitfire, maybe they compare? Still installing Spitfire libs to an ssd after my other ssd with that crashed so I can't test evolutions libs right now. Maybe Symphonic Destruction lib?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_Rwk4ohba8

u/NomadJago — 5 days ago

How to add a video in FL?

whant t start scoring my first scene in fl, but was quick to realize that the stock video player is only limited to 35 second clips, anything longer you would need to drop 100 dollars to get (wich may i add is one of the cheapest, most blatant cash grabs ever), and I am not spending 100 dollars just so i can score a 3 minute long short film. so does anyone know where i can get a free and reliable video player for my daw, maybye even something that lets my extract the audio file from the video directly?

reddit.com
u/Low-Chair-196 — 6 days ago
▲ 21 r/filmscoring+1 crossposts

Seeking music composer for Project Save Erid

Project Save Erid (PSE) is a non-profit fan animated series following Rocky and his 22 eridian crewmates on their journey to Tau Ceti. There will be 9 episodes, each averaging 10 minutes.

We are seeking a music composer to create a soundtrack for our animated show. The selected composer will be given the complete screenplay and will have one month to score each episode (9 months for 9 episodes).

Since this is a non-profit project, this role will be unpaid. The music composer will be credited in each episode.

RULES
You must be 18+ years of age to apply.

HOW TO SUBMIT:
The application form will open Aug 20-Sep 3. You will be asked to submit a 1-3 min demo for a specific prompt. The link to the form can be found on https://lliuwrite.carrd.co

For updates on the project, join the PSE discord and follow us on socials!

u/lliuwrite — 8 days ago

Where to get free scenes to practice on?

i really what to start practicing film scoring, and ive already checked out the cue tube for some videos but i dont really whant to spend any money on my first ever score, and the two free videos on there didnt really look like they would be fun to score so im asking here if anyone knows where i can find a big library of free scenes to practice scoring.

reddit.com
u/Low-Chair-196 — 6 days ago

Posts about finding the right music for your project

Seeing a lot of people asking how to find the right music on here recently….hire a composer or find someone building their portfolio who’ll do it for free. It will not take more time than scrubbing through tons of songs, and it will be bespoke. If you have a subscription that you get music through, use that money to hire someone instead. There are tons of talented people who specialize in any genre you’re looking for, so seek them out and build a connection for your future!

reddit.com
u/Sufficient_Two_9630 — 8 days ago

What is your VST/instrument libs backup strategy?

EDIT: I have decided not to use an internal sata spin drive for backups (I was going to get a 20TB internal drive) due to noise and risk of malware infection and damage. Instead I am going to use a half dozen external usb3 4-6 TB drives for which I already own five, will buy a couple more. I am storing the external drives in foam protective hard cases, will treat them gently, and work at making a second case with redundant backup usb drives to keep out of the house in the event of a house fire. The drives will be safe from rootkits and malware. I will make imaged backups of my C: drive with Windows and imaged backups of Linux, and for my data drive and my two drives with vst instrument libraries I will do folder/file copies to the external usb drives. I think this will suffice; if not please let me know how to improve this strategy.

-----
How many TB and #drives do you have all your composing libs (VSTs) on, types of drives (SSD, spin drive, internal vs external), and what is your strategy for backing up your drives of your libs?

I just had a 4TB internal SSD fail and it had all (2.5TB) of my Spitfire Audio libs on it and then some, frustrating as such drives are not cheap these days. I did not have it backed up due to its size and because it is not the operating system drive (C:/Windows), and because I figured well I can just reinstall the libs if the drive fails. The drive failed, and now I so wish I had done an imaged backup of the drive-- but that takes a lot of storage. I also have a 2TB internal SSD with a lot of non-spitfire libs (from Native Instruments and others). I am thinking I spend $600 on a 20GB internal spin drive (I know, noisy) for holding imaged backups of all my drives; I only attach the cables to the noisy spin drive when needed for backups or restores, thus avoiding the noise that interferes with composing. I have enough external usb drives to get it done, but I have learned that the most reliable drives for backups are internal SSD, then internal spin hard drives, then external because external relies on USB and that creates more possible routes of failure compared to internal sata drives.

reddit.com
u/NomadJago — 8 days ago