r/nhltraderumours

Should Kyle Davidson make a move for Simon Edvinsson?
▲ 3 r/nhltraderumours+1 crossposts

Should Kyle Davidson make a move for Simon Edvinsson?

With all the rumors that Simon Edvinsson wants out of Detroit, I think Kyle Davidson should be all over this situation.

Edvinsson was drafted 6th overall in 2021 and has developed into exactly the type of defenseman the Blackhawks are missing. He's 6'6", skates exceptionally well for his size, can move the puck, play heavy defensive minutes, and match up against top competition every night. His defense is the needle mover.

What makes him so valuable isn't the offense. It's the defensive game. A game the Hawks sorely lack.

Edvinsson uses his reach, size, and gap control to kill plays before they become dangerous. He defends entries extremely well, plays a physical game without running around chasing hits, and has established himself as a legitimate shutdown defenseman. Those players aren't easy to find, especially at 23 years old.

The puck-moving ability is underrated too. He's the type of defenseman who can help a team spend less time defending and more time attacking. Which is missing on the Hawks backend.

So what's the cost?

Probably something close to what Calgary paid for Simon Nemec: two 1sts, a 2nd, and a prospect/player. That's not cheap, but elite young defensemen never are.

The Hawks also have a surplus of young defensemen. Someone is eventually getting squeezed out. If I'm Davidson, I'm absolutely willing to move Wyatt Kaiser, a 1st, a 2nd, and another quality prospect if that's what it takes.

Then your defense suddenly looks like:

Byram - Levshunov
Vlasic - Edvinsson
Cole - Rinzel

That's a pretty ridiculous blend of size, mobility, and defensive ability.

The next question is the contract.

Edvinsson is probably looking for something in the neighborhood of $8-10 million AAV on a long-term deal. Under the new cap, that's simply what young top-pair defensemen cost.

The other interesting option is still Alexander Nikishin, who is reportedly looking for a similar payday. Don't look now but the Canes are really missing him already this season. Personally, I'd be pursuing both situations aggressively because true top-pair defensemen rarely become available at 23 years old.

Let's hope Detroit doesn't solve its problem by sending Edvinsson somewhere like Carolina for a 1-for-1 swap involving Nikishin.

u/SouthSideHawkMan117 — 8 days ago

Could Kirby Dach actually be the young center Edmonton has reportedly been chasing?

Dreger reportedly said Edmonton has been involved for weeks in talks involving an unnamed young Eastern Conference center with upside and something left to prove.

Obviously, he didn't identify the player.

What makes Kirby Dach interesting is the previous reporting: Seravalli has already said Edmonton's interest in Dach is extremely strong, while Friedman has said the Oilers are looking for a right-shot center and specifically connected that need to Dach.

Dach is also 25, right-handed, 6'4", on a one-year $3.6M contract and fits the “upside but still has something to prove” description.

But if you're Edmonton, would you actually want him? And what NHL-ready piece would Montreal realistically want back?

nhltraderumor.com
u/athleticwonder — 9 days ago

What would Flyers fans realistically give Detroit for Simon Edvinsson?

With Elliotte Friedman linking Philadelphia to Simon Edvinsson, I'm curious where Flyers fans would actually draw the line.

He's 23, 6-foot-6, averaged 22:21 last season, and remains unsigned with Detroit. Philadelphia clearly needs help on the back end, but Edvinsson would cost substantially more than a normal early-season defensive addition.

My view is Detroit should be looking for an established young NHL player plus another premium asset rather than a picks-only return.

What would your best realistic offer be, and what player would be untouchable?

nhltraderumor.com
u/athleticwonder — 9 days ago

Could Matt Poitras actually be the young center Edmonton is chasing?

Dreger's report about Edmonton's mystery trade target got me looking at players who actually fit the description instead of just throwing big names around.

Matt Poitras is interesting.

He's 22, right-handed, plays C/RW, has a $850K cap hit and is an RFA after this season. He also has 27 points in 70 NHL games and put up 44 points in Providence last season.

Friedman previously pointed out that Edmonton lacked right-shot centers and more recently said the Oilers had explored a lateral defenceman-for-forward trade.

That doesn't mean Poitras is the guy, Dreger specifically didn't identify the player.

But I'd argue the profile fits unusually well.

From Edmonton's side, something around one of their surplus depth defencemen would also be much more appealing to me than spending another premium draft pick.

Would Boston even be interested, and what do Bruins fans think a fair hockey trade would look like?

nhltraderumor.com
u/athleticwonder — 8 days ago

Oilers Coach Babcock on the Ducks

Oilers Coach Mike Babcock on the Ducks

“His team’s gonna play fast. He’s got a bunch of young players with size and speed and skill.”

He says he knows Q well “we worked together a bunch of times, and he’s a good man” and has a clear idea of what Anaheim brought in last spring’s playoffs.

With today’s lineup, he says they can’t simply “race up and down the rink and hope to have success.” Instead, the approach has to be a “forechecking track game” and taking care of the puck.

“If we want to race up and down the rink, it’s not gonna go our way.”

u/BleedOilBlue97 — 8 days ago