r/swingtrading

If you want to learn how to find runners at before market open comment below
▲ 22 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

If you want to learn how to find runners at before market open comment below

giving access to my private channel let me know!

u/Fabulous-Jeweler1881 — 11 days ago

Why is high reward-to-risk / low win rate so popular?

Why do people usually prefer a high reward-to-risk ratio and a low win rate? It is very confusing to me. I personally prefer a lower reward-to-risk ratio and a higher win rate. Mathematically, neither should be inherently better. For example, a 30% win rate with a 3:1 reward-to-risk ratio is equivalent to roughly a 70% win rate with a 0.71:1 reward-to-risk ratio, assuming the same risk per trade.

If anything, I think there may even be a statistical advantage to a higher win rate. With a low-win-rate strategy, the observed win rate may sit only slightly above the breakeven win rate, which means you can need hundreds of additional trades before you can be reasonably confident that the edge is real rather than noise.

reddit.com
u/kaljakin — 12 days ago
▲ 55 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

How the Morning Star candlestick pattern actually works (and when it means nothing)

Three candles:

  1. A tall red day: sellers in control.

  2. A small-bodied day that opens below day 1's close: sellers push, price barely moves.

  3. A strong green day that closes well into day 1's red body: buyers take over.

Example: Day 1 ₹110 → ₹100. Day 2 ₹98 → ₹99. Day 3 ₹100 → ₹107, which recovers 70% of day 1's body.

Two details most explanations skip:

- Nison's ideal version has a gap before AND after the middle candle. He notes the second gap is rare, and missing it doesn't weaken the pattern.

- It needs a prior downtrend. The same three candles in a sideways market carry little information. It's more useful at a level where buyers stepped in before, but that part is judgement, not definition.

It's not a guarantee. Nison's own examples include a rally after a morning star that stalled within days.

Source: Steve Nison, Japanese Candlestick Charting Techniques. Example numbers, not advice.

u/iktisab — 12 days ago

Tips going forward

I have been back testing and forward testing my support and resistance strategy for months now and my win rate is about 42% with a 2:1 risk reward ratio. I’m planning on starting with my real money shortly but I’m curious on what methods to journal there are

reddit.com
u/OkDoughnut1451 — 11 days ago
▲ 1 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

Swing Trading in S&S ISA

I've recently been looking at swing trading as a bit of a side hustle/top up for my longer term positions within my ISA. I've done a bit so far with relative success (around 25% this month, however this includes trimming some winners I've had)

For those that are doing it in a S&S ISA, what sort of strategies are you doing and are you primarily focused on LSE stocks or stocks listed on other exchanges nothing T212 has a FOREX fee and can eat into your returns.

reddit.com
u/danisbuff — 11 days ago

Am I just too early on these reversals?

I bought AMD sometime ago around $165 thinking it'd reclaim and reverse. It opened, dropped and took me out, then recovered over the next few days. that one still pisses me off tbh, because it did eventually do what I thought it'd do.

I think i was just too early, i bought the weakness before there was really any confirmation buyers were stepping in. And yeah, I've had a few like that lately. big selloff, starts basing, volume picks up and I'm thinking ok maybe this is the turn... then nope, just keeps grinding lower and hits my stops lol.

So now I'm trying to wait for the reclaim or retest before getting in. I missed a couple moves doing that too, maybe, being early doesn't really feel like an edge. if I keep hitting my stops before the move even starts then idk maybe I'm just front-running my own trade at this point lol.

idk, do you guys wait for confirmation too or am I just reading the tape completely wrong?

reddit.com
u/Plenty-Carob5570 — 13 days ago

Nice first 2 days of the October 19m

I dumped out of nvda with my last remaining shares i got at $174.84 back in march switching over to mrvl long term mainly because of the market cap and the growth for mrvl is higher to long. Other then that j hit my best month this year and currently best % return in a month

u/Own-Needleworker5872 — 12 days ago

A few things that stood out this week... $MU, $INTC and $NKE

Kind of an interesting week if you were watching individual names.

$MU had the earnings reaction, $INTC finally ran into a pretty important resistance area after that run, and $NKE went the other direction... now I'm mostly watching to see where buyers actually start showing up.

The overall market wasn't exactly straightforward either. Yields were causing problems most of the week, then the weak jobs number Friday flipped the mood pretty fast. Nasdaq somehow still finished green on the week while the S&P and Dow didn't.

I went through all three stocks plus the bigger market picture in my full weekly market wrap.

Going into next week I'm mostly interested in whether Friday actually carries over... or gets faded.

reddit.com
u/Dagger_000 — 12 days ago

Hi all, i need your advice

I have a goal of earning 5000$ in the next 5 years. That's the amount of money I lost on the CFDs, in my country it's A LOT so it's hard to cope with this loss. 5 year span allows me to write off my loss for the IRS, so no tax on earnings. What I want to ask is: do you have any recommendations for books/ articles/ tools that could help me learn and achieve this goal? I don't want to gamble my money away as I did to this point, so I know i have a lot to learn.

reddit.com
u/shittycarvings — 12 days ago

I believe SOFI is nearly ready for its next upswing.

Previously posted a setup 4 months ago, and anyone that had joined had multiple opportunities to trim and take profits. I think SoFi is near its next bottom. Sofi has been pretty range bound. Its TBV provides a certain valuation floor where it appears institutions are willing to step in to buy under $15.

It's recently been in a downtrend again with an increase in 30m in shares shorted in the past 1 - 1.5months. Think they're likely to cover fairly soon, possibly after another push to test the floor or under buying volume.

One to eye for entries with an appropriate risk management direct shares over calls or potentially ITM leaps if pushed below $15 and don't recommend more than 20% margin on entries in case of continued weakness.

Earnings end of the month, TBV should rise to ~$7.41 based on their guidance (historically accurate/reliable) placing 2x TBV at $14.82 which is likely to be another spot to find institutional support given the companies growth rate. Not fully showing the confirmation on MACD momentum currently but given the years baseline and the fundamentals of the business I think this is one to move up on your watchlist.

Potential failure for a breakdown: Macro and overall market liquidity/movement.

Personally would base my stop loss on a confirmed breakdown below $14.75 and size with that in mind.

https://preview.redd.it/yu08evm9wath1.png?width=524&format=png&auto=webp&s=dbf18482df76d304e7acd89b83be54aadf9d422e

reddit.com
u/TherealCarbunc — 12 days ago
▲ 36 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

Engulfing + RVOL in Pine v6: breakout/retest entries and what the volume grades actually showed

A trader asked for an engulfing strategy with volume confirmation and two ways to enter: a break of the previous candle’s high/low, or a retest of its range.

This as a free, open-source tool. You can find the script and the full testing write-up here:

Built it as a Pine v6 strategy. Here’s how it works:

  • Aggressive — default: entry one tick beyond the previous candle’s high/low. If the signal candle has already closed beyond that level, entry is at the next bar’s open.
  • Retest: a limit order halfway into the previous candle’s range.
  • Both: enables both entries and splits the setup’s risk budget equally between them.
  • Risk: stop beyond both candles, a 2R target, and default risk of 0.5% per setup.
  • Volume grading: Low / Medium / High, using relative volume against the previous 20 bars.

The interesting part was testing what those volume labels actually meant.

The request originally described low-, medium-, and high-probability setups. But the tests didn’t support treating those RVOL grades as win probabilities.

On OANDA:XAUUSD 4H, the 2025–26 development period was profitable, while a separate 2023–24 period lost with the same settings and trading-cost assumptions. The earlier period lost even before overnight financing. High-volume shorts were its biggest losing group.

That’s why the panel says “Volume strength only · Probability untested.” The grade describes the signal candle’s volume; these results don’t establish that a higher grade gives a better trade.

Retest entries also failed the research criteria I used, so they’re available as an option but disabled by default.

For those who have built similar strategies in Pine: how would you test whether RVOL adds predictive value to an engulfing setup? I’m particularly interested in comparisons against an unfiltered baseline, and how you handle the smaller samples after splitting trades by direction and volume grade.

Screenshot note: numbers beside the order marks are position sizes in oz, not profit. Some adjacent order labels overlap in the native TradingView chart.

u/Dependent-Ad6636 — 13 days ago
▲ 2 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

Indian Trading journal pricing

Hi Everyone

I’ve been a software developer (web-full stack & desktop apps) for over 16 years and swing trading for the last 7. Like many traders, I got tired of the friction: keeping endless Excel sheets for journaling and flipping through five different websites just to make a trade decision. So, I decided to build my own solution. It’s a comprehensive trading journal equipped with fundamental and technical analytics to help traders make the right decisions faster. Here are the core features:

  1. Consolidated Dashboard

  2. intuitive view of holdings

  3. Trade log

  4. Fundamental analysis View

  5. Insights View: portfolio insights, trade log and behavioral insights

  6. AI analytics view: For portfolio, trade log and holdings (premium feature)

  7. Calendar View: Day/Month wise performance

  8. Tools for stock average and CAGR calculators etc

  9. Data Import for trade log or holdings for major Indian brokers

  10. News for Holdings specific as well as General News

  11. Direct messaging support for Admin contact.

I know there are so many trading journals out there. This one stands out bringing an edge in the trade decision, using AI powered analytics.

For those who would like participate in the beta testing, please comment/DM for access to the website. The website is currently hosted locally, would to release this soon after the beta testing done. Hence it runs on limited credits for AI analytics until full deployment.

Benefit For Beta Testers: Selected eligible beta testers who contribute immensely will get life time free access to the software and will have a chance for the collaboration. So it is a win-win situation

Currently, AI analytics view is going to be part of Premium membership. Further there are going more features for fundamental analysis for stock KPI metrics.

Re pricing: What would be reasonable monthly membership for this software. Please comment

Note: Currently, the website includes Indian stocks, however soon, it will be upgraded to other stock exchanges as well. If anybody is interested in other stock exchanges, please DM/comment

u/Bubbly-Meal7934 — 11 days ago
▲ 2 r/swingtrading+1 crossposts

$ABT: Bullish Harami + Golden Pocket + Oversold RSI

$ABT printed a bullish-harami on October 2, closing at 97.50 after a sustained decline from the late-August high. Price has given back much of the rally that carried it from the high 80s into the 116 area, and the pattern showed up right at the recent low.

What makes me interested is where that pause is happening. $ABT is sitting in the Fibonacci golden pocket, while RSI is 28.57 and a MACD cross is in play. Relative volume was 0.99x, so there was nothing unusual about the volume behind the candle. Taken together, I read the setup as a potential pause in a stretched decline rather than a random bullish candle in the middle of nowhere.

The obvious counterargument is that this is still a stock that has been selling for several weeks, so the harami could simply mark a temporary pause before the decline resumes. That is why the candle itself matters less to me than how price handles its high and low over the next few sessions.

A close above the mother candle’s high within the next few sessions confirms the setup; a close below its low invalidates it, with a stop a few ticks below that low.

https://preview.redd.it/me7zzk6l56th1.png?width=800&format=png&auto=webp&s=bbb9cdaaf18e884bb8bcba9608a9182a8c0bff0c

reddit.com
u/Aromatic-Welder-3032 — 12 days ago