r/thehouseinfatamorgana

Yukimasa Aida or Aida Yukimasa (idk japanese names) is framed as a cold-hearted killer by, both the characters in the VN, and the community. But is this really fair considering he never killed anyone?

Lets start with why people think Yukimasa is a murderer:

Firstly, in Door 2 he is shown to kill a bunch of people, but is this really true? Yukimasa is first introduced as Bestia and only later revealed to be a human. But what if he never was a human in Door 2? What if he wasn't even in it?

Giselle is the one retelling the story of Door 2 and we know that she has insanely messed up memories due her lifespan and manipulation from Morgana. What if she just doesn't remember correctly and mistook Bestia for Yukimasa? What if they were never the same person? Another reason for Giselle framing Yukimasa as the killer could be that...

Giselle is racist! This might sound absurd but you have to think about it. She is a white woman who grew up in mediaval Europe. Of course she would be racist, and therefore she would blame the crime on innocent little Yukimasa.

The explanation for his "murders" in Door 8/Morgana's backstory could be Morgana's racism since she also technically is white (despite half her skin being red (from acne)).

Is this a good theory?

(We all know that Giselle was caked up. You can try and deny it but you’re not gonna convince anyone not even yourself.)

Ok so Georges soul came to the mansion for Michel right? So why then did he stay so long as a painting? I personally wouldn’t wait half an hour for my siblings if they were trapped in some hellscape, hell naw Im bolting outta there. So why did he stay then?

My theory is that Georges first came to the mansion to free Michel but then wanted to go back to the grave. That was until he spotted Giselle and became the painting just to stare at that cake as she wandered the mansion halls.

Is this a good theory?

Wow, I just finished Door 5 and it was ethereal. The art, the story, the buildup, the conclusion — everything was extremely well executed. And the music? Just out of this world. The story of Michel and Giselle was inspiring and beautiful,

But I can't stop feeling sad after what happened at the end. It's just too many emotions to process at once.

”Ai will take over the world” my ass