r/websitefeedback

https://playersclubcars.com

Just migrated to Shopify and want to know how it looks to visitors.

Over the past few months I built a tool that audits landing pages across CRO, SEO, AEO, and GEO. It's processed 2,400+ pages now. Here's what actually kills conversions — ranked by how often we see it.

1. The headline describes the product, not the outcome.

This is #1 by a mile. 73% of pages we audit open with something like "The all-in-one platform for teams" or "Welcome to [Brand]."

Nobody cares what your product is. They care what their life looks like after using it.

Before: "The smart project management tool for agencies" After: "Cut client reporting time by 4 hours a week — or we'll refund you"

The second headline has a specific outcome, a specific audience, and a risk reversal. The first has none of those.

2. The CTA says "Get Started" — which is the worst possible button text.

"Get Started" describes effort. It tells the visitor they're about to do work. That's friction at the exact moment you need zero friction.

Replace it with the outcome the button delivers.

Before: "Get Started" After: "See my score in 30 seconds →"

One word change on a CTA button routinely moves conversion 1–3%. It's the highest ROI edit on this list.

3. Social proof is either missing or buried.

The pages that convert have trust signals above the fold — before the visitor has to scroll. The pages that don't convert have testimonials at the bottom, after the pricing section, where nobody reads them.

Rule: your single strongest proof point belongs in the first 400px of the page.

If you have a good testimonial with a specific number in it ("conversion rate went from 2.1% to 3.8%"), it goes directly under your headline. Not in a carousel. Not below the fold. Right there.

4. No FAQ schema — which means AI tools can't find you.

This one is invisible to most founders. If your page has no FAQPage JSON-LD schema, Perplexity, ChatGPT, and Google AI Overviews can't easily cite you when someone asks "what's the best tool for X."

The fix takes 20 minutes. Add 5–7 Q&A pairs covering pricing, methodology, who it's for, and what makes it different. That's your AEO foundation.

5. The value prop takes more than 5 seconds to understand.

Read your headline and subhead out loud. If you can't explain what you do to a stranger in one sentence after reading it, your page fails this test.

Fix: show your homepage to someone who has never heard of your product. Ask them one question: "What does this do?" If their answer doesn't match yours, rewrite until it does.

6. Pricing creates confusion instead of removing it.

The pages that convert use pricing to anchor, not to explain. The moment pricing requires reading, you've lost.

What works: a free tier (or free trial) next to a paid tier, with a short, specific feature list.

What doesn't work: three paid tiers with 14 feature rows and tooltips on every line.

If your pricing table takes more than 8 seconds to parse, simplify it.

7. Mobile experience is an afterthought.

Over 60% of the pages we audit have a desktop experience that's been squished onto mobile rather than designed for it.

Fix: load your page on your phone right now. Tap the CTA button. If your thumb misses it or has to stretch, your button is too small or in the wrong place.

The pattern across all 7:

Every one of these is fixable in an afternoon. None of them require a redesign. The pages that convert aren't more beautiful — they're more specific.

I built Roast My Page (https://roastmypage.shop/) to automate this audit. Paste your URL or copy, get a score across CRO, SEO, AEO, and GEO in 30 seconds, and a prioritized fix roadmap with exact rewrites — not generic advice.

Free preview. Full report is $9 one-time. 100% refund if it doesn't find at least 3 issues on your page.

Happy to audit anyone's page in the comments too — just drop your URL.

Hey everyone,

I recently finished building this e-commerce website for a client in the saree/fashion space and wanted to get some honest outside feedback before I fully wrap things up. After staring at the same design for too long, it gets hard to notice what feels off 😅

The branding/content side will be getting a proper refresh soon, so I’m mainly looking for feedback on the website experience itself - how it feels as a user, whether anything feels confusing, awkward, slow, or if something would make you hesitate before buying.

Check it out: https://sarees-phi.vercel.app/

Would genuinely appreciate honest feedback, even if it’s brutal 🙂

I’ve been working on a website for a product called QuickProof and would really appreciate some honest feedback.

Here’s the link: https://www.quickproof.ai/ 

It still feels a bit rough in terms of layout and clarity, so open to suggestions on design, structure, or anything that stands out. If you’re a designer/developer and your ideas resonate, I’d be open to connecting and working together to improve it

https://panopsik.com/

Eight days ago, I posted this project Panopsik here and got some of the most useful feedback I've received since starting it. Thank you genuinely. The kind of criticism this sub gave would cost serious money from a consultant and you gave it for free.

I want to address the main points directly rather than just saying "we listened."

Basically...  you were right on almost everything. The event points were showing too little to be actionable, the intelligence assessments were AI-generated noise that wouldn't survive five seconds with a real analyst, and the related articles were embarrassingly off-topic. These have been the priority this week.

What's changed:

• Added a landing page.
• Broke down the main dashboard into multiple lighter dashboards.
• Fixed a mountain of imperfections.
• Added the infrastructure layer.
• Currently in the process of allowing users to create their own dashboards depending on what information they want.

What's new:

You can now create an account. This lets you save searches, set alert thresholds for specific regions, and track how situations develop over time rather than getting a snapshot. It also means we can start understanding how people actually use this, which will drive what we fix next.

Still rough: clustering confidence on lower-tier sources, multilingual support, Southeast Asia coverage. We know.

If you tested it last week and wrote it off... fair. Come back and tell us if it's any better. If you haven't looked yet, now's a better time than eight days ago.

you can check it out here : https://persora-three.vercel.app/

I'm a CEO of a platform for building AI digital twins for coaches and experts. I decided to do my personal page, where I offer personal VIP service for free for big coaches. Can you please read through the website a little bit and tell me if it's easy to understand what this is about, and it makes it click for you? Do you feel like you understand why it makes sense to create an AI digital twin for yourself? Or is it too abstract concept?
My main goal here is to figure out how much time it takes you to understand what I'm doing - is it short enough so that you keep reading, or are you lost and would likely close the page? It's a pretty new topic, so it might not be very clear from the get go.
Happy for any kind of feedback or ideas for improvement!
https://davidriha.com/

I’d really appreciate brutally honest feedback on my site, especially the product page. That’s where most of my Meta ad traffic lands, so I care much more about conversion feedback than general homepage opinions. If something feels off, low trust, confusing, weak, too salesy, or just not convincing enough to buy, please say it directly. https://mixxyy.de/products/tragbarer-mixer

I'm 32 and pretty introverted. For most of my 20s I called the quiet thing a personality trait and moved on. Around 30 it stopped holding up. I was skipping stuff I actually wanted (speaking up at work, posting my writing, asking people to hang out) and just calling it being introverted.

The confidence apps I tried didn't help. Most are rebranded journaling. The "do one scary thing every day" stuff burned me out in a week.

What worked was small. Embarrassingly small. "Say good morning to the barista." "Ask one question in the meeting." I kept a list, then notes, then built a simple iOS app because notes got annoying.

One challenge a day across six categories: social skills, career, public speaking, networking, self-expression, comfort zone. Each has a clear ask and a one-line tip.

Few honest surprises after using it for ~8 months:

• Tiny challenges did the most work. The big push days were forgettable.
• Self-expression challenges were the hardest and the highest leverage.

Free tier has the daily challenge, streak, and widget. Pro unlocks unlimited skips and the full library. iOS only, on device, no account.

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/introvert-daily-courage/id6762940412

Would love feedback on the categories or anything that feels off.

just moved to seattle and still trying to find spots to catch games. stumbled across huddleupapp.org the other day and honestly it's been super helpful. you put in a game and it shows you which bars around the city are actually airing it. thought it might help some other people out here too

Please note, I am not trying to advertise anything.

Just want suggestions/feedback on how to improve the look and feel of the website I just made along with my friend. This took a couple of weeks to make (after 6 months of procrastination). Really wanted to give it the hanabi/jp theme to it. Have already decided a few more things that we can add, but want to understand if anything in the current implementation feels off. Thanks!

Site