I move that we as a sub uncanonise Squirrelfight's Hope and Bramblestar's Storm
I love Jessy so I'm gonna need a moment.
...
Moment over.
Bramblestar's Storm and Squirrelflight's Hope both make Squirrelstar and Brambleclaw (retrospectively) commit unsavoury and out of character actions. Whilst these actions are on a different scale, they occur in both books by both characters.
This is not a post for a BrambleSquirrel argument, because there will not be an agreement reached (unless it's me and Squirrelflight (the user) because I dare say we actually listen to each other instead of arguing). But I digress.
Both books destroy characters, and SH commits the sin of that awful Starclan Trial which I think is the one thing everyone can agree on about that super edition: the trial is utterly ridiculous.
I move we uncanonise both super editions to preserve the characters of Brambleclaw and Squirrelstar by removing each of their out of character moments, especially since they have since moved on to such a happy and healthy note in their relationship.
Who's with me?