u/Anonymous_45948

Is my father physically abusing me?

Hi. Lately, I (14M) have been wondering if my father is mistreating me or if I’m overreacting. He’s hit me about fifteen times, I’d say. Once—when I was twelve, I think—I threatened to call the police, and he told me no one would believe me. My mother is against it; whenever he hits me, I hear them arguing about it that same evening. But when I talk to her about it, she tells me I’m overreacting, that my father had a difficult childhood (which is true), and that even though what he does isn't pleasant, it isn't cruel either—and it certainly doesn't justify getting the police involved. She also says she was spanked once when she was four, yet she gets along very well with her parents. I understand that, but what I’m going through isn't the same thing. The worst thing my father ever did to me was when I was nine: I had spoken out of turn in class, and since I was usually a model student, I felt guilty. Apparently, it showed on my face, but because I didn't want to tell them what was wrong, my father hit my fingertips with a stick until my mother told him to stop. The problem is that when I talk to them about it, they pretend to have forgotten or downplay the whole situation, so I really don't know if I'm overreacting or if they're downplaying it. On the other hand, there are times when my father is very kind and doesn't act violently (which is actually the case most of the time).

reddit.com
u/Anonymous_45948 — 3 days ago
▲ 14 r/onednd

Best summoner class

Only in PHB 2024. Explain your choice in the comments!

Edit: Only in the 2024 PHB! So please, don't tell me Artificer, or Shepherd Druid or Creation Bard.

>!Edit: I thought it would be the Wizard (Illusion) because he has all the summoning spells except Celestial. Why do most people say it's the Druid?!<

View Poll

reddit.com
u/Anonymous_45948 — 2 months ago
▲ 1 r/3d6

Alchemist Bard

Hello, I'm planning to create a Potions Master, but I only play with the PHB 2024 (so no Artificer...). However, I had an idea: an alchemist who, too poor to afford paper, memorized his recipes... by singing. So, a Bard. I love the idea of ​​bardic inspiration in the form of potions (as long as it doesn't change anything mechanically). However, this would drastically change the Bard class: it's said that they access magic through words, songs, and vibrations. But for me, singing would only be a mnemonic device. So:

  1. Is this possible in RAW?

  2. My DM will be very strict about the rules, since it's her first game as a DM. How can I convince her?

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Anonymous_45948 — 2 months ago
▲ 36 r/onednd

Why does everyone say Crafting is bad?

I'm playing a wizard and am considering taking the Crafting feat. I've looked at online reviews, but everyone says Crafting is the worst origin feat. Why is that?

Doesn't this feat give a 20% discount on spell material components? For example, I could save 300 GP to cast Simulacrum.

Also, the fast crafting table shows that you can create marbles or caltrops. If I have a familiar, it could set those traps, right?

However, I'm a beginner, so it's possible probable that I'm wrong.

reddit.com
u/Anonymous_45948 — 3 months ago