Clarification about puranas and Bhagavad Gita
My friend here who apparently is versed in shastras and vedas says Manu smriti is in the higher order priority/hierarchy compared the Srimad Bhagavat Gita.
According to his logic, certain purana mentions order or Shruti > Smriti > Purana etc. So manu smriti being a smriti, and Bhagavad Gita being a purana the order has to be vedas> Manu smriti > Bhagavatam & Bhagavad Gita
While id argue that there’s no way a text like Manu smriti could be compared to Srimad Bhagavad Gita which was (from my knowledge) a direct dialogue between God and human, transcribed by purest souls in highest states along with the Bhagavat puran and Mahabharatam. It’s just technically impossible with any logic applied.
But he doesnt want to understand the pressing issue of restoring a text as old as Manu smriti, interpolation and inappropriate interpretation associated with it along with contradictory statements within the text itself.
He says that he needs a shatric proof and can’t take my argument simply cuz it’s my “personal” belief.
He will only listen to a shastra vakyam and that nowhere in shastras its mentioned that Bhagavat Gita is superior to any smriti ? And he argues that it’s not a smriti but strictly a puran. And I’m not someone who studies other shastras, just the three above mentioned texts- Bhagavatam, Mahabharat and Bhagavatam. So if either of us are missing something please do enlighten us 🙏 thank you