AC Shadows is so UNDERWHELMING
AC Shadows just feels painfully underwhelming. Ubisoft has been on a downward spiral for years now and this game somehow manages to make that even more obvious. I absolutely hated Mirage, but at least Mirage knew what kind of game it wanted to be. Shadows just feels confused. Last truly great Assassin’s Creed for me was Assassin’s Creed Odyssey. Odyssey was everything I wanted from modern AC. Massive world, beautiful atmosphere, addictive exploration, naval combat, freedom to approach things however you wanted, and somehow hundreds of hours just disappeared while playing it. And after playing Ghost of Tsushima, Shadows feels even more underwhelming. Tsushima already perfected that cinematic samurai fantasy years ago. The combat felt clean, traversal felt fluid, the world had soul. Shadows constantly feels like it’s chasing that vibe without ever understanding why Tsushima worked in the first place. What hurts even more is how little actual Assassin lore is left now. The older AC games had mystery, conspiracy, tension between Assassins and Templars, the whole hidden war happening behind history. That was the identity of the franchise. Now it just feels like Ubisoft picks a historical setting first and then awkwardly stuffs the AC logo on top of it later. And Yasuke… man, playing as him was frustrating. They tried to force the mobility and stealth style of an assassin onto a massive armored samurai and it just never felt natural to me. The movement felt heavy in all the wrong ways. I genuinely only switched to him whenever the story forced me to. Every time I got control back, I immediately went back to Naoe because at least she actually felt like an Assassin’s Creed character. Ubisoft used to make games that felt ambitious. Now everything feels focus-tested, bloated and safe. Shadows isn’t terrible, which somehow makes it even more disappointing. It’s just another reminder of how far this franchise has drifted from what made people fall in love with it in the first place.