u/AsleepInterview2898

Not gonna write much for this. One couple gets more episodes while the other gets less. Would Anastasia get voted off to the other team in episode 1? More likely than you think. Gabby’s team should be more supportive with kinder people around but I could be wrong. She would feel included in the girls alliance. Their ages would be the same so no ‘She would be younger/older so this would happen’. Let’s just say they have the same circumstances despite being born in different times.

Irony + Satire with a question mark because this isn’t entirely untrue besides some placements

Both kind of suck at challenges, both are blondes, both wear speedos, but personality wise they differ.

Finn:

I don’t think Finn would be able to befriend Lill considering how mean he is. This would mean the Lill alliance would only be Will, Ashley, and herself. Finn doesn’t have an attraction to Tom being covered up with such outfit. He’d diss him on his fashion. Will still get eliminated through a 1-3-4 vote. I did consider if the Lill alliance would switch to voting for Finn but Will was adamant on voting Fiore out. Ashley still votes Alec.

I don’t think Finn can see through Fiore even if he is a theater kid. He seems like the type to hate children so I don’t think he would pay attention to her much.

Drew is still eliminated

I think the closest to a friend he’ll have here is Ellie for fashion and dreams. But she would be annoyed of him, only really tolerating the guy for votes.

Fiore doesn’t need to burn stuff because there is no alliance to broken. Or so she thought.

Finn would not win for his team in Nick’s original elimination episode. He’s kind of pathetic in combat from what we’ve seen in the show. Here a change happens. Finn votes with Ashley and Lill to cause a tiebreaker against Fiore. He gets the other three votes for being kind of useless. I think he would do this because he wanted Evie out for being useless so he would think the same for Fiore. Plus a villainous performance to switch the tides would be perfect.

Whether he wins the tiebreaker which would be the prison one from AS is up to interpretation but let’s just say he does since he has longer arms and more strength to get the key. Fiore loses. She crashes out, cursing everyone out.

In the cooking challenge, Lill would volunteer to cook now she doesn’t need to prepare to expose Fiore with the whole diary talk. Alec would also volunteer. Finn would be suffering getting disgusting things for food so he has to be accompanied by Ellie. I think Lill would be a much better cook considering she leads a girls scout who would teach the skills of cooking in the wild. The soup would actually be delicious and since a liquid is more easier to get down than a solid, Magenta Team would win. Ellie volunteers to be the representative to vote off another member off of Teal Team as a promise to Gabby.

Since the writers once to make Dan strategic, he would try to pitch to the boys on voting off Grett thinking she’s the leader of the hidden alliance. Jake would be on board but Tom is more hesitant. He would pull Jake in private to ask him to vote for Gabby instead. Jake is fine with either since they both are hard to get along with. But upon talking with this to Miriam she convinces him to stick the target on Grett. Grett would know she’s being targeted once Tom tells her about it. Does she go for Dan? No. She actually tries to get Gabby to get Dan to flip and vote for Miriam. Or else she’ll break this alliance apart. Gabby does try and kind of reconciles with Dan.

But it doesn’t work. Dan, Jake, and Miriam vote for Grett while Grett, Gabby, and Tom vote for Miriam. Another tiebreaker which I don’t know what it would be. Maybe something relating to collecting stuff. Grett wins for not being old. It all doesn’t matter because after the challenge, Derik makes Ellie reveal her vote. GRETT. She totally doesn’t cry on her way to elimination. Miriam is happy karma spat on that girl’s face. Jake would think Dan flipped which she promises he didn’t. Tom doesn’t tell the truth to keep his position in the game stable.

In the double team elimination episode it would be clear to Finn that he plays the swing vote. Two groups need him. How glorious, he’s practically safe. He’s more likely to side with Ellie and Alec since Ellie bias. She grows more frustrated with him by the day.

Dan and Gabby are not on okay terms after Grett got eliminated. She doesn’t want to talk to him. Same goes for Jake. He needs this immunity to win.

Alec and Lill got along during the last challenge. Something close to acquaintances. Ashley takes notice, having doubts about him.

I think Gabby/Tom and Alec/Lill win their immunities for being the strongest players on their team. Dan would be voted out and Finn would be too. Everyone found him a nuisance to deal with. But surprise they are team swapped instead. Finn swears revenge. Dan finds this to be a second chance he can’t screw up. Insert funny interaction between DanTDM and Finn from Adventure Time.

Dynamics in Purple Team are less divided with Lill and Alec having chats and same going for the other two. It’s a mix Dan gets added into. Finn is in a depressing site. He doesn’t like Gabby. He doesn’t like anyone here. But he’ll have to work with it.

Needless to say Teal Team is fucked for this challenge since Purple has both Alec and Dan to solve the puzzle. Also more numbers in general. Finn tries to get his revenge that doesn’t work. In elimination, as much he doesn’t like Gabby, he tries to befriend her so he can vote out the twink Jake. He knows if she goes, he’ll be next. Gabby plays her idol to nullify the two votes and gets Jake out. She could have voted for Finn but she thought the same as he did. Plus she can play more aware now, not letting him manipulate her. Jake says his goodbyes and Tom’s identity stays hidden

MERGE FINN

Alec still makes the plan to make everyone else fight each other during the questionnaire, dragging Finn, and Dan into it. Latter feeling a little guilty doing this to Gabby. Gabby still gets voted off with Finn, Alec, Ashley, Lill, Tom, and Dan voting her off. Though you could argue maybe he votes with Gabby and Ellie.

Zombie zombie zombie zombie zombie. Ellie dies. Finn wants to die. Lill and Alec kiss with the romantic tension between them. Ashley is crying her eyes out over the thought of her family being dead. Dan is trying to comfort Ashley. Tom is a lone wolf. Dan wins since I think Tom would get the most kills and survives the longest while everybody else dies, the purple guy could outsmart him. Think of a scene where Tom just killed someone or tries to hunt down Dan then he gets a surprise attack from Dan’s plan.

It’s revealed to be VR so the trauma definitely shouldn’t carry over. Alec realized he just cheated on his wife who he thought was dead on live television. Lill feels awful for doing what she did. The vote obviously falls on to Tom for being a threat. Random note, I think it would be funny for Finn to see Tom revealed, seeing him as a total hottie, then voting with him just for that. Mwah.

Alec and Lill would be so awkward right now but talk it out like adults. They need some time apart.

I’ll be honest beyond this point idk how things would play out. Something similar to this.

Ashley

Finn

Lill

Dan

Either Ellie or Alec win depending on which narrative would be more satisfying

Once again my disorganized thoughts. Won’t do Nick since FvF isn’t complete yet

Pictures are by AsleepInterview2898 and The audition/writing is by u/FriendlySky5457.

Xavier:

"(Aggressively pointing at the camera, leaning in way too close) You know me. Don’t lie, I know the producers read the Subreddit. I am HeatherSlay_AlejandroStan99. I am the head admin of the Reality TV Villains Wiki. I am the guy who wrote that 14-part thread on why the Season 3 pre-merge boots was statistically flawed. (He dramatically pushes his hair up, smiling at the camera too hard) But out in the real world? My name is Xavier. And I am going to dominate your ( season ) because I have studied the sacred texts. I don't just watch Heather and Alejandro. I live them. I have broken down their gameplay frame-by-frame, and I have synthesized it into the ultimate, mathematically perfect villain strategy. (He swivels his chair, grabs a shiny red apple off his desk, and tries to toss it in the air and catch it like Alejandro does. He drops it. It rolls under his bed. He pretends that didn't happen and clears his throat.) Phase One: The Aliance Protocol. I will be the puppet master of the masses! I have been practicing my effortless, hypnotic leadering. Watch. (He turns to a body-pillow standing upright in the corner of his room. He lowers his voice, trying to sound husky, but it just sounds raspy, like he has a sore throat.) "Hola, señorita. Your eyes are like… the… immunity idol of my heart. Are you an alliance? Because I want to be in you—wait, no, that sounded wrong. Cut that, I’ll edit that out later." (He turns back to the camera, his face slightly red, but he pushes forward with unearned confidence.) Anyway, my Spanish is getting really good. I have a 14-day streak on Duolingo. The ladies are going to be completely immobilized by my charm.

Phase Two: The Heather Protocol. When the time is right, the charm turns to venom. I am going to be so mean, you guys. You want drama? I have been practicing my confessional trash-talk in the mirror for six months. (He narrows his eyes, trying to look absolutely diabolical.) I will look right into the camera and say things like: "Oh, you think you’re safe, Brad? Well, your cargo shorts are so last week! And your hair looks like… a bird's nest that a bird decided to move out of because the rent was too high!" (He pauses, genuinely impressed with himself.) Boom. Destroyed. He’s going to need therapy after he watches this season air. (Suddenly, his bedroom door opens. A woman’s hand reaches in, holding a plate.) XAVIER’S MOM (O.S.): Xavy, sweetie! I brought your pizza bagels. They're very hot, don't burn your mouth like last time! XAVIER: (Instantly dropping the villain persona, whining loudly) MA! I’m filming my audition tape! I told you I’m entering my villain era! You’re ruining my winner's edit! XAVIER'S MOM (O.S.): Okay, sweetie! Did you take your gummy vitamins? XAVIER: (Furious, his voice cracking) YES, I TOOK THE FLINTSTONES GUMMIES! SHUT THE DOOR! (The door clicks shut. Xavier takes a deep, ragged breath, turns back to the camera, and tries to regain his composure, desperately attempting a sinister smirk.) See that? That’s called managing a pawn. I have her completely wrapped around my finger. She brings me sustenance, and I give her nothing in return. Cutthroat.

(He leans in close to the camera again. He looks incredibly desperate now.) Look, producers, you need me. I know the meta! I know about blindside split-votes, I know about the floater-to-coaster ratio! I have already designed my own evil theme song in GarageBand! Please! If you cast me, I promise I will cause so much drama! I’ll hide people’s shoes! I’ll maliciously rearrange the silverware! (He tries to do an evil, Heather-style hair flip, but he’s wearing a headset he forgot about, and it yanks his head back awkwardly by the cord.) Ow! (He scrambles to pull the headset off, knocking his webcam over. The camera is now facing the ceiling. We hear him breathing heavily into the mic.) (Off-screen) Just… please give me the villain edit. "

I decided Kelly being eliminated would make for a more interesting story. Possible boys alliance and more drama. Also no queer baiting with her and Ari.

Nicole and Jecka wondering how the vote last night even happened, coming to the conclusion it has to do with the boys because Class of ‘09 men are kind of fucked up besides 09 Hunter (Footside is not canon). Jecka wants to confront them about it but Nicole has a plan to give them karma.

In confessional, she points out the leader would most likely be Benji since he’s an adult. She was about to call him something else not appropriate to say but she got cut off.

09 Hunter and Crispin have a strategy meeting that mostly just the former talking ideas while the latter just agrees, going with the flow.

In confessional, Hunter thinks Crispin isn’t the best alliance partner around since it feels like he’s talking to a brick wall . He needs someone to add on to his ideas.

Principal Lynn and Kylar having a funny interaction relating to camp stuff. Kylar calls her a bitch. Gasp, oh my gosh.

09 Emily and Ari wishing they had drugs.

Natalia talks more with Ally about the idol and other stuff to get her trust more. Ally was thinking of giving half of it to someone who’s more likely to get eliminated but Natalia shoots that down since it would mostly likely come to bite her in the ass. They need someone who would not put them on the spotlight once they get eliminated and has a big target on their back. Then, a lightbulb would go over Natalia’s head.

Anastasia would struggle to do reminiscing without Gabby. Rosa tries to help and it works. Anastasia learns about her daughter and feels closer to her. Though Rosa still misunderstands Anastasia having a break up which she’s confused by. Rosa shuts up once Megan comes along to see what’s up. Yellow hoodie trying to keep this team together after Aiden got out. It would be cute if Anastasia would see Rosa as a mother she never had considering her real one isn’t the best.

Tom and Lake still swimming. Nobody drowns. More on the catching up part.

Alec and Spencer interact. The two trying to figure out how to sway the vote. Spencer is cautious of Alec and vise versa.

In the flower picking challenge, Kylar sits out since that shit is for girls. He gets glares from majority of the females.

Natalia pushed Tom to partner with Ally, making the excuse to go with Anastasia for….. catching up. Lake goes with Rosa obviously, and Spencer and Alec pair by default. Megan goes with Natalia and Anastasia by force since three girls are better than two. Really she doesn’t trust pinkie.

Nicole and Jecka pair, Principal Lynn pair with Emily and Ari to make sure they don’t do any trouble, Benji and Jeffrey pair up, and Hunter and Crispin pair up.

During the challenge, Anastasia asks why Natalia would wanted to pair with her, not believing her initial excuse. Natalia tries to make an apology for season everything they’ve been through even if she’s lying but Megan calls that bullshit. The two get into an argument and Anastasia has to break it up, defending Natalia for wanting to change as she tries to get Megan to understand not to be so distrusting. She knows from experience how much it hurts herself and others, believing Natalia has the right to not forgive her. This only angers Megan, thinking Anastasia is fake, storming off to get flowers.

In confessional, Natalia would be surprised by the further evidence of change Anastasia shows. She still distrusts her, being paranoid. She could either use this to her advantage or find a way to get the witch out if they ever lose.

Ally would make an excuse to separate from Tom, seeing some flowers they need up ahead. He would just let her go, being understanding. Though he would have liked to chat.

Ally in confessional talks about her plan with Natalia. One risky but would not interfere with the current dynamics in their team. She needs to give half of the idol to a fan. Someone who isn’t in a great position.

She passed by Benji and Jeffrey, just having a quick chat before going off. Jeffrey asks if he has a crush on her to which Benji explains he is already in a relationship with Tristan. Jeffrey wouldn’t really understand why he would date someone who identifies as nonbinary or they/them but it’s not something he can judge. When Benji asks who he likes, the response whispered to him would make him a little uncomfortable.

Benji in confessional tries not to judge Jeffrey for his type. He wasn’t going to say it on live TV. If the kid likes that then who’s to stop him? Let him be happy. Though inside he hopes Jeffrey grows out of it.

Lake and Rosa walk into Ari, Principal Lynn, and 09 Emily. They talk, Lake gets uncomfortable with Principal Lynn, Rosa tries to tell the principal to be less harsh on the kids until Emily calls her a washed up w:::: (idk if I can say that last part), shocking her completely. Ari reminds Lake of herself which she says in confessional.

Ally finds Crispin and 09 Hunter, deciding to give them the other half of the idol. She says it’s because she finds it funny how he’s named Hunter and she has a friend named Hunter. Also, she thinks they might need it. She runs off before they could ask anything else. Hunter sees it as a gold mine opportunity.

Who loses? Considering the favorites have Spencer and class of 09 doesn’t have anybody good with flowers then the answer should be clear. Fans are going to elimination.

Nicole and Jecka get Jeffrey and Benji to vote with them, threatening them to reveal their advantage. They’re changing targets to Kylar because they think he sucks. Once the girls walk away they would be approached by Crispin and 09 Hunter for the next vote. They suggest Jecka so they can leave Nicole vulnerable without her friend. Decisions, decisions.

In the ceremony the person voted out would be…

Jecka: Crispin, Hunter, Kylar

Kylar: Nicole, Jecka, Ari, Emily, Principal Lynn, Jeffrey, Benji

Kylar. He would curse everyone out, saying all of them will suck without him. He calls the women bitches one last time before leaving.

In confessionals,

Jeffrey is glad Kylar was gone so he would stop bullying him. Regardless of which alliance they chose, him and Benji would be fine! He still thinks Nicole wouldn’t vote him off and Jeffrey could just use his advantage to beat the other boys.

Principal Lynn voted with Nicole so he could get the most troubling student out. This would also make the boys be in pure desperation, something she plans to take advantage of.

Crispin is like “Aw man, they voted off Kylar like that like oh no this ain’t good. Oh no.”

Eliminated:

24th - Fiore

23rd - Gabby

22nd - Karen

21st - Aiden

20th - Kelly

19th - Kylar

Also forgot who went to Rescue Island or the Motel so here.

Rescue Island:

Fiore, Gabby, Aiden, Kelly, Kylar

Motel:

Karen

1. Would of fixed the issue of Anastasia overstaying a little as some people would say with 5 less episodes in her screen time

2. That screen time can be used to flesh out Marissa to be more than just Anastasia girlfriend. Really finish her military decision, add more dynamics to her, have her face off Lynda to ensure she’s eliminated to show her agency and how she’s changed. If Marissa was the one in the tiebreaker with Lynda then that would of boosted her memorability by a lot

3. We wouldn’t have Marissa tearing through the return challenge in a boring way. Anastasia would come back and actually have to fight for it and Marissa having to stand back so she can win. Assuming her partner would still be Ivy so they can have that conversation.

4. These changes would add more to Anarissa as Anastasia probably calmed down a bit in Rescue Island to be more level headed while Marissa is more willing to be ruthless to the people who are considered her enemies.

5. The tiebreaker while still would be dumb on Isabel’s part for wanting to break Anastasia wouldn’t be called plot armor since Marissa had more time to shine and probably wrapped up her arc to leave Anastasia the spotlight once more.

Also this would have been the first time someone hands over an advantage to another player during their exit which we don’t usually see in these type of shows.

It feels like this is what they should have done and probably many people agree considering Marissa needed more time to be her own character. This wouldn’t just help her but everyone else she interacts with.