Would you take a lower day rate for an outside IR35 contract?
I’ve been offered a contract that’s outside IR35 but the day rate is quite a bit lower than some of the inside IR35 roles I’ve been seeing.
The difference is big enough that on paper the inside role actually comes out fairly similar, once I account for the different tax treatment.
I’ve always preferred outside because I like having the Ltd company, being able to retain some profit, pension contributions etc but I’m starting to wonder whether I’m putting too much value on the “outside” label and the contract itself looks decent and the working arrangements seem genuinely independent, so it’s not really an IR35-risk question. It’s more whether the extra admin and uncertainty are worth it for a lower rate.
For those who have done both recently, how much of a rate difference would make you choose inside over outside? like I’m curious what other contractors are actually doing rather than what the theoretical calculation says.