Login

u/Careful_Tap_2358

r/bookdiscussion r/Electronicsinindia r/UPSC r/upsc_discussions r/Caste r/UPSCBharat r/IndianReaders r/AppleIndia r/Indianbooks
Feedback Needed: UPSC Mains Enrichment Notes on Poverty
▲ 2 r/UPSCBharat+1 crossposts

Feedback Needed: UPSC Mains Enrichment Notes on Poverty

I prepared these notes after studying the Class 9 NCERT Economics chapter on Poverty, with a focus on GS3 Mains answer writing and enrichment through current affairs, data, reports, government schemes, and constitutional provisions. Some figures and current-affairs references are marked verify in red for future updating.

Would appreciate suggestions on the structure, content, and usefulness of these notes for Mains answer writing.

Thank you!

https://preview.redd.it/6eatzuvxwguh1.png?width=1800&format=png&auto=webp&s=f3d0505b0fe92bbe7e1758acbda2df1ff4e45f99

https://preview.redd.it/u2kb6000xguh1.png?width=1800&format=png&auto=webp&s=0d1749214bc42d96c006c2427f3c32c01694c860

reddit.com
u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 6 days ago
▲ 45 r/IndianReaders

An Indian trying to understand Pakistan beyond the media narrative - looking for recommendations

Hi everyone,

I'm trying to get back into some serious non-fiction reading, and I'm planning to approach it theme-wise. This week's theme is Pakistan.

I'm currently reading Pakistan: A Hard Country by Anatol Lieven, and I’ve realised how limited my understanding of Pakistan has been. Most of what I knew about the country came from news and media coverage, which often tends to focus on politics and conflict.

I'd like to go deeper and understand Pakistan from different perspectives - its history, culture, ordinary people, the experiences of women, Partition, politics, and even fiction by Pakistani authors.

If you've read any books that gave you a different, more human and nuanced perspective on Pakistan, I'd love to hear your recommendations. Both non-fiction and fiction are welcome.

Thanks in advance!

u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 2 months ago
▲ 9 r/IndianReaders+2 crossposts

Undercover - My Journey into the Darkness of Hindutva by Ashish Khetan [SOME THOUGHTS]

TL;DR: Investigative journalist Ashish Khetan spent 6 months in Gujarat in 2007 posing as a Hindutva sympathizer with a hidden camera. He recorded 60 hours of footage. The book is not about the sting, it's about what happened after - 13 years in court trying to make that footage count as evidence. Powerful as a document, uneven as a book. 4/5. Content warning for communal violence.

[PIC] Kindle in hand - Took this right after finishing it. Undercover by Ashish Khetan.

Dear folks, I just finished Ashish Khetan's Undercover, published by Context in 2020, and it is one of those books you need a break after.

The book looks at the 2002 Gujarat riots after the Godhra train burning of Feb 27, 2002. Official records say around a thousand people were killed, many more displaced.

In 2007, Khetan goes to Gujarat as Piyush Agarwal, a writer researching Hindu resurgence. Button camera on his shirt, camera hidden in a bag. He lives that life for six months, meets people who were part of the mobs.

In October 2007 Tehelka runs the story as a full issue, tapes play on national news. He expects resignations and arrests. That doesn't happen. The rest of the book is about that gap - between evidence and accountability.

What I felt after the read is - Khetan is not just a reporter here tbh. He became a prosecution witness in three massacre cases. So he writes both from the field and from the witness box.

A NOTE THAT WORTH TO KEEP IN MIND WHILE READING: Khetan later contested parliament election from Delhi in 2014 and headed a Delhi government body. So there is a political background which critics point to. The book doesn't hide it, but you should read it knowing it.

What worked for me:

  1. The method is not attack, but inaction. The book's strongest argument is that you don't need a written order to make a system fail. You just need it to not reach on time. He pairs hidden camera claims of being given time with police control room messages and the geography - Gulberg Society was 3 km from the control room, Naroda Patiya around 6 km.
  2. How cases fail before trial. Chapter 7 is the most shocking. He meets two public prosecutors who are supposed to argue against the accused. On hidden camera, one of them, who was also a VHP office bearer at the time, talks about coordinating between prosecution and defence and shares his case disposal numbers. The other talks about advising witnesses to compromise. It makes you rethink what justice depends on.
  3. Who participates. He doesn't describe hardened criminals. He describes small shopkeepers, people with no prior serious crime record. That ordinary-ness is more disturbing than any dramatic villain.
  4. The few who didn't bend. It's not all dark. There is a DySP who questioned files and was sidelined, officers who rescued 400 kids from a madrasa and got a transfer, a CBI team that excavated a riverbed for bodies when their own senior called it waste of money, and Judge Jyotsna Yagnik who said witnesses are the eyes and ears of her court.

Writing style:

It's non-linear. It cuts between 2007 sting and post-2010 courtrooms. He often just puts Q&A transcripts with no adjectives, no commentary. He also keeps his own uncomfortable parts in - laughing with them, praising them to keep cover, and later writing how ashamed he felt hearing it in court.

>Small details make it even more believable - button camera burning skin in heat, changing memory cards in a toilet because battery lasts an hour.

What didn't work for me:

  1. It is a single-voice book. You as a reader cannot verify the tapes. Courts and forensic labs said the footage was authentic, but you are trusting that process.
  2. It tells you WHAT happened in great detail, but not WHY so many ordinary people believed in it. There is little curiosity about the worldview of the other side beyond the confessions.
  3. Last three chapters on snoopgate, love jihad probe and Delhi riots feel rushed and repetitive. The tight undercover narrative is lost there.
  4. Timeline jumps a lot between 2004, 2007, 2010, 2013. Lots of similar names and initials. A timeline or cast list would have helped.
  5. The most serious allegations about conspiracy at the top - those were not accepted by SIT or courts. Khetan's counter is that the investigation itself was sabotaged. That is an argument to consider, but it remains an argument, not a court accepted fact. All concerned have denied the allegations. The book notes denials but doesn't deeply engage with the counter-case.

Who should read it:

  • If you care about investigative journalism, how a sting is planned, and how evidence travels or fails in Indian courts, it's essential. Useful for law students too, I think so!!.
  • If you want a balanced two-sided history of Gujarat, this is not that. It's a testimony, with the strengths and limits of a testimony.
  • If you read this, read Revati Laul's The Anatomy of Hate (I finished the read) and Rana Ayyub's Gujarat Files (my current read) alongside - they fill some gaps this book leaves.

Rating: 4/5 - As a record of how journalism can become evidence, it is rare in India. As a book, it loses direction at the end and repeats its conclusion.

The book is from 2020, many of the cases it discusses have moved since then, so check latest updates when you read.

reddit.com
u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 2 months ago
▲ 130 r/IndianReaders

Just finished Arundhati Roy's 'Mother Mary Comes to Me' - a daughter who refuses to sanctify her mother!! [SOME THOUGHTS]

I finished Arundhati Roy's new memoir Mother Mary Comes to Me a few days ago and haven't been able to stop thinking about it, so I'm putting my thoughts down here. Fair warning, this is long....

What it's actually about

The subject is her mother, Mary Roy.! In 1967 she started a school in Kottayam with seven kids. Later, in 1986, she took the Travancore Christian Succession Act to the Supreme Court and won, giving Christian women in Kerala equal inheritance rights to their father's property. A national feminist icon, a liberator to hundreds of students.

>The question at the heart of the book is one line - what was that liberator like to her own two children?

The reading experience

The first fifty pages I read in one sitting - Ooty, Ayemenem, Kottayam move fast. The Delhi/film/court/Kashmir sections in the middle slowed me down considerably; her mother almost recedes into a phone call, a distant voice. Then the "Madam Houdini" chapter pulls you right back by the throat.

I put the book down twice - once during the beating scene, and once during the hospital period after her mother came off a ventilator, when steroids caused temporary psychosis and she started sorting nurses by caste while her daughter just endured it. Then one night, for the first time in sixty years, the daughter finally reacts - throws a chair to the floor. Afterward she writes: "I thought I had killed my mother. But no. I had killed something in myself." That line followed me around for a week.

What's left after finishing isn't peace, it's unease. There's no tidy "in the end I forgave her." Instead she writes that when her mother died, she no longer understood who she herself was - because she'd built herself entirely around her mother.

Where I think it falls short

  • The political chapters in the middle (Narmada, Kashmir, the parliament attack case) recycle material she's covered before in essays. If you've read My Seditious Heart, expect some repetition.
  • Her brother doesn't get the space he deserves. He carried the heaviest part of their mother's cruelty as a kid, but the book never really lets us in.
  • Mary Roy never gets to speak for herself - this is entirely the daughter's lens, for better or worse.

Rating

4.5 out of 5. For a daughter who managed to look at her mother this precisely without hating her, without worshipping her, without extracting an apology.

Strongly recommend it if you loved The God of Small Things, or if you have a complicated parent of your own - it'll work like a mirror, and not always a comfortable one. Don't go in expecting a gentle mother-daughter story with a neat resolution. It will hurt.

u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 2 months ago
▲ 26 r/Electronicsinindia+1 crossposts

Bought an iPhone 17 from an Apple Premium Partner in India. Display defect in 3 days. Apple's response: "you bought from a reseller, so replacement is the reseller's decision." Here's the whole saga.

Posting this so others know what they're signing up for when buying Apple products from "Premium Partner" resellers in India instead of Apple directly.

What happened:

We bought a brand-new iPhone 17 (256GB) for ₹79,900 on 05/07/2026 from Imagine (Apple Premium Partner), Lulu Mall, Edappally, Kochi. Also paid ₹8,499 for Protect Plus with AppleCare. Total damage: ~₹88,400.

Within 3 days, we noticed a stuck sub-pixel on the display - permanently glowing blue. Invisible on white backgrounds, clearly visible on dark screens, grey shades, and during video playback. The phone was never dropped, no moisture, nothing. Textbook manufacturing defect on a 3-day-old panel.

What we asked for: Replacement of the device. Not a refund, not compensation drama - just a non-defective unit of the phone we paid for, 3 days in.!!!

What the store said: No replacement. Only inspection/repair under the warranty process.

So we sent a legal notice through an advocate to both the store and Apple India (Bengaluru), asking for replacement OR refund + a token ₹5,000 compensation.

Apple's official response (over two phone calls):

  1. Only a display replacement will be offered. Full device replacement "is not reseller's policy."
  2. And here's the part everyone should know - the rep explicitly said: devices bought directly from Apple are eligible for replacement if a defect appears early, but since ours was bought from a reseller, it's the reseller's decision whether to replace. The reseller said no, so Apple says their hands are tied.
  3. Compensation? Flat "no."

So the same ₹79,900 iPhone gives you materially weaker after-sales treatment depending on which counter you handed your money across. Nothing on the box or invoice tells you this at purchase time.

Where it stands: We're deciding between accepting the display replacement (with written conditions - genuine part, warranty untouched, service report recording it as a manufacturing defect) or filing at the District Consumer Commission via e-Daakhil. FWIW, consumer commissions have ordered Apple to replace/refund before - Chandigarh DCDRC ordered replacement or refund of an iPhone this year, and Rohtak DCDRC ordered a ₹45,500 refund in August. But those cases took 2+ years, and in ours Apple has offered a free repair, which weakens a deficiency claim. So we're realistic about it.

TL;DR / lessons:

  • If you're buying Apple in India, buy from apple.com/in or an Apple Store. Same price, but you get Apple's 14-day return window and direct accountability. Premium Partner ≠ Apple Store, and the difference only shows up when something goes wrong.
  • A "Premium Partner" board on the wall doesn't obligate them to replace even a 3-day-old defective unit.
  • Get everything in writing. Phone promises are worth nothing.
  • The Consumer Protection Act 2019 does hold manufacturers liable for manufacturing defects regardless of seller - but enforcing it means years at the commission, which is exactly what these policies bet on you not doing.

Has anyone here actually gotten a DOA/early-defect replacement out of an Apple Premium Partner in India? Or fought this at a consumer commission? Would genuinely like to hear how it went.

u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 2 months ago
▲ 1 r/UPSC

https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/health/latest-nso-results-show-rise-in-health-seeking-behaviour-relatively-low-out-of-pocket-medical-expenses/article70920419.ece

NSO's 80th round (2025) reveals PPRA nearly doubled since 2017-18, govt. health insurance coverage rose 3.5x in rural areas, yet institutional hospitalisation costs remain high and private sector usage is rising. Exposes paradox of coverage without care PMJAY failing to reduce OOPE despite expanded coverage.

🔗Universal Health Coverage in India + Ayushman Bharat: Gap Between Coverage & Care

Link to: PMJAY, Ayushman Arogya Mandir, NHM, SDG 3 (Good Health).

u/Careful_Tap_2358 — 6 months ago