Favourite episode with a weak plot
What’s your favourite episode with a plot that doesn’t hold up to much scrutiny?
Mine is SGA S1E15, “Before I Sleep”. I absolutely love that episode: it’s beautifully told, there’s some great Ancient tech, and we even get a glimpse into the final days of Atlantis before the Ancients abandoned Pegasus. What’s not to love?!
But… I really struggle with the central premise. Are we seriously supposed to believe the Janus had no way to automate rotating the ZPMs every ~3,500 years? He’d just been revealed as inventor of a Time Machine, something the Milky Way Ancients couldn’t even do. The entire plot depends on someone literally staying behind in stasis just to swap power sources on a schedule?
I get that the story only works if Weir stays behind; otherwise she would have returned to Earth with the Ancients and the timeline never happens. Still, it’s absolutely one of my favourite episodes. I love it.
What episodes do that for you?
Edit: typos