
Too tender?
My last few brisket cooks have been pretty similar: Costco prime brisket, 18-20lbs untrimmed, cooked double-indirect (no wrap, fat side up) overnight, removed from grill when probe tender at about 200 degrees, wrapped in foil and placed into a cooler for 4-6 hours.
TheI’ve all been absolutely delicious, but seem to be a little too tender for my taste. Enough that it’s difficult to slice in pencil thin slices.
I suspect that the cause may be too long of a rest in the cooler (it’s one of those yeti style coolers that promise to keep things hot or cold for days). Unfortunately, due to the way that my family works and the convenience of overnight cooks, it will probably be too difficult for me to plan for a shorter rest time in the cooler.
I’m wondering if next time, my course of action should be to remove from the BGE at 180 or 190 degrees, before the brisket is completely probe tender, wrap and place into the cooler. The long rest in the cooler may suffice to bring the brisket to probe tender without it being too tender.
What do you all think? Any other ideas?