AITH for skipping traditional weeding gifts, making my bridesmaids buy affordable dresses, and giving my fiance a suitcase instead of a romantic present?
I (32F) am marrying my fiancé (35M) in three months. We’re paying for the majority of the wedding ourselves, so I’ve been very budget conscious. However, my future MIL and a couple of bridesmaids are hinting that I'm being cheap and ruining the wedding.
First, I skipped bridesmaid proposal boxes. Spending $100+ per girl on matching satin robes and plastic tumblers is a waste of money. Instead, I used that exact $100 budget to buy them each a classic pair of real pearl earrings ($98) to wear on the day and keep forever.
Since bridesmaids pay for their own dresses, I chose an online bridal brand where all gowns are under $100 and size inclusive. Two of my bridesmaids complained to my MIL that the dresses feel cheap compared to custom designer gowns and that the aesthetic is compromised.
Now my MIL is furious over parent gifts. She insists we are obligated to buy her a luxury crystal mantel clock ($150) and an expensive embroidered handkerchief set to thank her for supporting us. She hasn't contributed a single dime to the wedding. I told her it’s not in the budget and that we are gifting all parents a high quality printed photo album afterward. She called me disrespectful for bucking tradition.
The final straw was last night. My MIL asked what I bought my fiancé as a groom's gift. Instead of a luxury watch, I got him a premium carry on suitcase ($170) and a nice leather watch travel roll ($89) to keep his collection safe.
My fiancé loves the gifts, but my MIL lost her mind. She told him I’m treating our wedding like a sterile business transaction, a suitcase is an insulting gift, and my cheapness is embarrassing. She’s now texting him saying she’s worried I’m cutting corners and ruining the spirit of the day.
My fiancé is defending me, but the constant comments are getting to me. AITA?