u/EntrySufficient4968

In the third chapter of Rhodes, there's an NPC you can interact with: Joe Butler, a former soldier. You can interact with him every three days in the game.

In the same chapter, the gang is trying to deceive the Greys and Braithwaite families amidst the tension caused by the Bounty Hunter's interference and the kidnapping of Trelawney.

The important thing is that when you interact with Joe Butler, even before your Greys and Braithwaite storyline is complete, Joe tells Arthur he shouldn't be there because he saw some Bounty Hunters and government agents asking about him and the gang.

So how come the Greys and Braithwaite didn't discover this? And don't tell me their goal is to exploit the gang, because it's still dangerous for an entire gang to be used by two sides and then kill them all.

I believe Micah desperately wanted Dutch, and this is evident when he begs him on the mountain as Arthur is dying. Some argue that he was dealing with the Pinkertons, which is true, but his collaboration with them was different from any other informant's dealings. Informants typically provide information to the government, but Micah was giving them what benefited him personally, which weakened the gang and isolated Dutch. I also believe that Micah severed his ties with the Pinkertons in 1907. The proof is that he formed his own gang and obtained what he wanted—Blackwater's money—and didn't kill Dutch. Why? Because he needed someone like him in his new gang, and he believed that he and Dutch formed a powerful duo.

From my perspective, Bill Williamson's presence with Allende, the regional governor, in Mexico is perplexing. How can the head of an American gang of thugs seek immunity from a regional governor? What does Allende want from him? They shouldn't be together. I need your opinions.

I think the most will answer because revenge forbarthur or making his last wish to save john but i think thats not true, i think that dutch is selfish and arrogant that he doesnt want to revenge for anyone else than himself, in chpater 4 we see dutch seeking for revenfe against angelo bronte because he made him like a fool, despite opposition hosea and dutch says is not revenge and take from diffrent perspective when he says that killing angelo bronte will weakining the law and, that arrogant from dutch that he take it from another prespctive to proof his point is the clue why he want revenge from micah, micah is the man who turned dutch against his best friends john and arthur and he turns out that he is a rat and destroy the whole dutch gang that started before 23 years, so that micah turns dutch is very fool is why dutch want revenge from, and i have a theory to why dutch rob the blackwater bank in rdr 1 to compensate the failure of ferry job and proof that he will succes of any plan that he do

I think the most will answer because revenge forbarthur or making his last wish to save john but i think thats not true, i think that dutch is selfish and arrogant that he doesnt want to revenge for anyone else than himself, in chpater 4 we see dutch seeking for revenfe against angelo bronte because he made him like a fool, despite opposition hosea and dutch says is not revenge and take from diffrent perspective when he says that killing angelo bronte will weakining the law and, that arrogant from dutch that he take it from another prespctive to proof his point is the clue why he want revenge from micah, micah is the man who turned dutch against his best friends john and arthur and he turns out that he is a rat and destroy the whole dutch gang that started before 23 years, so that micah turns dutch is very fool is why dutch want revenge from, and i have a theory to why dutch rob the blackwater bank in rdr 1 to compensate the failure of ferry job and proof that he will succes of any plan that he do

I think the most will answer because revenge forbarthur or making his last wish to save john but i think thats not true, i think that dutch is selfish and arrogant that he doesnt want to revenge for anyone else than himself, in chpater 4 we see dutch seeking for revenfe against angelo bronte because he made him like a fool, despite opposition hosea and dutch says is not revenge and take from diffrent perspective when he says that killing angelo bronte will weakining the law and, that arrogant from dutch that he take it from another prespctive to proof his point is the clue why he want revenge from micah, micah is the man who turned dutch against his best friends john and arthur and he turns out that he is a rat and destroy the whole dutch gang that started before 23 years, so that micah turns dutch is very fool is why dutch want revenge from, and i have a theory to why dutch rob the blackwater bank in rdr 1 to compensate the failure of ferry job and proof that he will succes of any plan that he do

I wish the game had focused more on and given more attention to the side characters of the camp, such as Pearson, Bill, Javier, and Hosea, etc... and given them their own arcs and storylines, like Sadie Adler and her character transformation, or John Marston and his change from a bad husband to a good one. I know Hosea received good attention, but I wish they had added one or two extra missions or made us connect with a personal event related to him. Also, Susan Grimshaw is a good character, and I wish they had focused more on her, and Dutch relationship with Molly should have been explored further. Arthur Morgan's missions reach 85 main ones, and they could have reached 120 if they had focused more on the other characters.

I'm very immersed in the story of Red Dead Redemption 2; I've probably finished it more than five times. But questions about the game keep popping up in my head, making me feel like there's a plot hole. What was Micah's main goal? If it was just Blackwater's money, why didn't he kill Dutch when he teamed up with 1907 and they took Blackwater's money? And what was the purpose of his collaboration with Pinkerton? Was it to create an escape route if he was captured, so he could say he was with Pinkerton and they'd let him go? Well, if that was his goal, why was he so insistent on accompanying Dutch when they were at the top of the mountain while Arthur was dying? Because Micah desperately wanted Dutch at that time. Did he act to create an escape route while he took control of Dutch's mind and they formed their own gang and cut the deal between him and Pinkerton ? , or was it just for Blackwater's money? What was Pinkerton's goal? Is it just about capturing Dutch, or is it about wiping out the entire gang? And why do they want Dutch alive? Is it for Blackwater's money? If it's for Blackwater's money, why did they attack him so fiercely in Lakkay? Also, if Micah was present, why attack the gang when their informant was there? Furthermore, in Beaver Hollow, when they learned of Dutch's camp, why didn't they attack him? So as not to repeat the same failure they had in the Lakkay attack? Why didn't they have some of their men keep watch until Dutch or any other gang member emerged, so they could capture them and try to turn them against Dutch?