“Silence, Survival, and Revenge: My Thoughts on Maid’s Diary” Spoilers
Maid’s Diary by Loreth Anne White was honestly a solid 4.5-star read for me. One of the biggest things this book highlighted was the issue of women constantly believing they have to fix, protect, or clean up the mess created by the men in their lives. The amount of assault and abuse that gets covered up by wives, mothers, girlfriends, and other women is honestly alarming. In many cases, men get away with horrible things because someone is trying to preserve an image while another person’s life is being destroyed in the process.
As much as men are often at the center of these issues, I personally believe a huge percentage of them continue getting away with it because of the women around them protecting reputations, families, or appearances.
Now, Boone’s character is still something I am trying to wrap my head around. I honestly do not know how you can claim to be a friend to someone who cannot have children because she was gang-raped, forced into an abortion, and ultimately lost her marriage because of that trauma — and still stay silent knowing the truth. That part was difficult for me.
At the same time, a part of me also felt like Boone may have been one of the reasons Kit stayed sane. His storyline also touched on discrimination and the fear surrounding sexuality. Maybe one day people will truly be free without being judged for their sexuality, skin color, or identity. I also understand how terrifying it must have been for someone who had never openly come out to his parents. Honestly, that kind of pressure can destroy people mentally. So despite my frustration with him, I still give his character some grace.
Kit, however, absolutely still needs therapy. No one should ever have to go through what she experienced. But I would be lying if I said I was not happy she got her revenge. What fascinated me most was wondering how long she had been living in darkness for her to create an entirely different personality just to survive. Trauma like that can turn someone into a shadow of themselves.
Personally, I think there are some holes therapy alone cannot pull you out of. Sometimes the only thing keeping someone alive is finally seeing light at the end of the tunnel — and for some people, that light becomes revenge.
Detective Mallory was also one of the most relatable characters in the book. She represents the idea of “if I keep working hard enough, maybe I will not have to feel how much I am hurting.” She is an amazing detective, married to a wonderful husband, yet suddenly faced with early dementia. Honestly, marriage vows scare me sometimes because “for better or worse” becomes very real in situations like that.
I also wonder if she would have poured so much of herself into work if her personal life had been perfect. Her job became both a distraction and an escape, but the story also shows that no matter how hard people try, reality eventually catches up to everyone. Every single character in this book had to confront the consequences and truth of their actions in one way or another.