u/Fickle_Baker1393

The Only Book Canon Children (so far)

The Only Book Canon Children (so far)

There's been 6 official Bridgerton next generation children born on the show as of S4 but we know that by S5 we could be getting possibly at least 4 or 5 more children born in the universe after the 2 year time jump. (Saphne will have Baby #3 and #4, Kanthony will have Baby #2, Polin will have Baby #2, and Benophie most likely will have a baby).

But only 3 of them are based on book canon: Oliver & Amanda Crane and Edmund Bridgerton II

The Official Children as of Season 4:

  • Oliver and Amanda Crane
  • Lord August Basset, Earl of Clydedon
  • Second Basset Baby (Name and Geneder unconfirmed)
  • Edmund Bridgerton II
  • Elliott Bridgerton, Lord Featherington

We don't yet know what gender or name Daphne's 2nd baby is that we saw in Queen Charlotte but if we go by book canon, her second baby is a girl named Belinda and the baby looked very much like a girl.

But the show has not followed the books any other time. All the other babies have been genderswapped and names changed except for Edmund and Oliver and Amanda.

I think we might get more baby name changes.

If we go by book canon we should expect S5 to let us know Kanthonys second baby is going to be a boy named Miles Bridgerton ​and Polins second baby is going to be Thomas Bridgerton (already confirmed they're having another boy in S5).

Benophies firstborn is supposed to be Charles Bridgerton but something tells me they're going to do another genderswap or rather, they're going to swap baby orders and have Violet Bridgerton as their first baby.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 4 days ago

Eloise's season has to come out in 2028

With Franchaela S5 being officially confirmed to come out in 2027, I can only imagine it'll come out in the first half of 2027 and no later than that which should put Philoise's season within the time frame and schedule of releasing in late 2028.

I think S5 is definitely coming out by June 2027 (Pride Month) and if it comes earlier, EVEN BETTER!

So if they are finished with the S6 scripts by June 2027 (like how they were done with the S5 scripts before S4 even released) they can start filming in July 2027 and be done by February 2028 and have the season out by September or October 2028.

I think that's reasonable.

That's barring they don't shove a Violet spin off prequel show before Philoise. I hope they don't.

They can release the Violet and Edmund prequel in 2029.

reddit.com
u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 7 days ago

I felt so bad for Eloise feeling left out 🥺

Seeing Eloise purposefully being left out of conversations with her "married sisters" and being forced to babysit her younger sister because her mother just cannot leave her alone about finding a husband was hard to watch. And seeing Eloise so lonely made me feel so bad for her.

She has no one to talk to and no one to relate to because everyone else is moving on with their lives and are at different stages but she's stuck.

It's going to be so much worse in S5 with the time jump and everyone in her life having multiple babies and getting married while she's stuck babysitting her younger siblings.

But this was sadly the life of a spinster at that time but it's still so sad to watch my girl Eloise go through this 😭

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 10 days ago
▲ 1.0k r/Bridgerton

One of my most anticipated scenes in Eloise's season

Need this scene adapted from the books on the show.

Eloise seeing Phillip's scars for the first time and demanding to know who hurt him and having Phillip relive his childhood trauma of abuse from his father will be poignant. I hope they do not cut it out of the show.

It's important to their relationship and Phillip's growth as a character in being vulnerable and open about his past trauma.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 10 days ago

Happy Mother's Day to the Bridgerton Mother's!

Happy Mother's Day to all 💕💕💕

And a special mother's day to all the Bridgerton moms!

I included all the mothers who have Bridgerton children in the family (whether by name or only by blood)!

Here's how many children they have in the books.

  • Daphne Basset - 5 kids
  • Kate Bridgerton - 4 kids
  • Sophie Bridgerton - 4 kids
  • Penelope Bridgerton - 4 kids
  • Eloise Bridgerton (soon to be Crane) - 5 kids (+including 2 adoptive step children)
  • Marina Crane - 2 kids (biological mother of Eloise's adoptive children)
  • Francesca and Michaela Stirling - 2 kids
  • Violet Bridgerton - 8 kids

P. S This is an aesthetic moodboard of the characters and not a reflection of the actual cast. Images used are NOT AI generated and are real photos with some being photos from projects the actresses were on (see Yerin Ha on Survivors where she played a mother). Mood Boards are meant to convey a similar vibe to characters you are basing them on.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 11 days ago

This scene was a perfect set up for Eloise's season but since she's not next, what will she be doing in S5?

When I saw this scene I foolishly thought this was a set up for Eloise to be S5 because Eloise was finally coming around to the idea of marriage and when she mentioned all the advantages marriage can have, it was totally setting her up to eventually have a marriage of convenience with Phillip but since we now know S5 is not Eloise's season I really fear they will just have Eloise just...there waiting for her turn or worse, they could have Eloise regress back to her old self of complaining about the marriage mart because that's what they do with her every season. She has growth and then the following season she is back to square one.

They have to keep this momentum.

We already know that Eloise won't be searching or seeking out love because Jess said her story will be about being "surprised by love not seeking it" so I don't see her engaging with suitors either.

And there's been no indication we will see Phillip next season so there's no way to even believe Phillip and Eloise will interact. Maybe the letters will start but I don't think we will see Phillip and her writing back and forth with each other and if we get letters it'll be in secret which... sucks.

I really don't know what they're gonna have her do next season. What will she be doing?

What theories do you guys have? What do you think she'll be doing next season?

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 12 days ago

Will Francesca's Practical Reason To Remarry Be For Children?

The official synopsis of Season 5 tells us that Francesca will reenter the marriage mart for practical reasons but when Michaela returns to London, Frans complicated feelings will have her questioning whether to stick to her pragmatic intentions or pursue her inner passions.

What if the pragmatic intention is to have a child?

In the book (When He Was Wicked), Francesca reentered the marriage mart because she wanted to remarry in order to have a child, not necessarily for love. In the first five chapters of the book, we got Francesca's first marriage, John's death, she has troubles conceiving for two years, her suffering a miscarriage and then the four year time jump after Michael left to see her seeing all the children in her family and all her nieces and nephews from Anthony, Benedict and Daphne's children and seeing that she desires a family and wants children of her own and so that was the primary reason why she rejoined the marriage mart to find a husband. But she has always shown she desired to have a family and she decides to remarry not because she wants to continue the Kilmartin line (which she couldn't have anyway as she's not a blood born Stirling) but because she genuinely wanted a family and it wasn't because of societal expectations of her to have one. She loved children and even after struggling for years to have children after marrying Michael, she managed to still have her happy ending (although it's important to note that Julia Quinn only decided to give Francesca and Michael children AFTER the fans asked for it which she did in a 2nd epilogue years later so Julia planned to not give Francesca children).

On the show, however, Francesca is shown to still fall in love and marry John, still struggle conceiving and still lose her husband in death but the key differences is that she did not have a miscarriage but instead she just had a hysterical pregnancy (her body and mind believing she was pregnant when she was not) ​​and her reasoning for wanting to give John children is societal. She felt like she was obligated to have an heir for the Kilmartin line and because John desired children.. There hasn't been any indication that Francesca genuinely wants children for herself which could explain how the show plans to explore her relationship with Michaela who is now a woman instead of a man.

So if she pursues being with Michaela does this mean she'll give up her desire to have a child? Will she realize that her need for a child isn't necessarily based on her desire for one for herself but because she feels she is expected to OR will she genuinely feel like she gave up something she wants just to be with Michaela because they know they cannot have biological children of their own together?

So many questions.

Curious what the answer will be.

OPINION: I personally think the story would've been stronger if Francesca came to this realization of wanting to have a child of her own again after seeing Eloise get married to a man with two children which would link both her and Eloise's stories together and seeing the unconventional family model of adoptive children/step children that Eloise ended up having could show Francesca that it is possible to have a family with Michaela despite the fact that it's not necessarily by blood relation but taking an orphaned child and choosing to raise them as her own. That's if she desires to have children because she genuinely wants them. That's one of the reasons why I think a season switch wouldn't have made sense if Francesca really wanted children for herself.

If they go the route that Francesca desires children because that's what society expects of her then I guess it won't matter because the reason for children isn't based on something she's missing in life and when she marries Michaela she won't feel like she gave up anything.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 13 days ago

Thought I'd make a post about when I think we could see Philoise's season (finally) based on the production duration history of the show.

I know we joke about how we will be waiting a long time for Philoise's season which could release in 2030 or 2035 or 2052 but in all seriousness, I don't see us waiting 4 more years for Philoise's season (but you never know with this production🙄). ​​

Season Scripts Writers' Rooms

They usually take 6 - 8 months to write the scripts for a new season.

  1. Season 1 - They took 6 months to write S1 although it did begin writing end of 2018.
  2. Season 2 - They took 6 months to write the scripts from June 2020 to December 2020.
  3. Season 3 - They took 6 months to write the scripts from October 2021 to March 2022.
  4. Season 4 - They took 8 months to write the scripts from October 2023 to May 2024.
  5. Season 5 - They took 7 months to write the scripts from May 2025 to January 2026.

Season Releases:

  1. Season 1 - December 2020
  2. Season 2 - March 2022
  3. Season 3 - May/June 2024
  4. Season 4 - January/February 2026
  5. Season 5 - 202?

Season Filming Schedule:

  1. Season 1 - 8 Months (July 2019 - February 2020)
  2. Season 2 - 8 Months (March 2021 - November 2021)
  3. Season 3 - 8.5 Months (July 2022 - March 2023) + 1 Month Reshoot (December 2023)
  4. Season 4 - 9 Months (September 2024 - May 2025)
  5. Season 5 - 8 - 9 Months (March 2026 - November)

Season Lead Announcement:

  1. Season 1 - Cast was announced in July 2019.
  2. Season 2 - Jonathan Bailey was announced as a lead in January 2021 and Simone Ashley was announced in February 2021.
  3. Season 3 - Luke Newton and Nicola Coughlan were announced as the leads in May 2022.
  4. Season 4 - Luke Thompson was announced as the lead in July 2024 and Yerin Ha was announced in August/September 2024.
  5. Season 5 - Hannah Dodd and Masali Baduza were announced as leads in March 2026.

Season Waiting Period

The wait between season announcements and the release is usually 15-18 months.

  1. S1s leads (Saphne) were announced in July 2019 with the rest of the cast and they announced that production has begun in the same month and S1 was released in December 2020 - 17 months.
  2. S2s lead (Anthony) was announced in January 2021 and S2 was released March 2022 = 14 months. 
  3. S3s leads (Polin) were announced in May 2022 and S3 was released in May 2024 = 22 months 
  4. S4s lead (Benedict) was announced in July 2024 and S4 was released in January/February 2026 = 18 months.

 

So we should expect S5 within the 15-18 period. 

From March 2026 to around June - August 2027 we should expect S5.

My verdict: May/June 2026 will be when S5 will come out to coincide with Pride Month 🌈

When Could They Start Writing Season 6?

They usually begin writing new scripts shortly before filming ends on the previous season.

Usually the same month or a month or two before filming ends.

The writers could likely begin writing the scripts for Season 6 in October 2026 when Franchaela's season is likely to stop filming.

There's a small chance they could begin writing earlier as well, but that's yet to be seen.

Verdict: September or October 2026 is when I think they could begin writing S6 with the potential of November being a viable date if filming is delayed somehow.

Commencement of Scripts - September - November 2026

Duration: September 2026 - February 2027 OR October 2026 - March 2027 OR November 2026 - April 2027.

When Could Season 6's Leads Be Announcement?

There's usually a month long break between a season is released and then the next leads are announced.

If Season 5 comes out in June 2027, we could get an announcement for Philoise's season in July 2027.

When Could Season 6 Begin Filming?

Filming usually begins shortly after all the scripts are done and shortly after a season is released.

There's usually a month break between the end of a season and the filming with the exception of Season 4s filming which was delayed due to the casting of Sophie.

Season 6 at least already have the leads of their season cast already so that's a relief.

Filming could begin filming a month after S5 OR the same month of S5s release depending on if they want to speed production.

Jess Brownell did say she will try to speed the seasons up.

Verdict: June 2027 - February 2028 (8 Months).

When Could Season 6 Be Released?

Like I said before, there's usually a 15 - 18 month gap between a previous season and a new season.

But with S5 likely coming out in 2027 instead of 2028, we could get a yearly release schedule for Bridgerton seasons now.

If S5 comes out in June 2027, we could see Philoise's season EARLIEST in September 2028 and latest January 2029.

Season 6 Release:

  • September 2028 (15 months)
  • October 2028 (16 months)
  • November 2028 (17 months)
  • December 2028 (18 months)
  • January 2029 (19 months)

Verdict: I think we are getting S6 in October 2028 for the fall season so ironically, the year many of us assumed Philoise's season would come out before the season switch is the year we could be getting it.

BUT this is only the best case scenario barring any delays or extensions or any unforseen occurrence such as a writers strike etc.

S6 - Philoise = October 2028.

reddit.com
u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 15 days ago

Thought I'd make a post about when I think we could see Philoise's season (finally) based on the production duration history of the show.

I know we joke about how we will be waiting a long time for Philoise's season which could release in 2030 or 2035 or 2052 but in all seriousness, I don't see us waiting 4 more years for Philoise's season (but you never know with this production🙄). ​​

Season Scripts Writers' Rooms

They usually take 6 - 8 months to write the scripts for a new season.

  1. Season 1 - They took 6 - 8 months to write S1 but we don't know exactly how long it was although it did begin writing end of 2018.
  2. Season 2 - They took 6 months to write the scripts from June 2020 to December 2020.
  3. Season 3 - They took 6 months to write the scripts from October 2021 to March 2022.
  4. Season 4 - They took 8 months to write the scripts from October 2023 to May 2024.
  5. Season 5 - They took 7 months to write the scripts from May 2025 to January 2026.

Season Releases:

  1. Season 1 - December 2020
  2. Season 2 - March 2022
  3. Season 3 - May/June 2024
  4. Season 4 - January/February 2026
  5. Season 5 - 202?

Season Filming Schedule:

  1. Season 1 - 8 Months (July 2019 - February 2020)
  2. Season 2 - 8 Months (March 2021 - November 2021)
  3. Season 3 - 8.5 Months (July 2022 - March 2023) + 1 Month Reshoot (December 2023)
  4. Season 4 - 9 Months (September 2024 - May 2025)
  5. Season 5 - 8 - 9 Months (March 2026 - November)

Season Lead Announcement:

  1. Season 1 - Cast was announced in July 2019.
  2. Season 2 - Jonathan Bailey was announced as a lead in January 2021 and Simone Ashley was announced in February 2021.
  3. Season 3 - Luke Newton and Nicola Coughlan were announced as the leads in May 2022.
  4. Season 4 - Luke Thompson was announced as the lead in July 2024 and Yerin Ha was announced in August/September 2024.
  5. Season 5 - Hannah Dodd and Masali Baduza were announced as leads in March 2026.

Season Waiting Period

The wait between season announcements and the release is usually 15-18 months.

  1. S1s leads (Saphne) were announced in July 2019 with the rest of the cast and they announced that production has begun in the same month and S1 was released in December 2020 - 17 months.
  2. S2s lead (Anthony) was announced in January 2021 and S2 was released March 2022 = 14 months. 
  3. S3s leads (Polin) were announced in May 2022 and S3 was released in May 2024 = 22 months 
  4. S4s lead (Benedict) was announced in July 2024 and S4 was released in January/February 2026 = 18 months.

 

So we should expect S5 within the 15-18 period. 

From March 2026 to around June - August 2027 we should expect S5.

My verdict: May/June 2026 will be when S5 will come out to coincide with Pride Month 🌈

When Could They Start Writing Season 6?

They usually begin writing new scripts shortly before filming ends on the previous season.

Usually the same month or a month or two before filming ends.

The writers could likely begin writing the scripts for Season 6 in October 2026 when Franchaela's season is likely to stop filming.

There's a small chance they could begin writing earlier as well, but that's yet to be seen.

Verdict: September or October 2026 is when I think they could begin writing S6 with the potential of November being a viable date if filming is delayed somehow.

Commencement of Scripts - September - November 2026

Duration: September 2026 - February 2027 OR October 2026 - March 2027 OR November 2026 - April 2027.

When Could Season 6's Leads Be Announcement?

There's usually a month long break between a season is released and then the next leads are announced.

If Season 5 comes out in June 2027, we could get an announcement for Philoise's season in July 2027.

When Could Season 6 Begin Filming?

Filming usually begins shortly after all the scripts are done and shortly after a season is released.

There's usually a month break between the end of a season and the filming with the exception of Season 4s filming which was delayed due to the casting of Sophie.

Season 6 at least already have the leads of their season cast already so that's a relief.

Filming could begin filming a month after S5 OR the same month of S5s release depending on if they want to speed production.

Jess Brownell did say she will try to speed the seasons up.

Verdict: June 2027 - February 2028 (8 Months).

When Could Season 6 Be Released?

Like I said before, there's usually a 15 - 18 month gap between a previous season and a new season.

But with S5 likely coming out in 2027 instead of 2028, we could get a yearly release schedule for Bridgerton seasons now.

If S5 comes out in June 2027, we could see Philoise's season EARLIEST in September 2028 and latest January 2029.

Season 6 Release:

  • September 2028 (15 months)
  • October 2028 (16 months)
  • November 2028 (17 months)
  • December 2028 (18 months)
  • January 2029 (19 months)

Verdict: I think we are getting S6 in October 2028 for the fall season so ironically, the year many of us assumed Philoise's season would come out before the season switch is the year we could be getting it.

BUT this is only the best case scenario barring any delays or extensions or any unforseen occurrence such as a writers strike etc.

S6 - Philoise = October 2028.

reddit.com
u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 15 days ago

The engagement rings for each of the ladies we've seen on the show have been shown to be period accurate with smaller diamonds, colored gemstones and pearls.

Which one is your favorite?

For me, Sophie's engagement ring is superior over the other rings. I'm not a big fan of the pearls for the other brides and it just feels like they were the same rings in different font, especially Kate and Penelope's rings.

Sophie's is also the prettiest because it has a ruby colored gemstone and I'm a big fan of colored diamonds! Ruby, emeralds, sapphire and topaz being my favorites. ​

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 15 days ago
▲ 1.6k r/Bridgerton

The Duke aka Simon Basset's crown has yet to be tipped when it comes to the face card of male leads. He's got such a remarkable face card!

All the men are handsome and gorgeous in their own individual ways but man... Rege Jean Page was BEAUTIFUL!

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 15 days ago
▲ 2.0k r/Bridgerton

Thank you to @/sovereignheritage on TikTok for this because it's better articulated and researched than how I could have ever compiled it but there's definitely a reason why they chose Francesca as the queer one because it would make the most realistic sense.

Not to mention, women in Scotland could inherit titles and estates because their rules of succession aren't as strict as English rules were so Michaela will be Countess of Kilmartin.

P. S. I'm addressing the comments of those who said a lesbian romance like Franchaela would've been historically inaccurate to the time period as to why it shouldn't have happened.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 18 days ago

According to Jess Brownell, there will be three/four core characters that will be important in Eloise's season and story.

  • Benedict and Sophie
  • Kate
  • Penelope

Now whether any of these things come into fruition and in what capacity they are all important remains to be seen because Jess has a history of overexemplifying/overstating and exaggerating the importance of certain characters in seasons.

For instance, I don't really expect Kate to be such a CRUCIAL role in Philoise's season because they are barely using her now.

I think if anything Kate will probably be present in Eloise's season to offer advice to her in a scene or two and then we don't see her again until the wedding probably.

Before S3, Jess said we will see more of Eloise and Kate's friendship and bond and we only got that one scene of them together in S3.

So it's good to keep our expectations low for our faves having any significant subplot in Eloise's season.

With Nicola having significantly less screentime in S5 as well, I don't expect Penelope to suddenly appear as a secondary character in Eloise's season either.

Yes, they are best friends and of course Penelope will be involved in Eloise's love story but I do not think they will give Penelope or Colin some BIG MEATY subplot in her season. Penelope wasn't even in Eloise's book.

I also think whatever Benophies subplot in S6 will be significantly reduced from the major subplot they had in Eloise's book as well.

Jess already promised that Philoise's season will be different from the book. I'm prepared to see a lot of changes and lots of cuts of storylines from the books.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 20 days ago

I find it so funny that the siblings who had their seasons swapped/delayed are the fan favorite sibling duo who are against convention.

It's almost so on brand for them to not follow tradition even in their season order 😂

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 21 days ago

I keep thinking about the day we will see Eloise as a lead and seeing her journey as she falls in love with someone, have all the romantic love scenes that all the other siblings have had, give/receive those bridgerton love confessions and experiences her sexual awakening.

It doesn't fathom in my head we will actually see Eloise having a love story. Everyone deserves to be loved even Eloise.

And it pains me to think so many people do not want that for Eloise. They want her to never be loved loudly, to never be touched lovingly, to never be seen or appreciated by the partner who will support her for the rest of her life.

Eloise deserves an epic romance! I'm so excited for her season.

And it's always the ones who you least expect to find love to be the ones who love HARD and I think Eloise will be the one who will be hit the hardest when it comes to love because she never thought it would happen for her 😭

And it's always the ones who aren't love crazy and wouldn't normally fantasize or dream about sex who are the freakiest as well so we can be sure Eloise is gonna be a certified freak 👀.

The reluctant lovers are always hit like a tsunami when they meet the person who makes them believe that love is possible for them and that internal battle between wanting to hold onto your singleness and independence vs. letting yourself be loved and appreciated by someone and giving that same love and devotion to someone else is going to be such a joy to watch.

Her season will be the most interesting for sure. Can't wait for it to come out in 2052.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 22 days ago

I have my problems with Jess Brownell and how she's handling Eloise's story so far but I can say with full confidence I have no doubts that she will have Eloise end up with Phillip.

She said so on a number of interviews in the S4 press that she will end up with the love interest from the book and she never said Phillip by name because unfortunately it's a spoiler (and I hate that they're treating it as a spoiler because the name is on the cover of the book. It's TO SIR PHILLIP WITH LOVE).

So anyone still having doubts or having hopes for a different endgame need to put that to bed.

But we can hope that it won't be book accurate so we can imagine they're going a different direction for Phillip and Eloise's love story while keeping the core beats of the book which I think can be a good thing.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 22 days ago

I, like many people, have been so dissatisfied with the way Eloise has been written in the past 2 seasons of the show.

Although she made some strides in Part 2 or S4, it still feels like we're treading the same waters over and over...and over...and over again with the material they keep giving Eloise every season.

It's like she is forced to learn the same lessons again and again and somehow every season she manages to piss off another one of her sisters or friends who she had to apologize to in the end...

Don't get me started on what they keep giving her for her relationship with Violet who is making her stance against marriage snd love seem like some childish, immature tantrum that Eloise needs to get over which is so... ICKY imo.

There's a nuanced way they could've approached Eloise's disdain for the marriage mart without making it a "Eloise is just an immature girl who will grow out of this phase in her life once Violet knocks some sense into her".

But I suppose it's more realistic that a Regency era noble woman like Violet would think that way about her daughter's disinterest in marriage...

But they could've given Eloise better material to work with surely other than only complaining about the marriage mart and debutantes.

It's getting tired and boring frankly.

And again she is constantly used as the anti-romance character which is kind of odd for such a romance focused series and they sort of make her seem like an antagonist in a romance show which isn't how they should be using such a modern, progressive character like Eloise.

That's why I really enjoyed Eloise in the first 2 seasons and I love what they did with her character (for the most part). They made her so interesting and gave her such interesting storylines.

Even the storylines I despise the most for her like the whole Lady Whistledown hunt that was repetitive the first 2 seasons, was still interesting because it allowed us to see her play an active role in actually DOING something for herself. She was an investigative detective living her Nancy Drew era and I loved that for her so much. ​​

Even the addition of Theo (which in hindsight I have problems with) allowed us to see a side of Eloise we have never seen and that's her being open to romance and seeing how she acts just like every other teenage girl when she meets a cute guy that intrigues her and dispels any notion that she was anti-love or anti-romance.

But S3 and S4 have torpedoed all that development and sent her back to square one and I can't help but attribute that to the showrunner switch.

CVD clearly had plans for Eloise and I think he mentioned before that Eloise is his favorite character (don't quote me) so I can only imagine how many cool ideas we could've gotten from him with Eloise if he stayed for S3 and S4. Eloise could've had a university arc that she's always wanted since S1 or something... She could have formed friendships with women of the working class or something I don't know.

She could've had so many fun storylines under CVD and we probably would've SEE Phillip on the show a lot more and made him an actual supporting character to set up their season because it's no coincidence that all the times we saw Phillip was when CVD was the showrunner.

Now she's just...stuck .

CVD had big plans for Eloise but we will never know what they were...

And that's what I'm mourning.

"What if"...

I love Eloise so much and I wish she was written by showrunners and writers who loved her just as much as her core fans do.

I can't imagine they just throw Eloise into her season expecting the audience to just accept that she's going to be this woman who is ready for love and marriage and everything her siblings have without any sort of narrative arc and reasons why she got to that place.

I don't want her to be just relegated to a one off line at the end of S5 that tells us she is ready for love. 🙄

Although I dont agree with CVDs choices during his tenure as showrunner (please for the love of God no more love triangles) I did love what he did with Eloise for the most part and that's because he LOVES Eloise.

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 23 days ago

Queer relationships especially lesbian relationships have been around for centuries and so contrary to the belief of certain naysayers, it's totally possible for a lesbian relationship to exist in the world of Bridgerton (which is already a historical fantasy fictional world of our world anyway where racism doesn't exist anymore and we have a black English queen).

So Franchaela can have a happily ever after if they take inspiration from Boston marriages.

Women were encouraged to have companions and female friendships and it wasn't illegal for two women to live together as it would've been for two men to cohabitate in a non-family way.

They can make it work. They can even have a wedding for Franchaela even in a church before God (see Anne Lister and Ann Walker for reference).

u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 24 days ago

I've seen this topic discussed on the reddit, subreddit and other social media platforms with fans wondering if the show is going to legalize gay/lesbian marriages through The Queen or the monarchy or something of that variation so that Michaela and Francesca can marry each other in the end.

I think it's a nice idea since the show is already incredibly anachronistic and changes a lot of things that would've otherwise never have happened in the 19th Century Regency England but I personally think legalizing gay marriage 200 years before it's common in our society isn't the way the show is gonna go in my opinion.

But it also would incredibly impact Gregory's season.

If you don't know... Here come spoilers!

&gt;!Lady Lucy Abernathy is the late Earl of Fennsworth's daughter and after her father died, she and her older brother are the taken in by their uncle who then raises them until her older brother Richard is old enough to take over as earl!<

&gt;!Fast forward, Gregory falls in love with Lucy Abernathy (after falsely believing he was in love with her best friend Hermione for half the book) who is betrothed to Lord Haselby, a family friend who her uncle arranged to be married/promised to marry off to him when she was a child because of a business agreement and so both of them were forced to marry but they are also getting married to hide a secret and that is Lord Haselby is secretly a gay man who needs a lavender marriage to hide his true self from the public because being gay as man is illegal in the 19th century that could have him imprisoned and even when Lucy finds out about this, she isn't bothered by it but this is just a tip in the iceberg at the chaos that ensues from this book but Lord Haselby being gay was important in the story and crucial to why there was even a lavender marriage agreement in the first place!<.

So if the show takes away this element by legalizing gay marriage in the ton, then there wouldn't be any reason to include this storyline, surely? He would be free to marry whoever he chooses to marry without any shame. This would fundamentally change their story.

That's why I just don't personally see them legalizing gay marriage.

Queer women in that time had it easier than men did and could have happy lives with their female partners even though it was still frowned upon.

Many women took "companions" as roommates/housemates, especially if they were widows. Most of them were family, and others were friends. And there were a few women who chose to be spinsters all their lives who lived with another spinster in a shared household and the ton doesn't question it.

And sometimes some of these women were allowed to marry albeit it wasn't legally binding.

Take Anne Lister for example who "married" her female lover/partner in 1834 when they took communion together in front of a church which even though it wasn't a legal marriage, it was a marriage recognized by God.

I could see this being similar to what will happen to Franchaela.

reddit.com
u/Fickle_Baker1393 — 25 days ago