




How the Swiss Tried to Fight Back Against the Japanese in Uruguay During the Quartz Crisis -- in formerly secret documents...or how Patek and Bulova nearly shared a movement
The Quartz Crisis is often discussed in terms both vague and dismissive -- oh, yeah, the Japanese arrived with a superior technology, Hong Kongers produced it cheaply, and the Swiss nearly went belly-up, save for the heroic efforts of a man named Hayek.
That all may be true if you take the widest possible lens, or from the distance of the year 2026 -- a half-century after the events in question. But during the slow, painful, grueling loss of a customer base, the Swiss writhed and wriggled -- did their best to escape the trap like a squealing mouse on a Manhattan apartment sticky-pad (if you've lived here, you know).
Take for example the above Swiss government document, formerly undisclosed -- of which I've posted only a few pages, as I've been chastised previously for posting so-called walls of text.
The rundown: July, 1970. Gerard Bauer, head of the FH (essentially the main Swiss watch cartel organization), and his cronies, including the head of Swiss watch evangelism in the region, a man normally based in Sao Paolo, meet the local Swiss diplomats in Uruguay. Of course, the challenge is that the Japanese have captured the local market. How to fight back? We're in the trenches now, boys. Bauer is frantic -- he has been traveling the continent trying to save Swiss market share -- he's been to Recife, Rio, Sao Paulo, Buenos Aires, Rosario, Lima, Bogota, and Caracas on just this trip.
The meeting is fascinating. One presentation: in 1966-67, all vended watches locally were Swiss. But the Japanese have built from the ground up an infrastructure so robust that retailers have dropped Swiss watches from their storefront displays entirely. The Japanese have mastered local distribution and importation, the sale of parts, publicity.
Theirs is an operation predicated on hunger and discipline. The Swiss, by contrast, have been complacent and lazy. What they had once in the market they expected always to have.
The solutions? They come up with two fascinating ones, though neither is ever implemented, as far as I know. The local Swiss-importer-distributer who controls Universal Geneve, Patek Philippe, Angelus and Bulova here argues that there must be a strong campaign such as the wool and natural fiber industry waged against synthetic, polyester sweaters and textiles. Make the Japanese watches seem functional but fake -- lab-grown, ponderous, just inorganic and unnatural. The Swiss watches are natural fibers such as cotton and wool -- they will hug your body and let you breathe. Thusly should the Swiss fight back in the marketing realm, says the man who sells Pateks and UGs in Montevideo.
An interesting smear campaign and one with an unquestionable quantum of creativity. But Gerard Bauer -- the head of the FH, the cartel -- has perhaps a more intriguing idea. If we supplied you, Uruguayan importers with just a few standard calibers, if we cleared up with this in-house caliber confusion, which only serves to confuse customers, would you all be willing to unite your vending efforts under just three brands? NO more Patek versus Rolex or anything like that -- to regain market share, would you just band together and sell three brands -- your pick -- that use the three standardized calibers we, the Swiss, should have ready for you by mid-1971?
Welcome to the era of streamline or die. Now, it's not clear anything from this meeting was ever implemented in LATAM. Nor is it the least bit clear that consolidation in such a manner would have beaten back the Japanese. This truly remains a case study in business that has still barely been studied. Nobody knows about these government memos. About the frantic machinations of watchmakers suddenly excluded from the party, trying to figure out desperately how to get back in.
But yes, if these ideas had been followed, you would have had ads targeting Seiko as Dacron, you would have had Bulova and Patek sharing movements, perhaps.
Wild stuff -- and only found out because I worked my tail off researching the secret history of historical, transnational watch chicanery for my new book, out now: "Borrowed Time: A History of Espionage, IP Theft, and the Global War for Horology."
Hope you've enjoyed this post and find more to enjoy in the text if you get there