
The Nahel Shooting: Unpacking the Myths, the Chase, and France’s 2023 Riots – Inside the Book *Dernier Recours*
On June 27, 2023, in the Paris suburb of Nanterre, a French police officer fired a single shot that killed 17-year-old Nahel Merzouk during a traffic stop. Within hours, a short viral video—missing the events that came before it—sparked nationwide riots and intense debate in France. What followed were several days of widespread unrest that caused over €1 billion (roughly $1.1 billion) in damages to businesses, along with political statements and claims that quickly formed a dominant narrative. The book Dernier Recours (Last Resort) by journalist William Molinié reconstructs the full sequence hour by hour using investigative records, witness statements, and official findings. (Note: The book is currently available in French; no English translation has been released as of today) It does not take sides or judge; it examines what was publicly claimed versus what the evidence supports.
The initial public understanding in France rested on several assertions that later investigation contradicted. Officers never shouted "Shoot him" ("Shoote-le"), as investigators determined. No blow was struck with a gun butt before the shot. The incident was not a simple routine identity check but followed a two-minute-plus high-speed chase in which the car endangered bystanders near a school. Expert analysis of the vehicle confirmed Nahel restarted the car voluntarily (performing multiple deliberate actions: pressing the start button, shifting into gear, and accelerating), not by reflex or after being hit. The officer did not fire with the intent to kill but as a last resort to stop a vehicle that had repeatedly tried to drive away, endangering lives — hence the book’s title Dernier Recours. The widely circulated 40-second clip omitted this critical prelude; even its author later expressed regret over the incomplete framing.
These distortions shaped the broader reaction across France. While outrage over the death played a role, surveys of those who rioted showed only about 8% were primarily motivated by Nahel’s death, with group dynamics (29%) and thrill-seeking (23%) figuring more prominently. The unrest was neither purely spontaneous nor ended solely by external actors such as drug dealers protecting their turf; rioters largely ran out of fireworks and ammunition against police. Far-left militants under court exclusion orders participated actively, including in attacks on police infrastructure. Early political statements, including from President Macron, were made before key facts emerged, helping lock in the initial story that later evidence complicated. The officer’s account, by contrast, remained consistent across all hearings.
Article in French : https://www.lefigaro.fr/faits-divers/affaire-nahel-il-a-bien-tente-de-redemarrer-quatre-fois-avant-le-tir-du-policier-releve-william-molinie-20260331
Nota : The book is much better than my write up. A previous version of this story made without having read the book was very confusing. I hope this one will be better.