commander night RANT
okay so i need advice. tell me how i should’ve handled this. i go to commander night tonight and walk up to a pod and see if they need a fourth. they do! so i sit down and join. i pull out my low bracket 3 choco, and everyone else pulls out their commanders. one guy is running teval with proxies (he asked if we’re okay with proxies and i said yes as long as you’re not proxying anything crazy) and another guy is running chatterfang. i run squirrels myself with hazel as the commander, but i have the chatterfang/pitiless plunderer/ warren soul trader combos along with some other 3-4 piece infinites. i ask the table “oh i would love to play my squirrels too, but it has infinites are we okay with that?” they all say no, this is around low bracket 3. fine! no issues i’ll play choco.
everything is going okay, squirrel man plays chatterfang turn 3 and i counter it because i know what he does and i need more time because he has tireless provisioner out as well. turn 4 he casts him again. fine i’ll let him through. game is playing as normal. first, teval man is milling through his deck and mills a rhystic study. my face is 😐 but i let it go because its whatever. then, turn 5 squirrel man plays PITILESS PLUNDERER. i IMMEDIATELY say “uh that goes infinite” and everyone plays dumb. so i explain it, and i say “i thought we weren’t doing infinites? i would’ve played hazel” and the squirrel man goes “oh i didn’t even realize it went infinite.” my face: 😐😐😐😐. OF COURSE YOU KNEW. i counter it, then by doing that i put a big fat target on my head and even though i had 15 life and they had 40, squirrel man and teval man were attacking me incessantly and i lost shortly after.
so my question is, what should i have done in this case? should i have been more clear at the beginning talking about brackets? should i have said something different? i’m relatively new to commander night so i dont know if this is just something that happens.