WIBTA for telling my sister “and you wonder why you don’t have any friends?”
My younger sister regularly complains about having no friends. It’s to the point where, whenever I make plans with my friends, it’s a huge spectacle where she rolls her eyes and has a very obvious “if I can’t have friends, no one can” attitude. However, there have been many, many times where I’ve really wanted to say “how do you not realize why you don’t have friends?”
The reason behind that is the way she treats me and my mom (her family), strangers, and just how she acts overall. She can’t take responsibility or accountability for anything. She refuses to learn from her mistakes and try to act like a better person. She leaves messes all around the house and trash on the ground, then gets mad at anyone who tells her to clean up. Whenever me or my mom is upset or had a rough day, she never does anything to comfort us or even show us she cares. She just sits on the couch and stares at her phone while me and my mom are emotionally and physically there for each other. She’s incredibly judgmental and rude and goes around making comments about strangers to me, calling them “fat” or “cringe“ or “ugly” or anything else. Not to their faces, but nonetheless. She’s incredibly entitled and has no concept of how money works despite having a job. If something is expensive, she’s just like: “yeah, so? Get it for me.” She argues with me and my mom on literally everything and regularly calls us stupid. Most recently, she got into a fight with my mom because my mom said we needed to be eating more leftovers as to not waste food because we have medical bills to pay. My sister‘s argument against this was “I don’t want to.” Emotions are a complete annoyance to her unless they’re her own. She doesn’t care when anyone else is sad, but expects everyone to care when she’s sad.
The most ironic thing is that she regularly tells me how I should act around other people. She insults me and says things like: “nobody will want to be friends with you if you do that. Why do people want to hang out with you?” The things I’m doing when she says that? Trying to teach my mom the Cotton Eye Joe dance or having harmless fun in public that, yes, some people might call cringe. Now I don’t deny that I have flaws too and it contributes to how she treats me. I can be controlling and demanding and act like the parent when I shouldn’t, especially since my dad’s passing. But personally, I’ve been working on it in therapy (among other things), and I feel I’ve really improved. My sister, meanwhile, refuses to work on her own behavior and has to be forced to by my mom. I’m also aware that people can act very differently around their family vs. their friends. However, if someone treats their caring family and strangers in public this badly and also happens to have no friends, is it really just a coincidence?
In so many of these moments (they come up pretty often), I feel the urge to say “you treat us like this and you wonder why you don’t have any friends.” I haven’t yet because it feels like it’d be out of line for me to say (that would be my mom’s job or someone else’s), but I’ve been thinking it more and more often. Would I be the asshole if I told her that she shouldn’t wonder why she doesn’t have any friends when she treats the people who are around her so badly?
TLDR; My sister is a judgmental asshole to strangers and her own family and then wonders why she has no friends. Would I be the asshole if I told her that she shouldn’t wonder why she doesn’t have any friends when she treats the people who are around her so badly?