u/Less_Zone_6767

​

One thing I'm still confused about is Ian's whole plan from the beginning.

Why was he pushing Bear so hard to confess to Nikki when he had history with her himself? What was he actually expecting to happen? Was he genuinely over Nikki and just wanted his friend to be happy, or did he think that if Bear and Nikki got together, it would somehow make Nikki realize she still had feelings for him later?

Also, when Bear and Nikki were alone at the bar, Ian kept interrupting them. At the time I thought it was weird because he knew Bear was trying to make a move. Obviously the later reveal explains some of it, but why was he acting like that when he was literally the one pushing Bear to ask her out .

Another thing: after Bear said Nikki was freaking him out, Ian actually spoke to Entity Nikki himself. Didn't he realize something was seriously off about her? He even seemed suspicious later and kept saying something wasn't right with her.

So if he already noticed something was wrong, why was he so quick to dismiss Bear when Bear finally told him about the One Wish Willow? That's the part I don't fully get. Ian seemed more aware than everyone else that something was off, but then when Bear gave him an explanation, he acted like Bear had completely lost it.

​

Why didn't the curse seem to affect the people leaving online reviews?

Some of them were saying their wishes actually worked, but they still seemed completely sane and normal enough to leave reviews. If they knew what happened and understood the consequences, why were they basically recommending it to other people instead of warning them?

And then there were people saying it didn't work for them at all. Is there an explanation for why it works for some people and not others?

Also, I've seen a theory that everyone who makes a wish has some sort of death wish. Bear died, which eventually led to Spell/Nikki dying, and she had also made a wish. Then Ian died too, and he made a wish as well. I don't fully buy that theory lol, but it did make me wonder if there's supposed to be a connection there.

​

I don’t really see the hype of it, and I’m genuinely asking this in a non-hate way. I just want a proper reason why the series is so popular. Is it the acting? I think the FL’s acting isn’t great, no offense. The plot… I don’t think it really exists.

The love triangle is, in my opinion, one of the worst I’ve watched. I don’t really think dating both of the lead guys is a proper love triangle, and I got the biggest ick from it. I thought Belly and Jeremiah only happened because they needed to create a rivalry vibe between Conrad and Jeremiah.

The only thing I actually like about the show is Conrad. Conrad and Belly together seem good to me, I actually like them.

I really don’t want to get downvoted, please don’t lmao. I also don’t want people saying “if you don’t like it, don’t watch it,” because I’m not here to hate I genuinely want to know what’s good about the show from your perspective or what makes it different from other shows .