Court of Garenbrig + Doubling Season

Hey gang! I run a +1/+1 counters deck and I have a question about an interaction between two of my keystone cards.

Court of Garenbrig makes me the monarch upon entry, and that's where the question in my pod arose. The first trigger distributes two +1/+1 coutners, then doubles all counters on a creature if I'm the monarch. I'm going to use Doubling Season as an example, but the question also applies to any other doublers I have in my deck.

Does Court of Garenbrig count as two separate triggers for Doubling Season, or is it all one?

The two +1/+1 counters are easy, those become four counters. Neat! But after that, does Doubling Season trigger on the Garenbrig doubling effect?

Using an example of a 1/1 lil guy. If CoG has one trigger:

Court of Garenbrig: 2 +1 counters

Doubling Season: 4 +1 counters

Monarch: Double the counters (4 doubles to 8)

Total: 8 +1/+1 counters, 9/9 Creature

But if Doubling Season sees the "...then double the number of coutners" as a separate thing which will also trigger Doubling Season:

Court of Garenbrig: 2 +1 counters

Doubling Season: 4 +1 counters

Monarch: Double the counters (4 doubles to 8)

Doubling Season: Double the counters again (8 doubles to 16)

Total: 16 +1/+1 counters, 17/17 Creature

As you can see, if "...then if you're the monarch, double the number of +1/+1 counters" is the questionable part here. Is that a separate instance of counters that would proc Doubling Season an additional time? What's the ruling on this?

Thanks!

reddit.com
u/LoveStoryGaming — 8 days ago
▲ 138 r/jankEDH+2 crossposts

Lord of Pain Sadism Deck

Hey all,

I'm designing a deck with The Lord of Pain as a commander! I want to build around the theme of saidsm, and my goals are pretty specific. I'm building this as a Dom Sadist deck, and I don't necessarily need it to win. I want games against this deck to feel like being in a Saw movie or an intense BDSM session. The goal is to make game states that force sadistic choices, pit the other players against each other, and/or create scenarios that just hurt to be in. I don't plan on running this in random LGS games, but for people who know what they're getting into and, crucially, consent to it.

Cards I currently have planned are:

Sadistic Shell Game

Prisoner's Dilemma

Xantcha, Sleeper Agent

Electrodominance

I could use a hand with this! I'm only getting back into the game after a 15 year hiatus, and I'm wanting to make something fun for the polycule on game nights. What do you suggest for adds to the deck?

Thanks!

u/LoveStoryGaming — 3 months ago