Would you say that a perfectly decade accurate kit for a poorer soldier is actually less accurate than a kit that's a mismatch from different decades?

First and foremost, this is just a random thought I had when sleep deprived and had nothing to think about, also I'm the prime example of an armchair historian so please take everything with a grain of salt and my bad is this is a stupid question.

Anyway, I've seen the topic of armor inheritance brought up a few times recently and that got me wondering

"If armor is expensive to the point where people would pass down helmets and maille shirts through multiple generations then would a poorer soldier in 1430~ who has all his equipment made in a style from the 1430s actually be less accurate than a poorer solifer in 1430~ who has a dagger from 1430~, a helmet from 1410~ and a cuirass from 1390~?"

I have heard about munition armor made from cheap wrought iron so I guess that could completely dismantle my idea but it's like a semi fun thing to wonder about, in my opinion.

reddit.com
u/MT2113 — 19 hours ago

Maile sabatons with plate leg harness and standard/collar under bevor

I've seen these two combinations before so I'm wondering if they're accurate

Unfortunately I was able to find only one picture only for the maile sabatons but hopefully you understand what I'm talking about

u/MT2113 — 1 month ago

Advice for a begginer and also for my build?

I have only been playing around 30 ish hours so I'm far from the best which is very obvious on the rare occasion I decide to tackle legendary difficulty

I'm mainly looking for advice on what weapons, talents, properties etc I should use and what to focus on improving. I have heard that defense and dodging are crucial so that's mainly what I want to get better at. As for my build, I'm still unsure on what type of playstyle I prefer but I guess I want something more tanky that is great at dealing with hordes

u/MT2113 — 1 month ago

What are the real world counterparts of each faction?

While I do have a general idea of what culture most factions represent I wanted to make sure if I was wrong, which I probably am, and what some other factions are inspired by.

Empire- Byzantine

Vlandia- Normandy

Khuzite- Mongol

Aseria- Mali Empire (?)

Nords- Nordic tribes

Strugia- I don't muck about this one but my best guess is Anglo Saxon

Battania- Same as with Strugia, my guess is that it's another vaguely nomadic culture turned kingdom

These are just my guesses and some of them are very likely wrong

reddit.com
u/MT2113 — 1 month ago

Was messing around with cheats and this happened [KCD2]

After having played a little over 350 hours, having beaten nearly every side quest this game has to offer and currently on my 3rd hardcore playthrough I decided that I deserve to have a bit of fun so I started making outfits by getting items via cheats. After finally making something I like I dumped everything I had over at Tachov, including visored bascinets, cuirasses and brigandine, limbs harnesses, war horse tack, shields, crossbows, polearms and a few sketches of prized weapons Radovan would appreciate. I think that Tachov might just surpass Troskowitz as the biggest village in Trosky

u/MT2113 — 1 month ago

How much did an arm harness interfere with shooting from a longbow?

I've seen quite a few depictions of archers, specifically English longbowmen, having a full leg harness yet little to no arm protection so that got me wondering if an arm harness made shooting much more difficult to the point wealthy bowmen would opt in to have a full leg harness but only lightly protected arms

Image is from Alex the History guy on YouTube and the video is called "How a Saint George English Longbowmen shall be armed"

u/MT2113 — 2 months ago

Just started this "Medieval" thing. When does Radzig appear? [Other]

u/MT2113 — 2 months ago

  1. Is there a name for the leather strap between the breastplate and plackart and what purpose does it serve?

  2. What exactly is he wearing with the plackart? I've seen this type of combination multiple times but the answers seem conflicted. Some people say that it's a brigandie, others a corazzina and a few a textile covered cuirass so I'm pretty confused on what it is

  3. Is that triangular piece a tasset? Is there any name for it? Where was it used in?

  4. Did squared besagew rondels exist? Do we have a specific name for that type and where did it originated from? How common was it compared to the typical round rondels we see in most examples?

  5. What is that half backplate called?

  6. What are the differences between English and Milanese plate harnesses?

Thanks for all the replies and answers in advance

u/MT2113 — 2 months ago

I basically just want to have a feature where I can select a few troops in my party and tell them to wait in a settlement while I take the marine troops with me without any negative penalties from being ship crew limit

reddit.com
u/MT2113 — 2 months ago