

Which eternity ring should i go with?
I need help deciding which of these eternity rings look best with my engagement ring? (Ignore the wedding band in pic 1)
I love both equally and both are within the same price range.
My main idea is that my engagement ring looks like a flower, so i wanted a floral/leaf-like eternity ring to compliment it and add to the look.
E-ring #1:
Pros: beautiful design, super sparkly and shiny.
Cons: a but bulky so not for everyday wear i think?
E-ring #2:
Pros: daintier design and fits well with the engagement ring without overpowering it.
Cons: the stones aren’t shiny and a bit dull (replacing the stones isn’t an option)
Which one would you choose? Or should i look for something else entirely?