[QCrit] The Ordinary Magic of Autumn in Eaves [adult cozy fantasy 80k words 1st attempt]

Hello! I’m hoping to get a feel for how my blurb reads. My manuscript is a cozy adult fantasy with a romantic sub plot. Thanks for the help!!!! 🤗

Dear [agent],

[book info and comp titles]

For three years, Autumn has run the only apothecary in Eaves, mostly treating the hangovers of her overindulgent townsfolk. It’s not glamorous. It’s certainly not lucrative. But after losing Gran, the apothecary is the only home she knows. Nothing ever happens in her sleepy town. No quests. No adventures. It’s the perfect place for a powerless witch such as herself to idle away every passing day. Or so she thought.

When a storm blows a rain-soaked ranger through her door, followed by a cursed shifter her magic can’t cure, Autumn’s quiet life is quiet no more. Suddenly she must travel to the elven kingdom, all while contending with a companion who answers every question in four words or fewer, a patient who might eat her if they dally, a bully horse who bleeds her dry of sugar cubes, and the sneaking suspicion that a long-dead magic might be returning to the continent—impossible as it may be.

The closer she gets to the elven land, and the maddening ranger by her side, the harder it is to ignore all the dark magic popping up around her. As fate would have it, Autumn isn’t the powerless witch she once believed. Accepting the truth might be the only cure to the strange curses sweeping the land. But Autumn knows that sometimes the hardest curses to break are the stories people believe about themselves. 

[bio and sign off]

reddit.com
u/Not_S0_Common — 1 day ago

Love and other Brews [cozy fantasy] [page one critique 278 word]

Hello fellow fantasy writers! I’m working on the first draft of my story. I have several chapters written but would like to hear someone’s thoughts on page one’s vibes. A few specific things I’m wondering about: Does the opening hook you? Cozies are a bit slower but I’m still trying to establish a conflict right away. Albeit a minor one lol. Does the character feel interesting? Does the voice come through? How’s the flow and all that jazz?

I’m open to suggestions for improvement.

The picture is long so if you’re on mobile you’ll have to click to see the whole thing. Thank you for reading! I appreciate the help!

u/Not_S0_Common — 27 days ago

[in progress] [2800] [cozy fantasy] first chapter thoughts

I’m looking for a beta reader for my first chapter only. I’d like to know thoughts about whether the opening scene and characters are engaging, does the tone fit a cozy vibe, is it too wordy or clunky, how is the atmosphere, and mostly: do you feel compelled to continue.

I’m available for first chapter swaps to provide the same feedback, but I can’t beta an entire project.

My story is a cozy fantasy with a romantic subplot. Please dm me if you’re interested. Thanks!

reddit.com
u/Not_S0_Common — 29 days ago

Thanks for welcoming me to heaven

Common here 🫡

Chicken wing enthuse. Flat superiority. Buffalo sauce girly.

Controversial opinion: boneless wings are nuggs

Noncontroversial opinion: nuggs are not boneless wings

Top sauces. Ready? Go!

reddit.com
u/Not_S0_Common — 2 months ago