Image 1 — “What if France annexed British North America?”
Image 2 — “What if France annexed British North America?”
▲ 1.9k r/BritishEmpire+1 crossposts

“What if France annexed British North America?”

In this timeline, France, through multiple military victories in the Seven Years' War, successfully captured British North America, and after the war ended, exchanged Hanover for sovereignty over British North America. New France would transform from a "fur-trading post empire" into a vast continental empire ruled by a French-speaking minority over an English-speaking majority. In the early period, the French crown retained the grassroots autonomy and agricultural economy of the former British colonies, but reclaimed sovereignty for the crown and established a governor-general to administer them uniformly; the area west of the Appalachian Mountains was designated as an Indigenous buffer zone and a French military-agricultural zone, with English settlers forbidden to cross. Economically, the French pursued mercantilism, monopolizing trade and restricting colonial industry, but the English-speaking population reached 1.5 million while the French-speaking population was only 70,000, a ratio of about 20:1, making assimilation and control extremely difficult. To change the demographic disadvantage, France relaxed religious restrictions, funded the immigration of veterans and farmers, and recognized mixed-race populations, but French immigration still could not catch up with the English-speaking population.

After 1760, English-speaking population growth and land demand continually eroded the western prohibition, while the unequal political status of English-speaking and French-speaking populations also triggered direct confrontation between the two sides. On the eastern seaboard, with support from Britain, multiple tax resistance movements, anti-French movements, and armed rebellions broke out. French financial and military pressure intensified, and eventually the New France colonial government compromised: the French king granted self-government to the English-speaking states, while also establishing joint development zones west of the Appalachian Mountains, thereby alleviating the conflict. The French seigneurial system was difficult to transplant into the English-speaking free-land tradition, and the West gradually formed a frontier society mixing French, English, and Indigenous peoples. As time passed, cultural blending and social change in the Americas would help promote the intellectual emancipation of the colony's French population, thereby making it an important bastion of the Enlightenment.

u/Ok-Phone3052 — 14 days ago

What if the Kingdom of Italy remained independent since 887?

In 887, the Carolingian Empire disintegrated, and Italian nobles proclaimed Adalbert I as King of Italy at Pavia, establishing the Lombard dynasty. In 951, King Otto I of Germany invaded Italy, triggering the Lombard Wars. The Italian nobles, in alliance with the Papacy and neighboring states, fought a bitter struggle against Germany for nearly a decade, ultimately defeating Otto and preventing Italy from being annexed by Germany, thereby securing Italy's independent sovereignty for the next thousand years.

Nevertheless, the fragmentation of Italian royal authority was inevitable. Due to the feudal system and partible inheritance, the internal feudal powers of Italy became increasingly divided over time, with an extraordinarily complex web of interlocking relationships. In the early 10th century, Italy had only four margraves—Piedmont, Verona, Lombardy, and Tuscany—but by the 12th century, that number had grown to thirty. Not only were there conflicts of interest among the feudal lords, but the Pope and the King also frequently clashed, plunging Italy into feudal strife.

In 1020, the King promulgated the Charter of Pavia. The King reached an agreement with the leading citizens, whereby the citizens would support the crown with finances and manpower in exchange for urban autonomy. This laid the foundation for the crown-burgher alliance, which was used to counter the feudal lords. At the same time, Norman mercenaries established footholds in southern Italy and continued to raid northward, eventually founding their own kingdom. The crown's initial policy of "using barbarians against barbarians" failed, and it came to regard them as a border threat but lacked the capacity to deal with the south.

In 1077, King Henry II came into fierce conflict with Pope Gregory VII over lay investiture. Henry II went in person to the Pope's residence to do penance, but afterwards, through political maneuvering and military pressure, he ultimately reached the Concordat of Viterbo with the Pope, securing the actual right to appoint bishops within the kingdom.

In 1183, after nearly a century of intermittent warfare, the Kingdom of Italy signed a peace treaty with the Holy Roman Empire, formally establishing the Alps as the border, with the Empire officially renouncing all claims of suzerainty over Italy.

In 1218, the Lombard dynasty died out. After a brief "interregnum," through a marriage alliance with the line of Countess Matilda of Tuscany, the Tuscan dynasty was established, and the center of royal power shifted south to Florence.

u/Ok-Phone3052 — 1 month ago

PAX SINITICA: HEAVEN SAVES THE SHUN

This is an alternate-history timeline in which the Great Shun Dynasty, founded by Li Zicheng, survives and ultimately becomes the last feudal dynasty of China.

In this parallel universe, the plague that historically struck Beijing never occurs. As a result, Ming forces are able to tie down much of the Qing military strength. Even so, Li Zicheng successfully compels the defenders of Beijing to surrender. At the same time, Wu Sangui submits to the Shun regime rather than cooperating with the Qing. Without Wu Sangui's assistance, the Qing are unable to rapidly enter China proper and are forced into a temporary stalemate with the Great Shun.

The Shun government then turns south to eliminate the remaining Ming loyalist forces and the regime established in Sichuan by Zhang Xianzhong. Zhang Xianzhong organizes a determined resistance against the advancing Shun armies, but in the end three of his adopted sons betray him and surrender to the Shun. Only one adopted son, Ai Nengqi, remains loyal. Following Zhang's death, Ai Nengqi leads the remnants of his forces to join the surviving Ming loyalists.

Although the remaining Ming forces attempt to resist the Shun advance, most are intimidated by the overwhelming strength of the Shun armies marching south and choose to surrender. The only force that continues fighting to the very end is Ai Nengqi's army. Nevertheless, after a prolonged struggle, it too is defeated by the Shun. By this point, the Great Shun has unified all territories within the Great Wall.

Having consolidated control over the Chinese heartland, the Shun Dynasty does not abandon its struggle against the Qing. A massive final campaign is launched in the northeast, culminating in a decisive battle in which the main Qing army is destroyed. Most of the Qing princes and senior nobles are killed during the conflict, effectively ending Qing resistance as a major political force.

Following its victory, the Great Shun assumes control over the Mongol tribes of Southern Mongolia that had previously been under Qing influence. At the same time, Shun forces successfully repel bands of Russian Cossack raiders who have begun penetrating into Manchuria. These victories secure the dynasty's northern frontier and establish the foundations for a powerful and expansive empire that will dominate East Asia for generations to come.

What destiny awaits the Great Shun, and where will its path ultimately lead?

u/Ok-Phone3052 — 4 months ago

What if India had not been completely colonized?

In 1798, on the eve of the Fourth Anglo-Mysore War, the envoys dispatched by Tipu Sultan successfully persuaded Baji Rao II and his principal sardars (Scindia, Holkar, and others), making them deeply aware that the British threat was existential and far greater than their internal conflicts. Shortly thereafter, Mysore and the Maratha Confederacy concluded a mutual defense treaty, effectively making the two states allies. The treaty stipulated that if either party was attacked by British forces, the other must launch diversionary attacks in its rear and sever its supply lines. During the Fourth Anglo-Mysore War, while the main British force advanced on Mysore, Maratha cavalry carried out large-scale raids on British-controlled areas in the Bombay Presidency and western Bengal, preventing the British from coordinating their front and rear. Although the British still held a technological advantage, they were unable to achieve a decisive victory. The war descended into a stalemate, imposing immense financial strain on the East India Company. In 1799, Britain signed a peace treaty with the Mysore-Maratha alliance, buying precious time for the Indian nations.

Meanwhile, Napoleon's campaign in Egypt drew the attention of both Britain and the Indian states, and Mysore and other Indian kingdoms began actively seeking French military assistance and technical advisors. After 1805, with the Napoleonic threat escalating in Europe, the British Parliament was unwilling to pour limitless resources into the "secondary theater" of India and was forced to halt its expansion there. In 1809, the Kingdom of Mysore supported the anti-British uprising in the Carnatic, triggering the First Carnatic War, which, however, ended inconclusively in less than a year.

During the Second Anglo-Maratha War (1803–1805), thanks to the Mysore-Maratha alliance, although British forces repeatedly defeated Maratha armies on the battlefield, they were never able to secure a decisive victory and even faced the constant risk of having their supply lines severed by Mysore forces. The Maratha and Sikh polities would more consciously socialize the war effort. Exploiting their home-ground advantage, they mobilized local armed forces and militias to conduct incessant harassment in British-occupied areas, turning the entire countryside into a quagmire for the British and greatly suppressing the effectiveness of British line infantry. Every step the British took forward came at a huge cost in maintaining local security. In the end, Britain signed a peace treaty with the Indian states, temporarily abandoning its plan to conquer the Indian subcontinent by force.

After the war with Britain ended, Maratha generals and foreign advisors alike realized that the Marathas' partial Westernization of their military had not proven a panacea for defeating the British. A European officer who had participated in the Peninsular War proposed that the Maratha Empire revive its earlier cavalry raiding tactics, and a more flexible hybrid military system was developed. Under the impetus of Maratha Peshwa Baji Rao II, the Maratha Empire undertook a large-scale Westernization movement and military reform, greatly enhancing the empire's military capabilities. Beyond this, Baji Rao II sought to leverage the prestige gained from the war victory to advance further policies, particularly strengthening central authority and weakening the power of regional families. This overreaching act immediately triggered direct conflict between the Maratha center (the Peshwa) and the powerful sardars. In 1826, the major sardars—Scindia (centered on Gwalior), Holkar (centered on Indore), and Bhonsle (centered on Nagpur)—once again united to oppose the Peshwa in order to defend their autonomy. Most members of these regional families had participated in or promoted the earlier Maratha military reforms as officers, and they mostly possessed their own private modern armies. Coupled with interference from Britain, Hyderabad, and the Sikh Empire, the Maratha Confederacy dissolved entirely into an extremely loose confederation. The Peshwa was reduced to a nominal "first among equals," powerless to organize any unified external action. The princely states of central India achieved de facto independence.

Meanwhile, under the leadership of Maharaja Ranjit Singh, the Sikh Empire in the north unified the Punjab and, leveraging the balance-of-power dynamics among the British, Marathas, and Mysore, along with its own formidable military strength, conquered much of the Gangetic Plain and became a major power in the northwest. During the Maratha civil war, the Sikh Empire supported the various factions resisting the Peshwa. After the civil war ended, the Sikh Empire stood as the most powerful indigenous state on the Indian subcontinent.

Amid the Great Game between Britain and Russia that emerged in the 19th century, the Sikh Empire established friendly relations with Russia and maintained its independence by maneuvering between Britain and Russia. In the mid-to-late 19th century, the Sikh Empire became the leader of the anti-British alliance on the Indian subcontinent, completely taking over the role previously held by the Marathas. Many of the Sikh Empire's military actions on the subcontinent had Russia's backing. In 1867, Britain, allied with Hyderabad, launched a final war against the Kingdom of Mysore but met with united resistance from various Indian nations. The war ultimately ended in failure in 1872, marking the final chapter of British expansion in India. By 1880, the Sikh Empire had annexed Oudh, Gwalior, and Jodhpur and frequently supported the anti-British wars of South Indian states. The Kingdom of Hyderabad initially was a British vassal, but after Britain's repeated military defeats and the eruption of its own succession crisis (with the anti-British prince gaining support from various Indian states), it gradually moved to break free from British control. During this period, wars between the major indigenous Indian kingdoms also continued unabated: the powerful Kingdom of Gwalior gradually declined under the combined pressure of Indore and the Sikhs; the Kingdom of Baroda fell into internal chaos after a popular anti-British uprising and was annexed by the Kingdom of Indore; Hyderabad was partitioned among the Marathas, the Kingdom of Nagpur, and the Kingdom of Mysore...

u/Ok-Phone3052 — 5 months ago
▲ 66 r/kaiserredux+2 crossposts

This map depicts an alternative timeline centered on a Central Powers victory in the Great War."

u/Ok-Phone3052 — 5 months ago