Image 1 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts
Image 2 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts
Image 3 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts
Image 4 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts
Image 5 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts
Image 6 — Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts

Suspicious $2.50 Liberty need some thoughts

I recently acquired this 1846-O $2.50 Liberty on eBay from an estate auctions house with over 50,000 sales on eBay.
I went to put it into an A18 airtite capsule which I store all of my $2.50 Liberty and Indian pieces in, however this one would not fit into the A18. I then noticed that the rim is flat and wider than my other Liberty pieces. The date is clear but the rest of the coin is pretty worn, and the head has some misshapen elements in my view.
It passed as 90% on my sigma, and the size looks about right. I think it’s gold but I think it’s also a fake, what do you guys think?

u/Optimal_Ad_4688 — 12 days ago