Please recommend me some games based on the reviews below. I am very picky so please dont mind my weird / horrendous takes.

TIER GAME STORY
Goated Kingdom Come Deliverance 1&2 Incredible story — both main and side quests kept me hooked.Deeply detailed and rewarding combat mechanics.I love how grounded the medieval realism feels.The trade and reputation systems were surprisingly satisfying.
Goated RDR2 Another masterpiece of storytelling — every quest felt meaningful.Combat isn’t revolutionary, but the Dead Eye mechanic is iconic.The 1899 setting and worldbuilding are phenomenal, especially the NPC interactions.
Goated Heavy Rain Short but rich narrative set in a modern timeline.I enjoy choice‑based games with investigative elements.Not a fan of dark horror or murder‑centric themes (not talking about this game, just and additional info)
Enjoyed GTA 5 (story) The main story isn’t the strongest, but it’s still entertaining.Loved the side quests and the “freaks and strangers” missions.Rockstar nailed vehicle physics and variety — driving in this game feels amazing.
Enjoyed Detroit Become Human I like choice‑driven narratives, though I rarely replay them.Tech‑futuristic setting isn't my thing.I personally prefer current‑era or historical themes over futuristic ones.
Meh Hitman WOA The story isn’t the main reason to play this game.It’s mainly about studying and following targets to execute creative kills.It does get repetitive after a while.
Meh Sleeping Dogs The story was decent.The fighting mechanics felt fresh at first, though nothing groundbreaking.Driving wasn’t particularly enjoyable.
Meh Fahrenheit (Indigo Prophecy) Similar to Heavy Rain — I liked the story except for the absurd, unrealistic ending.The QTE sequences were frustrating enough to make me quit once.
Didnt Like Batman Arkham Asylum Some games just pale in comparison to masterpieces like KCD and RDR2.I completed about half the game, but it didn’t keep me engaged.I’m not into dark, night‑themed settings.Combat felt dull, and the save system was annoying.
Didnt Like Witcher 1 I don’t enjoy zombie or monster‑based games — I prefer human‑focused stories.The narrative didn’t grab me (spent 30 hours, currently near the end of Chapter 2).The quests are boring (mostly, go there bring this, beat them type of quests)
Didnt Like Mass Effect 1 Played the Legendary Edition for about 45 hours.The story and quests didn’t interest me (dialogues felt very boring to me)I dislike tech‑heavy, futuristic settings.
Didnt Like Cyberpunk Again, not a fan of futuristic worlds.The pacing felt too fast — I prefer games that give me time to absorb and process things.I have no idea about story/quests because i didnt spend much time.
Didnt Like Vice City Started it for nostalgia, but the story didn’t hold up.Like Witcher 1, most side quests were simple “beat this guy” mafia‑style missions.

reddit.com
u/Over-Employment6960 — 1 day ago