Which setting looks best?
Need help choosing a setting for my 5 ct round brilliant 💍
After what feels like endless research, I’ve finally picked my diamond:
- 5.00 ct Round Brilliant (lab grown)
- E Color
- VVS1 Clarity
IGI Report: https://www.igi.org/verify-your-report/?r=LG\_792631924
The diamond will be price matched to the lowest price I’ve found ($1,141 from William & Sons), so now I’m just trying to decide which setting to pair it with.
Here are my top three (all prices below are the total cost, including the diamond):
1. Adiamor – $4,355
https://adiamor.com/your-setting?setting=R3138-Plat-Round&diamond=D-80328019
2. William & Sons Jewelers – Fiona – $2,501
https://www.williamandsonsjewelers.com/us/products/fiona-accent-diamond-engagement-setting
3. Rare Carat – Skyler Rolled Pavé – $4,774
https://www.rarecarat.com/setting/170-Skyler-Rolled-Pav%C3%A9-Engagement-Ring-SideStone/1835656?sp=/diamond-search
Since the stone is fairly large, I’m looking for something timeless, elegant, and secure that lets the diamond be the star. I’m planning on platinum.
A few questions:
- Which setting do you think complements a 5 ct round best?
- Is the Adiamor or Rare Carat setting worth paying roughly $1,850–2,300 more than the William & Sons setting?
- Does one look more durable than the others for everyday wear?
- Are there any red flags with any of these designs?
- If you own one of these settings (or something similar), how has it held up?
I’d also love to hear if you’d recommend a cathedral vs. non-cathedral setting for a stone this size, or if there are other settings I should consider.
Thanks in advance! I’ve stared at these for so long that I can’t tell which one I like best anymore. 😂