
What can Arthur accomplish here?
I know you can find the parrots here to check of the animal list. But what else should Arthur hunt for? Any items not found anywhere else? This chapter always feels rushed. At what point can you free roam?

I know you can find the parrots here to check of the animal list. But what else should Arthur hunt for? Any items not found anywhere else? This chapter always feels rushed. At what point can you free roam?
Mods keep taking down my posts. But this seems to be useful for players. Here it is until it gets scrubbed again.
I have always used Express ammo in my playthroughs thinking they are the best. But I'm starting to notice they kinda stink. Started using Split Point and find it to be vastly superior to all other ammo types. It's a pain to make them, but it seems to be worth it. At the end of the day, a head shot with regular ammo does the trick, but for messy gun fights, Split Point is king. It has both increased damage and accuracy.
What do you like about being naughty?
It glows, but you can't get to it. I tried dynamite. No luck. Anyone found other boxes like this? Anyway to get to them?
Before I get downvoted to oblivion, let me state for the record that Micah is a piece of sack of crap and I do not like him at all. This is just a discussion about the narrative.
I personally feel like it's not the best writing that Micah ends up being the one that was ratting out the gang to the Pinkertons. It's too obvious from the start that he is the uber bad guy snake that no one is going to like, to have him be the one that does them dirty.
I personally feel it would have been more dramatic if it was actually one of the other gang members that was the snitch. Someone like Strauss or even Molly. And poor Molly gets blasted by Grimshaw even though she wasn't the rat!
Does anyone else feel this way? Should one of the other gang members been the rat? Or is it fine that Micah is just a one note bad guy?
This thing is amazing. From blasting schools of ducks and geese to get fat and flight feathers, to killing rodents up to beavers, it's a machine. But why can't it kill a fox? You can headshot humans with an insta kill. But the goddamn foxes and coyotes shrug it of with a yelp. What gives???
Lillian Powell seems like a character that was meant for something more. A side quest to get her some cocaine at the very least. As it stands, she just kinda barks and serves no purpose other than flair.
How hard would it have been for R* to fix this monstrosity? It should be super easy to unequip. And at the very least, they could have had it facing the right direction. Still annoys me to this day. Same goes for the satchel. All of them are ugly. Why can't I just use my horse saddle bags?
So I was riding through Valentine when this woman comes out and starts yelling at me that I killed her husband. It prompted me to give her $2 so I did. She then storms off telling me to go to hell and that she never wants to see me again. Anyone else encountered this? Anyone know who she is? This was early chapter 3.
Does anyone actually still use this after chapter 2?
...But has to walk slow with this. Why Rockstar???
I don't understand unlocking this after you already have the Lancaster. It does a bit more damage but is slow and the range is terrible. The argument could be made that it is good for close combat. But I use the pump and semi shotguns for that.
Does the dialog change with the gang if you upgrade the cosmetics? Is it worth the effort? I've always upgraded everything so I have no frame of reference.
He's one of the only characters you can do anything to without a witness or bounty. Was this intentional?
Found this at the O'Driscoll hideout. Not sure why it's glowing. Probably just a lantern under it, but it's definitely strange. Any ideas?
This is the only sidearm I use. When I upgrade it, I keep it looking plain. I don't even get the longer barrel. It's just esthetically pleasing. And it's the only one that looks good in the holster. I know the other pistols have better stats, but it just doesn't feel right. Am I the only one who doesn't switch?
I personally can't stand chasing Magnifico. What are some other bad stranger missions?
I absolutely want to punch his face every time he wins a hand of poker.