Two postdoc offers and a potential industry offer. How should I navigate this?
I have been on the job market since the last semester of my PhD (around 7 months), I am now in a situation where I am not really sure how to navigate the next steps.
I have applied to many industry positions and postdocs. At the moment, I have two verbal postdoc offers, although neither is in writing yet. One is through my own PhD advisor, but honestly, I do not have much motivation to continue working there. The other is with a different group at my university, and that opportunity is more interesting to me. I have to make a decision sharp this week by Friday on which one i choose, and have to inform the other one.
The tricky part is that I have not told either postdoc group that I am also in discussions with the other. In both cases, I have given them the impression that I am planning to work with them, since at the time I was genuinely considering both options. I am now worried about what happens when I eventually choose one. Will the other PI take it badly? Could there be consequences, especially since both are within the same university?
Then there is the industry opportunity, which is honestly one of my dream jobs. I have gone through an onsite interview recently and today the recruiter asked about my availability to talk about the decision, so I am assuming this probably means an offer is coming, hopefully (i have another contact in the same company and he confirmed that he got the same email when was offered the position). However, I do not have a verbal or written offer yet (call with recruiter is scheduled for tomorrow). I also know that even if they tell me I am getting the job, it could still take some time before everything is official and I have something in writing. My biggest fear is that I turn down the postdoc options based on an expected industry offer, and then something happens during the process and I end up with nothing.
So right now I am basically sitting on two verbal postdoc offers and a potentially upcoming industry offer, but nothing is officially confirmed.
For people who have been in a similar situation, what would you recommend?
Would you wait until you have a written and signed industry offer before making any decision? And how would you handle the two postdoc PIs when you eventually have to tell one of them that you are going with the other?
I am especially interested in hearing from people who have dealt with multiple offers within the same university or moved from academia to industry. I want to handle this professionally without burning bridges, but I also do not want to make a decision based on something that is not guaranteed yet.