Does a tragic ending disqualify a story from Romance genre? What genre is it then?
I've been told that if a romance story ends tragically, not necessarily with a protagonist's death, as long as the two don't have a happily ever after, it's not romance. I feel sad about this, 'cause tragedies are memorable, conventional happy endings are forgettable. Think about Titanic, La La Land, If Only, Great Gatsby, various Nicholas Spark adaptations, just to name a few. They're really profound.
And I wonder if you guys have read any, other than the classics. It could be that one lover sacrificed for the other; one willingly left for the benefit of the other; one or both traded their relationship for career, duty or other callings.