So confused about my gender identity
Apologies that this may end up being a sort of long post but I feel so confused about would love any thoughts or experiences! I don’t know how to tell if I’m non-binary in any way.
I am AFAB and almost 30 yo now. I realized I was queer when I was 13 and had relationships with both girls and boys as a teenager. I was always seen as fairly “girly” because I would do my makeup every day and wear “feminine” clothing. But as long as I can remember, I did always hate clothing that was form fitting at all around my boobs or made them stand out more. Senior year when I was 18, I cut my hair short and went between very “girly” outfits and more androgynous outfits, and I felt super confident in more androgynous outfits. However, going into college, I let my hair grow out and presented very femme, which idk how much was just me wanting to vs performing for the male gaze (which I cared way too much about at the time).
Now I’m married to a straight, cis man (a leftist and very progressive) and have two kids with him. I’ve always just said I’m a bi woman, but I felt like I have never really had much time to think about or explore my identity until the past year when both my kids have been in school. I’ve been really uncomfortable in my body since my first was born because my boobs are several sizes bigger and I’m generally more curvy. I’ve half-joked for years with my husband that I wish I could get rid of my boobs and have more of a “boy” body. For the longest time, I’ve resorted to wearing sweatpants and sweatshirts almost all the time to feel like my body is more hidden and I just work from home.
This past year I’ve been having a lot of inner turmoil as well as some positive self discoveries. Although I really do not think I actually want to be a man, for a while I felt very upset that I was not born a gay man. And although I love my husband so much and do not want our relationship to change, I started wondering if I would be more comfortable in a relationship with a woman because I might be able to more easily express masc traits.
This year I told my husband I wanted to create a sort of shared wardrobe because we wear roughly the same size in clothes and I liked the looser fitting men’s styles. Now I LOVE that and feel so hot in that style lol I now describe my style as “a thong + big men’s pants”. But otherwise am pretty femme presenting. I also always thought that I wanted to be more of a “bottom” / submissive in bed and though it was fine, it always felt a bit uncomfortable or awkward. Recently I started trying out being more of a dom “top” and we both love it and I want to explore this further.
So now all of the thoughts that have been going on in my head… I feel fairly tied to the identity of being a woman and how amazing women are and that’s what I’ve known my whole life, but I feel confused by how much more confident I feel when leaning more androgynous in style. Although my husband and I are both very anti gender roles, I do feel like I end up inherently falling into them to some extent and have felt really good when feeling like I’m bringing out more of my masc energy. But I keep wondering, am I non binary or just a girl who doesn’t like wearing “girly” clothes? Am I non binary, or do I just want to push myself more against gender roles in my relationship? If I had ended up in a relationship with a woman, would I feel the need to even wonder if I was non binary and feel more confident in my queer identity and just leaning more masc as a woman?
Today I randomly asked my husband if he would still want to be with me if I were nonbinary. He said yes of course, that wouldn’t change anything and I’d support you. I told him I really really didn’t know if I was, but opened up some about these feelings, which obviously wasn’t a huge shock since I’ve been saying I want a “boy” body for a while and sharing his clothes lol. He then made a joke asking if that means more pegging, which is something I’ve half-jokingly said I wanted to do for most of our relationship but we never have.
I know at the end of the day, labels aren’t always needed as long as I’m doing what makes me happy, but I can’t stop thinking about it!