Is the mirarle of Guadalupe true?
Hi! I've been catholic for about 1 and a half years so far, with my ups and downs as normal. However, recently I dove into the history of Juan Diego and the related marian apparition, and I find all the supposed properties of the image of our Lady of Guadalupe to be messy, without reliable sources and plenty of disinformation. From baffling supernatural characteristics (pupil dilation, absence of decay, eye reflection, lack of brush strokes, unknown pigments, etc, etc etc.) to all being a hoax with totally opposing findings.
Everything is so confusing and I haven't found any official report of any sort. What is going on?
If the miracle ends up being falsified (therefore skeptic findings being true), wouldn't it severely undermine the credibility of the Church?